Alright these are the two basses i want cause the musicman is just too expensive for me so what are the good things about the Gibson Grabber and the Gibson G3?
Enjoy the benefits of a premium membership!
Upgrade Account
-
TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
G3 or Grabber?
- Thread starter xXxTWO FACExXx
- Start date
If you think a MM is too much money,Then you better get one with the word Epiphone on the h/stock.Gibson=Lotsa money.Too much,IMO.
Once upon a time,I had a Grabber.Heavey,punchy-sounding bass.I liked it.
Once upon a time,I had a Grabber.Heavey,punchy-sounding bass.I liked it.
I voted Grabber even though I have a G3 that I love. The G3 is a great sounding bass in its own right, but to me, it's really a one trick pony. It's a very very mid-heavy bass, like almost all mids, and it cuts through the mix like no other. It sounds a lot like a jazz bass without the bottom. If you're playing with a pick (or even if you aren't), you could probably get some real heavy tones from one if you EQ it right.
That said, I got the G3 because I was looking for a Grabber. I'm not saying I'm disappointed with it, I'm just saying that IMO people are looking for a G3 because of a Grabber, and they aren't exactly the same. How many bands do you know where the bass player is playing a grabber? How many for a G3? It's probably around 100:1. I can only come up with Dirnt, Entwistle, and Signs. And I only know the last two played one because of the the fly guitars website haha.
That said, I got the G3 because I was looking for a Grabber. I'm not saying I'm disappointed with it, I'm just saying that IMO people are looking for a G3 because of a Grabber, and they aren't exactly the same. How many bands do you know where the bass player is playing a grabber? How many for a G3? It's probably around 100:1. I can only come up with Dirnt, Entwistle, and Signs. And I only know the last two played one because of the the fly guitars website haha.
Save your money and get a used MM.
Just trying to save you a lot of time and money down the road for when you decide you don't like the G3 orGrabber and wish you'd bought the MM to start with.
Just trying to save you a lot of time and money down the road for when you decide you don't like the G3 orGrabber and wish you'd bought the MM to start with.
^ fine advice unless you have a Grabber and a G3 you can try out locally.
I loved my G3.Very Jazz bass like tonewise as coreyfyfe said.I'd still be playing it if the damn headstock wouldnt keep coming unglued........................
I loved my G3.Very Jazz bass like tonewise as coreyfyfe said.I'd still be playing it if the damn headstock wouldnt keep coming unglued........................
I had both Grabber and G3. I stand for Grabber after all. It's little different. Grabber didn't need to change to G3 and so on. Itself get great tone and punchy.
JUst going off of general opinions, it seems the Gibsons are kind of a niche bass. Those who love their GIbson (any model) really love em, but they are not overly popular in the bass community. I am not saying just go with the pack all the time, but there is probably a reason why that is. I'd get a ray. Every Gibson I have had experiences with has been quirky and kind of odd. SOme people love them despite or because of their quirks, but for a general purpose bass, I'd go ray all day. +1 on that being null and void if you can compare them all side by side first. YOu may be a Gibson guy and not know it, but like Rics, some people spend all the money and find out they just hate the things.
G-3 definately. More tonal variation than the Grabber. If you play with the relative pickup heights, you can change the tone a lot. The sliding Grabber pickup doesn't do a lot.
It's true Gibson basses have their fans and detractors... These basses are about as Fendery as Gibson get (i'm talking choice of woods and construction) and are worlds away from other Gibson bass output. My personal favourite of these basses was the Ripper, but with the set neck and humbuckers, it leans closer to Gibson tradition, and a darker sound.
Buy a G-3, and if you don't like it, flip it on ebay. You certainly won't lose any money doing that. (as long as you don't overpay), and you'll have no problems selling it either
It's true Gibson basses have their fans and detractors... These basses are about as Fendery as Gibson get (i'm talking choice of woods and construction) and are worlds away from other Gibson bass output. My personal favourite of these basses was the Ripper, but with the set neck and humbuckers, it leans closer to Gibson tradition, and a darker sound.
Buy a G-3, and if you don't like it, flip it on ebay. You certainly won't lose any money doing that. (as long as you don't overpay), and you'll have no problems selling it either
If you can get a G3 Grab it! I've had all 3 and the G3 is my preference, it has it's own sound and with the proper EQ it can mimic a lot of other basses. The trick is to drop the middle pick up down as far as possible, mine is mounted on the body.
i haven't had enough play time on a G3.. although, my Grabber *was* a G3 at one time, a previous owner changed the guard/electronics and it's a Grabber now..
i'm happy with my Grabber.. and i feel there is a bit of tonal change with the sliding pickup.. i suppose it depends on what your playing through, and how you have it strung up..
get what you can afford..
i'm happy with my Grabber.. and i feel there is a bit of tonal change with the sliding pickup.. i suppose it depends on what your playing through, and how you have it strung up..
get what you can afford..
Another vote for the G3. It's not everyday you find a 3 pickup bass, so that's interesting in itself, though I've heard you can't get every possible pickup combo with a stock G3.
the switch does neck/mid, all three, mid/bridge. I feel like the front and back positions are really weak so I pretty much only keep it on the middle position. Although, when I switch it to the mid/bridge setting and play close to the bridge it sounds a lot like the stevie wonder "superstition" tone.
best poll I've seen in a while. I went with the G3 just because it's got a bit more versatility. I've got a Grabber right now, but it doesn't get that much attention, just because IMO it's a bit too aggressive for most applications. However, If I was playing metal or heavy rock that's a completely different story altogether
