• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Genres on a violin bass

Sir Paul only chose the violin bass because he could flip it over and play it left handed.
That's often stated, but not true. McCartney ordered the bass from Steinway's music store to be made left-handed when he was playing a regular gig in Hamburg, Germany. Hofner made it quickly for him. The members of The Beatles were well acquainted with Hofner guitars, both John and George had one. Their bass player at the time was Stuart Sutcliff, and he played one of those big bodied ones like the Hofner President model, which was right handed. When it became clear that Stuart would not be continuing with band, McCartney ordered his 500/1 bass. It was what later was to be known as the "Cavern" model because they played at the Cavern, in Liverpool, with it about 300 times.
 

Attachments

Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: JRT64 and DJ Bebop
I played at an open blues jam once and the bassist following me had a Hofner Violin bass strung with flats. I was amazed at how good it sounded for blues. If you really want one then buy one and play it for a while and see how it fits in with your music. It sure worked well for Sir Paul and many other Pop/Rock bassists of the 60s. You can always sell it if it doesn't work out. Good luck.;)
 
The body shape has noting to do with a Hofner's limitations. That fact that it's hollow does.

If you want a little more versatility than a total hollow-body, the Contemporary line has a 4" wide center block running all the way down down inside. Less energy is absorbed moving the top, so you get more sustain without totally losing the Hofner vibe. My only bass is a HCT Cavern Club and it'll do a reasonable job on any music style except slap. The pickup in the same position as a P bass is really useful. And there's always the neck pickup solo for a convincing 60's sound. It was Dale Davis' sound on "Back to Black" that tipped the scales for me on a Hofner.
PXL_20211121_010102201.jpg
 
  • Like
Reactions: JRT64 and jafp
If you want a little more versatility than a total hollow-body, the Contemporary line has a 4" wide center block running all the way down down inside. Less energy is absorbed moving the top, so you get more sustain without totally losing the Hofner vibe. My only bass is a HCT Cavern Club and it'll do a reasonable job on any music style except slap. The pickup in the same position as a P bass is really useful. And there's always the neck pickup solo for a convincing 60's sound. It was Dale Davis' sound on "Back to Black" that tipped the scales for me on a Hofner.View attachment 4760147

And this thing has staple pickups. Talk about your throwbacks.
 
The bass in the Jazzanova vid is actually a Contemporary Club, which is something of a different animal than a traditional fully-hollow Hofner. See my post #52 above. A little more growl and sustain, a little less thump. Love the sound in that clip.