• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Genre defying artists

If it wasn’t for his patronage of the technology, we wouldn’t have multi-track recording, or at least it wouldn’t have developed in the way that it did. It’s a tale of twists and turns involving German wartime tech/disinformation, a US Army intelligence officer, Les Paul, and the Ampex company.
Now, that sounds like a tale and a half! 😮🤔
 
Your third band sounds like its in the vicinity of the ensemble known as “Rachel’s”, or perhaps Godspeed You! Black Emperor. Then there was the This Mortal Coil rabbit hole. Am I getting warm?
In instrumentation, perhaps, but stylistically not really.

The band used to incorporate a lot of elements of Indian classical music and often featured woodwinds as well as strings years before I joined. The current 7-piece is what the bandleader jokingly calls his “stripped-down, rock n’ roll version” of the band.

True to this thread, I have a hard time categorizing it. The band is called Church of Betty if you want to look us up. I’ve been onboard for a little over two years of its 30+ year history. We’re in the middle of recording our first record in over 10 years.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Michedelic
In instrumentation, perhaps, but stylistically not really.

The band used to incorporate a lot of elements of Indian classical music and often featured woodwinds as well as strings years before I joined. The current 7-piece is what the bandleader jokingly calls his “stripped-down, rock n’ roll version” of the band.

True to this thread, I have a hard time categorizing it. The band is called Church of Betty if you want to look us up. I’ve been onboard for a little over two years of its 30+ year history. We’re in the middle of recording our first record in over 10 years.
As in Page?😁 I’ll look it up.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lo-E
The original MP3 player WinAmp shaped the metadata used for describing digital music. Their list of genres, which became standardized in the MP3 ID3 format, included “blues”, “rock”, “jazz”… and “Primus”.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Drzejzi
In instrumentation, perhaps, but stylistically not really.

The band used to incorporate a lot of elements of Indian classical music and often featured woodwinds as well as strings years before I joined. The current 7-piece is what the bandleader jokingly calls his “stripped-down, rock n’ roll version” of the band.

True to this thread, I have a hard time categorizing it. The band is called Church of Betty if you want to look us up. I’ve been onboard for a little over two years of its 30+ year history. We’re in the middle of recording our first record in over 10 years.
I just did, and wow, that’s quite a musical mosaic. I’ve seen similar ensembles, even did sound for one once(Jai Uttal), but that’s pretty sprawling. It reminded me of this thing that Mohini Dey was involved in early on…


There is a small but somewhat related current outfit that I came by due to being interested in their bass player, Shahzad Ismaily…

The guitarist is the son of minimalist Terry Riley, Gyan. Shahzad works extensively with guitarist Marc Ribot. I’m always down for cross-pollination.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Lo-E and jerry
I just did, and wow, that’s quite a musical mosaic. I’ve seen similar ensembles, even did sound for one once(Jai Uttal), but that’s pretty sprawling. It reminded me of this thing that Mohini Dey was involved in early on…


There is a small but somewhat related current outfit that I came by due to being interested in their bass player, Shahzad Ismaily…

The guitarist is the son of minimalist Terry Riley, Gyan. Shahzad works extensively with guitarist Marc Ribot. I’m always down for cross-pollination.

The Arooj stuff is amazing, it takes me away! Very healing!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Michedelic
Minutemen def had their own sound. Big boys were adjacent, but also different. I think both occupied the tail end of when punk was much broader in scope. Reagan Youth, Butthole Surfers, X, MDC are a few more from that era that could easily be described as punk, but also clearly had lots more going on than the most generic and simplified definition of punk describes.
Totally, Meat Puppets too.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JMacBass65
Now, that sounds like a tale and a half! 😮🤔
Here’s part of the story…


Les was playing guitar for Bing, and Crosby gifted him the second machine off the assembly line.
 
Laurie Anderson.

And while we're playing the genre name game: I was talking with my stepson, who is also a bassist (and was 20 at the time, so our life experience is half a century apart) about "Metal" sub-genres - metal being a term coined AFTER I started playing bass. I believe it actually arose from the lyric "heavy metal thunder" from "Born To Be Wild" by Steppenwolf, which would arguably make them the first Metal band, but I digress. ANYWAY - I was asking him what the distinctions were between the sub-genres and he was very helpful, as, for him, these variations were obvious, being as they've always existed in his lifetime. After a bit I said something like "At least there's no such thing as 'Folk Metal'" to which he replied - "Yeah, that's actually a thing, too."! :eek: :roflmao:

BBB
 
Laurie Anderson.

And while we're playing the genre name game: I was talking with my stepson, who is also a bassist (and was 20 at the time, so our life experience is half a century apart) about "Metal" sub-genres - metal being a term coined AFTER I started playing bass. I believe it actually arose from the lyric "heavy metal thunder" from "Born To Be Wild" by Steppenwolf, which would arguably make them the first Metal band, but I digress. ANYWAY - I was asking him what the distinctions were between the sub-genres and he was very helpful, as, for him, these variations were obvious, being as they've always existed in his lifetime. After a bit I said something like "At least there's no such thing as 'Folk Metal'" to which he replied - "Yeah, that's actually a thing, too."! :eek: :roflmao:

BBB
Here ya go, dig in…

I’d say that Donovan’s “Hurdy Gurdy Man” with possibly(depending on who you ask)Jimmy Page on the fuzz guitar is the first folk metal song. But YMMV.

The term “heavy metal” was around before Mars Bonfire(AKA Dennis Edmonton, brother of Steppenwolf drummer Jerry Edmonton, but not a member himself)wrote the tune, coined by beat writer William Burroughs. Some scholarly types cite the Kinks’ “You Really Got Me” as the musical birth, but me personally, I would go back to the Paleolithic “Rumble”, by Link Wray. Stravinsky’s “Rite Of Spring” might be a contender.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Bar Band Bassman
Here ya go, dig in…

I’d say that Donovan’s “Hurdy Gurdy Man” with possibly(depending on who you ask)Jimmy Page on the fuzz guitar is the first folk metal song. But YMMV.

The term “heavy metal” was around before Mars Bonfire(AKA Dennis Edmonton, brother of Steppenwolf drummer Jerry Edmonton, but not a member himself)wrote the tune, coined by beat writer William Burroughs. Some scholarly types cite the Kinks’ “You Really Got Me” as the musical birth, but me personally, I would go back to the Paleolithic “Rumble”, by Link Wray.
Thanks! Not surprised Burroughs had a hand in it. Did he use it as a music reference? Of course, heavy metals are originally a group of elements on the periodic table.

BBB
 
Here ya go, dig in…

I’d say that Donovan’s “Hurdy Gurdy Man” with possibly(depending on who you ask)Jimmy Page on the fuzz guitar is the first folk metal song. But YMMV.

The term “heavy metal” was around before Mars Bonfire(AKA Dennis Edmonton, brother of Steppenwolf drummer Jerry Edmonton, but not a member himself)wrote the tune, coined by beat writer William Burroughs. Some scholarly types cite the Kinks’ “You Really Got Me” as the musical birth, but me personally, I would go back to the Paleolithic “Rumble”, by Link Wray. Stravinsky’s “Rite Of Spring” might be a contender.
Seeing/hearing Stravinsky’s “Rite Of Spring” from a full real orchestra is a must experience.