happened a couple of times in my old band
one time they txt me and asked if I could learn 'Uptown Girl' (Billy Joel)
I learnt the song and the BV's, get to rehearsal, drummer counts in 1,2,3,4 and we start - I look at guitarist, he looks at me, drummer looks confused and we stop.
I asked guitarist what key he is in and he said 'D'.... 'Ahhhh' I said - it should be in E.... Guitarist looks confused, then drummer gets out the laptop and plays the song.... the 'Westlife' version of the song - which is indeed in the key of 'D'.... turns out our Drummer didn't even know it was a Billy Joel song!
We never did rehearse or play that song
another time singer txt and asked if I could learn 'One Love' from Bob Marley but learn it down a key so drummer could sing it better.... I hated the song (still do actually) but learnt it in the key they wanted.... then get to rehearsal and find out that Drummer / singer have learnt 'Is This Love' from Bob Marley and me & guitarist had learnt 'One Love'!
We all had a good laugh about that one
