• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Everyone thinks bass is so easy

Here's the thing about bass - and drums too, actually - if you screw up even once, it can (in my opinion) affect the song MUCH more drastically than flubbing a note on the guitar.

I have been to more than one show where the guitar player(s) screwed up here and there, and it was no big deal to my ears (especially if it was the odd squelched note in a solo), and might have went completely unnoticed by audience members who weren't players...but when the bass player totally drops a note (and I speak from experience as a bass player who has dropped a note :D), WOW...again, same goes for a drummer, especially if he screws up on the kick.

Of course, everything is relative, and the context has to be considered: If there is a song that has a part that is dominated by the guitar - let's say bridging from one part to another where most, if not all, of the other instruments drop out for a few measures, as the guitarist strums a few complicated-ish chords, and he utterly mangles those chords - that is going to have a huge (negative) impact on the tune as well, and that guitarist, depending on how much of a professional/perfectionist he is will likely be cursing himself.

But in the overall picture of most songs, yeah, I barely notice the occasional minor mistake on guitar, but I cringe when the bass player or drummer screws up.

The debate about whether or not bass is "easier" than guitar, or whatever other instrument you want to put it up against, is probably one that will never be resolved. At the end of the day, it's not "easy" to play any instrument well, but it is exceedingly easy to play one poorly...and all that this "instrument X is much harder/easier to play than instrument Y" debate does is, at best, annoy people, and at worst causes people to not want to play with those people who keep bringing it up, or maybe even stop playing music altogether.

I mean seriously, can you imagine a professional like, say, Steve Vai, being in rehearsals with Billy Sheehan, or Phil Bynoe, and crapping all over them because they play the "easier" instrument? :meh:

One little anecdote before I get down off my soapbox :woot:: Several years ago, I was on the phone with one of my aunts...this woman doesn't have a musical bone in her body, but she was telling me how she had been visiting someone at the old folks home one week where a guitar/bass/singing duet were performing for the oldies. She said she was back again a week or two later, but this time the musical performance consisted of just the guitarist/singer, and she (my aunt, who again is not musical whatsoever) said something to the effect of "The music was just so empty with no bass player there..." :wideyed:
 
The idea that bass is easier than guitar for most people is absurd, barring some non-typical physical characteristics that make the longer scale and larger strings of a bass easier. Like if you’re, literally, a giant.

Playing technical solos or complex chord melodies on a standard guitar is way easier than trying to play the same thing an octave down (or not) on a bass guitar.

Since your average full-scale bass guitar is much harder to play,note for note, than a standard guitar, our expectations of virtuosity are different for each.

But what I think folks are focusing on when they’re saying ‘bass is easy’, are bass parts . That ain’t the bassist’s fault.
 
  • Like
Reactions: HubbardsFate
Is this the “Everyone” that you’re referring to?
A95E0D2B-1DA0-45C6-A0A5-2853CA20E05F.jpeg
 
(Zombie thread I know.)

I haven't had anyone say that to me recently but when they did I would just agree with them.

It is very difficult to argue with someone who agrees with you, it usually confuses the hell out of them and they walk off wondering if they won that one.

In reality I won because I didn't have to waste my time talking to them.

I've done this too, and I kind of regret not trying to set him straight, but as you say, it likely would have been a waste of time... besides, he was pretty loaded. I think a lot of folks say that since it is the prevailing 'wisdom', and they repeat it in order to try and sound knowledgeable about something they have no real insight into.
 
  • Like
Reactions: delta7fred
It is easier!

It's the instrument that a musical looser plays. It is an embarrassment to been seen playing one or even saying, "I play bass."

It's the instrument that when people come over to visit your home, they never ask you to play anything for them.

It's the instrument where for every 400 guitars sold, one bass is sold.

It's so easy to play that even your mom can play it.

NOT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
 
Full disclosure: I find playing bass much easier than playing guitar. My ceiling is higher on bass, if that makes any sense.

But I’m familiar with the viewpoints above. I get a lot of compliments on my guitars, which would be nice if they weren’t actually basses.
 
I started playing bass a little over four years ago after playing guitar for almost 50 years. I did so after a year of playing ukulele with a seniors group of about 50 people when the leader of the group asked if anyone would like to take up the bass to fill in our sound.

In the years I played rhythm guitar, I was often told I should play bass, that I had good feel and tempo, but I never wanted to be encumbered by a big electric bass, forget a stand up double bass. In contemplating the idea of playing bass for the uke group, I discovering and tried the sub-short scale basses available, 21 to 24 inch, they were so comfortable that I went for it.

In my case, I did find the transition to be fairly easy, certainly for my guitar experience, but as well, in my opinion, the small scale where the frets are closer together and lower string tension for both the poly ones and the short metal flatwounds I use. I took a few lessons from Denny Croy at McCabe's in Santa Monica (an excellent teacher), which helped considerably as well.
 
If I hadn't thought it was going to be easy, I would have never picked it up. I started playing purely out of necessity. One note at a time, what could go wrong?

Well, the easy stuff I started with was easy enough for an ex fiddle and uke player, but the nuances are many, and that is where most people need the most work, and that stuff is far from easy. Learning how to mute well was (and still is) perhaps the biggest challenge for me. I have a good ear, I can find the notes, but learning how to play them right will take a lifetime.

There are many skills I don't have and don't have any reason to acquire. I don't slap well. I have been known to fake-slap by popping a string here and there, but that's as close as it gets. I know that's a bit of a limitation in this day and age, but the people I play with don't seem to mind. I'm not technically fast, never will be, got too much inflammation in my hands due to autoimmune disease for that. But I do okay with what I have. The most important thing is being able to lock in tightly with a good drummer and zone into the groove. Is that easy? I don't know, but I do know that when I close my eyes and fall into that zone, it all seems to work.
 
I started playing bass out of necessity, as a 16 y.o. I didn't give any thought to how easy or difficult it might be.

When we were forming our school band every other kid seemed to play, or should I say own, a guitar. I recall there were about 8 wanting to join us. One kid had a drum kit but we had no bass player so I built a bass in woodwork class.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LBS-bass
It amuses me that people find out I play bass, and want to lecture me on how bass should be played, etc. Usually it's some variant on "the bass player should be obedient, invisible, and play no more than three notes." I usually respond with some variant of: "I play music that most people hate."
 
I play bass because of someone who was playing some complicated,aggresive stuff.
So that's my musical preference.

It can be as simple as a nursery rhyhme.
Or it can be quantum physics.

The attitude of "everyone"(whoever that is)who thinks that bass is easy,and it often is,is a"poker tell"
It shows what music they listen to.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: LBS-bass

Latest posts