Let me put it this way, I'm 80% sure it's flats on 100% of what they recorded with a bass.
Or let me put this another way, I'm 100% sure it's flats on 80% of what they recorded with a bass.
Ain't that the truth... like always.
I tried Fender 9050L flats on my Jazz with Fralin pickups before I chose to keep 9050Ms on it. For what it's worth, I'd characterize 9050 flats on my Jazz as keeping use of the VVT and the mixing of all three extremely relevant. I can go from a tubby dub bass tone to a somewhat bright grinding tone and the spectrum between with it. (e.g. Including that general-purpose Fender 34" scale bass tone that people who don't know struggle to discern as a P or a J.)
I briefly tried 9050 flats on a Nash PB but the combination didn't please me. IMO, they're in the flats for Jazz bass lane. It's connected with the relative openness and versatility of the Jazz bass sound.
Dunlop flats--if you get the G string to intonate properly--and Monel Rotosound Jazz 77 can suit a P or J, IMO.
I like the sound and feel of 45-105 or 50-110 Dunlop flats but they have some practical or mechanical issues I won't tolerate; they're so close but so far away from satisfactory to me.
GHS P flats and Labella DTB 760-series flats could probably work on a Jazz bass but IMO they best fit in the P bass lane.
Would you say that the 9050 are not suited to Pbasses in general? My 2008 Am.Std. Pbass with PV63 pickup sounds the sweetest so far with 9050M. Pyramid flats were also very sweet sweet but didn't have the bouncy tone of the 9050. They were also stiffer than the 9050. Haven't tried GHS flats.
