• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Favorite "mistakes" in great recordings

Grand Funk Railroad - I want freedom. from the album survival. they actually started the song twice and kept the tape running between.
I Want Freedom (Remastered 2002) - YouTube
That is one of the best albums ever recorded. and not only because of Mel Schacher's bass playing. Although the bass is awesome on all of the songs. I like the version of gimme shelter from this album better than the Rolling stones. both Mark and Don have more interesting voices than Mick Jagger in my opinion.
but i am not objective... my first band was virtually a Grand funk, and iron butterfly cover band.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Hummergeist
The Sound of Silence thread got me thinking. I think music has suffered in the digital age, where the goal is technical perfection, as you can digitally alter everything, and you have virtually limitless tracks (which some people seem to think you have to fill them all.

What are some of your favorite recordings where there were "flaws" in fantastic songs? One of mine is the Abbey Road medley. In the last minute, the tuning changes almost half a step.
Can you elaborate on the medley part? I’ve listened to it a million times but haven’t noticed it I guess
 
Barry Oakley coming in a beat early on One Way Out was the first one that came to mind for me too. It is amazing how the band adjusted rather than had a train wreck.

In Elvis Costello's Watching the Detectives bassist Andrew Bodnar makes a booboo towards the end.

Sting's laugh at the beginning of Roxanne, occurred because he accidently sat on a piano keyboard.
 
  • Like
Reactions: equill
At around the start of the nah nah nah's in Hey Jude (jsut before) Someone (sounding to me like Eric Clapton, but I can't find any indication he was there) comes in early, someone else shrieks in surprise and John Lennon swears. If any one had picked this up at the time, the song would have been banned.

Similarly under 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 in the medley in Abbey Road side 2, Lennon again swears.

When the drummer drops the sticks in Louis Louie, the drummer lets out a swear word (in the first minute)

Strange brew was meant to be another track. That's cream

Someone mentioned Barbara Ann. In an early take, Carl Wilson tells Dean to 'sing on key, ....)
 
I’ve always loved it when recordings are released with a clam or a flub. It accents that the music is played by people and not pieced together as jigsaw puzzles. My favorite [recovered] clam is Albert King in the solo part of As the Years Go Passing By. He acknowledges it (“alright!”) without missing a thing.
 
Bottoms Up from Van Halen II - During the breakdown after the first guitar solo you can hear DLR laugh uncontrollably while Michael Anthony is solid with his vocals. But they went ahead with it anyways and it kind of signifies the fun aspect of the band at the time.

What's the Time (Hey Buddy) from Bow Wow Wow - Annabella forgets the words during the third verse. She laughs it off and just has fun.

Cheap Sunglasses from ZZ Top - The ending slows down but they don't seem to be together on it. It's very short but it always bothered me.
 
  • Like
Reactions: rollie 55
At about 4:05 or so in "Stealin" by Uriah Heep you can hear bassist Gary Thain miss the chord change from D down to C, just after David Byron sings "Rock n Roll allright" for the second time. Still my fave Heep tune and Thain is still one of my fave players.


Uriah Heep - Stealin - YouTube
 
  • Like
Reactions: rollie 55