Enjoy the benefits of a premium membership!
Upgrade Account
-
TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
Fender Modern Player: Coronado or Starcaster?
- Thread starter iualum
- Start date
I voted Starcaster, just like the style more. Sweetwater has a black one with maple neck so beautiful that I vowed to not gaze upon it again as I have waaay too many basses already......
Of these two I've only played the guitar versions and the coronado was extremely unbalanced. The non-offset-body gave it 'body-dive'. Maybe it's different with the bass version though, because of the bigger neck.
So if that's taken care off, I'd go Coronado.
So if that's taken care off, I'd go Coronado.
I don't know as I've never heard one, but from all I've read, that's pretty much the reason the Coronado failed in the first place, in that most thought it had terrible tone.
Has the chance to play one and really liked it. Sounded and played great. Haven't had the chance to played either Fender but the weight is a deal breaker.
I like the natural models at Sweetwater...three to choose from with different grains.
Great store where you can see what you're getting before you buy.
Starcaster. The pickups are much hotter (which I prefer) than what is used on the Coronado, and I liked the tone better as well. I was also fortunate to find a light one (compared to the others I had tried) in the cherry sunburst finish (which was my first choice.)
Just looked, couldn't find a Starcaster bass at that weight... If it was that weight, it would have been an original. Very rare bass model.
Of the new crop, the only ones close to 8 lbs are the guitar models at 8 lb 3oz.
None of the current crop are neck divey because of the center block and short scale. Most of them weigh in at 9 lbs 10 oz, and it feels heavier than that because of the wiggy weight distribution (all in the center), though I will say the Starcaster guitar feels more "normal" than either the Starcaster or Coronado basses.
The Starcaster guitar is about the same weight as my Jack Casady bass. I got a nice 3" strap and installed some planet waves elliptical strap buttons to alleviate the slight neck dive the JC had.
At 9+ lbs for the Starcaster and 10+ lbs for the Coronado, I would suggest a 3" strap for the Fender basses as well.
Fender JP-90
Epi Bass Club #169 JC sig
Well, I don't think it sounds better than the original. I've played an original Coronado II, and it sounded better to me than the current reissue.
Tried the Jack Casady, brought the case because my Starcaster fit in it almost perfectly. Wish the case didn't have the manufacturer's name on it but oh well. I've replaced the strings that it came with with D'Addario Chromes and really like the sound. Unfortunately the bass spends too much time in its case but every time I get it out and play it I realize it's a keeper.
I've played both of these--and both guitar versions as well.
I like the Starcasters a lot--I tried an older Starcaster guitar before they re-introduced these, and have liked them since then.
I voted Starcaster--for reasons similar to ones above.
I prefer the feel and the playability of the Starcaster.
I also prefer the sound.
One issue I have with the Coronado (Both bass & guitar versions), is the pickguard blocks the view of the bridge pickup volume control.
Either the pickguard is too big or the control is poorly placed or both.
You can help by removing the pickguard (Which I would do if I had the Coronado), but it's still oddly placed.
Budget & other concerns right now mean I won't be buying either, but maybe one day I'll get one of them used, or I'll win one in a draw.
I like the Starcasters a lot--I tried an older Starcaster guitar before they re-introduced these, and have liked them since then.
I voted Starcaster--for reasons similar to ones above.
I prefer the feel and the playability of the Starcaster.
I also prefer the sound.
One issue I have with the Coronado (Both bass & guitar versions), is the pickguard blocks the view of the bridge pickup volume control.
Either the pickguard is too big or the control is poorly placed or both.
You can help by removing the pickguard (Which I would do if I had the Coronado), but it's still oddly placed.
Budget & other concerns right now mean I won't be buying either, but maybe one day I'll get one of them used, or I'll win one in a draw.
I voted for the Coronado, only because I had an original back in ‘69, identical to the photo. In truth, it was a challenge to hold and to play, and I never got it set up quite right. So I sold it. But it’s nice to vote for it for old times sake
.
