• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Flats on a jazz?

Who has done it and what was the result?

  • Never done it. Sounds like a stupid idea.

    Votes: 4 1.4%
  • Never done it. Doesn't sound very interesting.

    Votes: 15 5.4%
  • Never done it, but now I want to!

    Votes: 11 4.0%
  • Tried it and hated it.

    Votes: 14 5.1%
  • Tried it and it was okay.

    Votes: 59 21.4%
  • Tried it and loved it!!!

    Votes: 173 62.7%

  • Total voters
    276
I've got TI jazz flats on my not-really-a-jazz Jazz Bass Special fretless (80's MiJ fender PJ).

They're fine, but I've got rounds on my 70s reissue jazz.

The world offers a multitude if options for all tastes and preferences. 🤘
 
Anybody ever put flatwound strings on a Jazz bass?
I never had a choice.

First jazz bass I ever saw was strung with flats so I just took it as the norm, same went for the P-bass.

There was one music shop in town when I was young. Very traditional place, salesmen in suits, a lot of brass and woodwind, reams of sheet music.
One fateful day 3 electric guitars appeared in the main window, bookended by 2 electric basses. All had the same drab stained wood finish, all bore the shop's name and both the Jazz and P-bass had flats.

Come to think of it my very first bass, Audition semi hollow, had flatwound strings. Second bass, Kay from Taiwan, also had flats. I bucked the trend whn buying my first set of strings, those were Rotosound nylon tapes :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: BeyondFiredUp
I use flats on my fretlessJazz basses. I have La Bella Lo-Tensions on one and TI Jazz Flats on the other. Both have a good sound and feel.

However, I think the La Bellas have run their course. Next week I’m switching out the La Bellas and going TI flats totally. They seem to me to be a bit “brighter” for better choice of words.
 
D'addario flats on my jazz bass. They are super bright to begin with flats, they are know to be the "flats almost round bright" but they are breaking in after a bit, and I love em, I also have put some Fender Flats on and thought they were great. I much rather Flats on my jazz but also I am pretty much a jazz bass guy to begin with. Think they work great for all genres but especially older roots Reggae and such.
 
One school of thought is to use brighter sounding flats on a J; mine ruled the roost for a long time with Chromes.
But there's also the more thumping, old-school camp. I had a set of Pyramid Gold flats that had been driving me a little nuts on various P-basses. Just too dull! I went ahead and threw them on the J just to see what would happen, and I wound up loving it! Turns out a nice set of single coil pickups was what those strings were really needing all along. (I could say that about most strings.)
 
Used TI flats for years on my old 73 Jazz, sounded great


IMG_0799.jpeg
 
I mean, it IS one of the classic electric bass sounds after all. The "P must wear flats and the J must wear rounds" thing is only because when people started getting all slappawacka all the time, the J w rounds seemed a better candidate for that. That and Jaco.
But a J with flats is as classic a sound as a P w flats if you look at the history of recorded music.
 
Anybody ever put flatwound strings on a Jazz bass?

I have a Sire Marcus Miller V3P. But I don't really like it, because I play with a pick (yellow Tortex), and the single pickups have a very bright sound, even with the tone turned all the way down. I was going to get rid of it, but then I thought....what happens when you put flats on a jazz?


No offense, but this is a silly question. Jazz basses were developed using flatwounds. Rounds or any other kind of string variation didn't appear for about another 10 years.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LowendG
I hate flats on jazz basses because it nullifies everything that makes a jazz sound like a jazz. You can still hear the character of a p bass when you put flats on it, so I’d rather do that if I need flats. If you put flats on a jazz and turn the tone all the way down you might as well bring a cardboard box with you and hit it with your fist. It’s very light, sounds the same, and you don’t have to worry about where to put your fretting hand.
 
Get a new capacitor for your tone pot while you're at it. IIRC, the Sire V3P comes with a .022uf cap that doesn't roll off enough treble. Swap it for a .068uf and it'll mellow out plenty, especially with flats. Give the flatwound strings a few months to break in, too.