• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

"God's Not Dead"

o sorry this is about redbox not about God anyway redbox's release window has a jump on other home entertainment release dates--about a week or two revenue stream is still greatest at box office but studios took a major hit by dvd's & aren't exactly compensating by streaming or through-video online rental is prob best deal if you like to watch at home (see: itunes rentals) in the company of others for convenience & price
 
The infamous quote by Nietzsche that "God is dead" is nearly universally taken out of context these days.

Nietzsche wasn't an atheist, but a rather devout Christian. He was lamenting that God is dead in the hearts and minds of his countrymen.

Erm.... no. Nietzsche was no Christian, in any sense of the word. It's true that what he really meant by the phrase was that belief in God had faded and become irrelevant in society, but he wasn't lamenting it. He was saying that society was going to have to rethink its values in a post-religious world.

Haven't seen the movie in question, have definitely seen some awful ones - religiously preachy and non-religiously so. It's rather embarrassing to have someone in church lend you a DVD and say "oh, THIS one is different, it's so good," and it's... not. The only one I can think of off hand that actually succeeded was probably Chariots of Fire, and that was a long time ago.
 
  • Like
Reactions: zontar
On the depiction of academics: actually, it can happen. My wife had a writing teacher who was into shamanism, and when he found out she was a christian, singled her out. She had only just recently become a believer, was about 18 or 19 years old, and was constantly put on the spot as the class' token Christian to justify or defend anything and everything about the religion, and treated with contempt when she wasn't prepared to out-debate a 50-year-old PhD. Most academics are wise enough not to indulge in that kind of bullying, but you do get one every once in a while.
 
It had Kevin Sorbo in it. What else did you need to know.

The ads made it clear that it was a blatant attempt to perpetuate the false narrative in the US that somehow Christians are "under attack" by what they call academic elites. They've been playing this card since the days of the Roman Empire. There is a sect of Christians that feel like they have to be the underdog in some kind of struggle to give their belief system validation.


What? Ignore historical and current fact much? Didn't the Romans place Christians (and others) in the colosseum to face the lions as a means of entertainment? Also I think Christians in regions overtaken by ISIS might have a different perspective.

In the US, I think we are at a point where we tend to push our ideologies or lack of one on others and we feel entitled to not have to listen or see any dissenting opinions. Many many crap films are released each year on all types of subjects.
 
What? Ignore historical and current fact much? Didn't the Romans place Christians (and others) in the colosseum to face the lions as a means of entertainment? Also I think Christians in regions overtaken by ISIS might have a different perspective.

I didn't realize the movie is about getting eaten by lions and being beheaded by jihadists. That sounds much more exciting that the trailer suggests. It's odd, they usually put the exciting bits in the trailer, wonder why they didn't this time.
 
Gorn Captain. It is my understanding that we are not supposed to link to anything obscene in TB. That vid is full of obscenities. Children come on TB too you know.

I am not impressed by your lack of judgement. Where is your sense of social responsibility?

TB leadership: is this how you want the legacy of TB to proceed? Is this what you want children that visit TB clicking on?

I implore SOMEONE to delete that link.
 
Last edited:
Gorn Captain. It is my understanding that we are not supposed to link to anything obscene in TB. That vid is full of obscenities. Children come on TB too you know.

I am not impressed by your lack of judgement. Where is your sense of social responsibility?

TB leadership: is this how you want the legacy if TB to proceed? Is this what you want children that visit TB clicking on?

I implore SOMEONE to delete that link.
I removed it when someone else politely reminded me of the rules and suggested I remove it without questioning my sense of social responsibility.

Personally, I find the movie as it is more offensive than any profane language.
 
Haven't seen the movie in question, have definitely seen some awful ones - religiously preachy and non-religiously so. It's rather embarrassing to have someone in church lend you a DVD and say "oh, THIS one is different, it's so good," and it's... not. The only one I can think of off hand that actually succeeded was probably Chariots of Fire, and that was a long time ago.

I think that Amazing Grace is a good movie. It is about William Wilberforce and his struggle to end slavery in the British Empire. No popular theme song and no Kevin Sorbo but it does have Albert Finney playing John Newton.
 
If I was taking out student loans to pay for that class I'd be pretty upset at the class time being wasted on 2 people's personal agendas at the expense of 60-70 other paying students.

Also, if Kevin Sorbo is the biggest star in any film you should know better than to rent it.
Is Kevin Sorbo more of a star than Dean Cain? Personally, I liked "Lois and Clark" a lot better than "Hercules".
 
You are right about that. I know Christians in the industry who say the same thing. They are trying to make a difference. In the past a lot of the Christian movies have been made by amateurs with a minuscule budgets, Bad acting, cliche scripts etc. A lot of those movies "preach to the choir." If their intention is to spread the gospel they are not very effective.


That tends to be the case with most (not all) "agenda" movies, regardless of the subject. They don't sway anyone who doesn't already hold that opinion.

EDIT: and most of the time they tend to be bad. There are a few movies on various topics that I 100% agree with, but the movies regarding those topics were garbage.
 
Last edited:

Latest posts