Enjoy the benefits of a premium membership!
Upgrade Account
-
TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
Flatwound: Fender or La Bella?
- Thread starter squire65
- Start date
I always wanted to try Fender flats. Rotosound flats are the only ones I've tried but I haven't had problems with any sets from Fender
J + Fender 9050 = Focused bottom with a bit of the J growl.
P + La Bella DTF = Classic thump with low-mid bark.
Those would be my personal choices.
P + La Bella DTF = Classic thump with low-mid bark.
Those would be my personal choices.
Flats have purcussive attack.
If you want Growl, you want roundwounds.
Flats Don't Growl. They Punch.
If you want Growl, you want roundwounds.
Flats Don't Growl. They Punch.
thats it exactly.
depends on what sort of music you like to play, if its more modern you should probably stick with rounds. I play old RnB, Rock n Roll from the 60's and 70's so the 10 year old Labellas on my Jazz bass fits the bill perfectly, they sound fantastic. If I want an edgier tone than I use a bass with RW's
depends on what sort of music you like to play, if its more modern you should probably stick with rounds. I play old RnB, Rock n Roll from the 60's and 70's so the 10 year old Labellas on my Jazz bass fits the bill perfectly, they sound fantastic. If I want an edgier tone than I use a bass with RW's
They also grab and fill out, enveloping you in a warm hug of deep throbbing bass. It's the sound of mountains making love.
I'm not personally familiar with Fender flats. Labellas on P is about as classic a P-bass tone as you can get.
They don't growl, they purr.
They don't growl, they purr.
Let me re-word my previous post to better describe the different flavors in the flatwound goodness.
J + Fender 9050 = Creamy milk chocolate with almonds.
P + La Bella DTF = Rich dark chocolate.
I guess my point is, if I were to have a J and a P with flats on both, I might as well have two different sets for tonal variety as not all flats are the same.
You have obviously never played the Fender flats. They growl. I played a single set for two years, until I decided to go with tapes after Fender discontinued my favorite set, the CL 45-60-80-105. The only thing that happened in that two years is the E string did end up being a little dark, so I replaced with an Ernie Ball 105, which also has a tad of growl to go with the punch.
Sorry, but no. Flats do not growl. At All. Never have. Never will. It is impossible for them to do so. Flats are good for many things, but growl is not one of them.
I wouldn't say the Fenders growl, more like honk, especially at first. Compared to my current set, they were harsh-sounding. They were nice, though.
Just go with the Labella 760fl's............you can thank me later.
I tried both with A P Bass - While I liked the Labellas more for the smoothness of the sound they didn't seem to cut as well as the Fenders did. The Fenders had more mids. Try the Fenders with a mute....
^^^What he said. I have both basses and currently use both the Fender and Labella as described. I have also used Chromes, GHS Precision and Thomastik flats.
I like the GHS Precision Flats as much as the Fender 9050, maybe a little bit more. My moods shift a bit y'know...
=JR=
Your mileage may vary. I stand by my opinion, and have concert footage. The problem is it is a single file, and I am old enough that I have never learned how to post sound clips.
