... discussion ... re the ... issue of achieving a satisfactory ... sound balance on the part of the band ... it's an area that needs more attention, ... During sound check, how do you judge the overall blend and balance of instruments and vocals? ... ... This is not a trivial question. And bass in particular is extremely susceptible to measurable fluctuations ... I'd be interested in hearing how some of our fellow TBers achieve a satisfactory balance between all instruments, including vocals and drums.
Whew! You said a mouthful, BO! I'll toss in my 2¢, if I've narrowed down to the crux of your post correctly.
A. I've never had to operate as "the soundman", so I don't have that perspective, at all. At most, I've turned knobs as directed by the PA owner/operator (also singer/guitarist) as he steps out in front of the band to hear the mix in some small bands. As such,
I concern myself only with my own sound to me during soundcheck and, more importantly,
during the gig (realizing that the addition of bodies to the room changes the room acoustics!).
2. Then my "strategy", if you will, is to
play with as low a bass volume as I can bear, then wait for either a request to turn up, or my own perceived need to turn up to suit my needs. In acoustic jams/gigs in boomy rooms, usually without drums, the requests to turn up come quickly and often! But I make very sure to not drown out the rhythm guitarist, but rather lock in with him to reinforce the rhythm for all to hear. In amplified bands, of course, I lock in with the drummer and only use my amp with enough volume for me to do that effectively. I leave it to the soundman to do what he must with my post EQ & post Master XLR Out for the FOH. Usually I must turn up on my own initiative in amplified bands to be abled to hear myself once the drummer gets warmed up, and the FOH invariably bleeds onto the stage. Expecting this,
I play louder for "official soundcheck" than I anticipate really needing! Then, I can turn down for, at least. the first set and sometimes the whole gig!
iii. Unfortunately, there are times when
I must use earplugs out of self defense! Sometimes I can still hear myself and the drummer OK. Other times this adds complexity to my strategy if I can't hear myself well, but don't want to add to the volume wars. I still concentrate on locking in with the drummer's rhythm, but I just go on faith that I'm playing OK. The whole band always blames the soundman when that happens. I've never experienced that in a rehearsal and I've never been implicated in these situations, AFAIK.
So, that's my take. I'd like to hear others' approach.
.