• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Going on two years now and I can't even think about... [5 string content]

Apr 18, 2015
3,149
3,510
65
...going back to 4 string.

As the late George Burns would say (in another context); "I still remember how. I just don't remember why". And that's sort of how I feel about playing 4 string bass anymore.

Like others, when I first picked up a 5 string I felt like a fish out of water. My left hand was so confused. Perhaps I'm slow, but it took me a full 6 months to get to where I wasn't fumbling, a year I think, not to be in my head about 5 string. But here I am, approaching the two year mark and 5 string is home. I'll play my (one) 4 string occasionally as I did tonight. But now the 4 string feels odd, knowing that I could have that extra lower string, if only I'd put the 4 banger away and pick up any of my other basses.

As an extra, I've been fiddling with 6 string during the pandemic and got some relief of 3 outdoor summer performances where I did play my 6er for the first time at one of them. Going from 4 to 5 feels like it was more difficult than going from 5 to 6. I just needed to spend some quality time with the 6er, but it took only a week or two of practice to add the extra upper string. I supposed I'd have had a longer adaptation if I'd jumped from 4 to 6.

Anyway... I thought I'd share that for anyone contemplating making the jump to 5 string or might be hesitant to do it for some of the above reasons. All I can say is, if you've been thinking about it, now is the time. Why let a perfectly good pandemic go to waste?
 
I got my first 5 in 1997, an L2500 which I still have. I also had a '94 Stingray 4 at the time, had them both until 2012 when I sold the Stingray (I have been regretting the sale ever since, not because it was a 4, but because it was the first real bass I ever bought). I have since been playing 5's and have no inkling to go back to 4 - unless I can find my old Stingray again.
I tried my hand at 6 stringers, but they are not for me.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Giffro
I guess Im a freak, about 10 years ago I was intrigued about trying a 5 because I was also the singer in a band at the time and my range was around the D,E side of things. When I started playing a 5r for the first time it clicked right away. The scale extension was a revelation. Walking UP to E is so cool. Then i joined a country band and a lot of the songs we played are in D. Now it is second nature and when I play a 4 string I am reaching for the B that isn't there. I know everyone is different but I don't understand why you wouldn't want to play an instrument that isn't as versatile as a 5. I have seen players saying that they can tune down a E to D and so on, but why not have a B ready to go, and when tuning down one string for one or two songs ,that throws off muscle memory. If one has small hands, ok, but maybe it is just a matter of players using a 4 for so long that it just doesn't work, and I get that, but for me I can't ever see myself using a 4 again. I don't see me going to a 6 though because my style is to hold down the bottom, and I rarely go up on the G string.
A
 
...going back to 4 string.

As the late George Burns would say (in another context); "I still remember how. I just don't remember why". And that's sort of how I feel about playing 4 string bass anymore.

Like others, when I first picked up a 5 string I felt like a fish out of water. My left hand was so confused. Perhaps I'm slow, but it took me a full 6 months to get to where I wasn't fumbling, a year I think, not to be in my head about 5 string. But here I am, approaching the two year mark and 5 string is home. I'll play my (one) 4 string occasionally as I did tonight. But now the 4 string feels odd, knowing that I could have that extra lower string, if only I'd put the 4 banger away and pick up any of my other basses.

As an extra, I've been fiddling with 6 string during the pandemic and got some relief of 3 outdoor summer performances where I did play my 6er for the first time at one of them. Going from 4 to 5 feels like it was more difficult than going from 5 to 6. I just needed to spend some quality time with the 6er, but it took only a week or two of practice to add the extra upper string. I supposed I'd have had a longer adaptation if I'd jumped from 4 to 6.

Anyway... I thought I'd share that for anyone contemplating making the jump to 5 string or might be hesitant to do it for some of the above reasons. All I can say is, if you've been thinking about it, now is the time. Why let a perfectly good pandemic go to waste?
I just did.
IMG_20201027_111903593.jpg
 
I've been playin 5s since 91 or so. I heard a tune played with a Low B, had to have one, and have not looked back. Nor will I. A couple things come to mind as to why...

Each 5 string comes with a 4 string attached.

My hands do what I tell them. I like a Low B, they'll figure it out.

I was awkward on a 4 before I got used to it. I didn't go back to a 3 string bass. Heh.

A bit of smart alec. But, you see my point. 5 strings. 6 strings, 13 strings, don't work for some. For others they are a revelation. I like my B. And you'll have to pry it from my cold, dead hands.
 
About twenty years ago I returned to music after stepping away for a couple years. Had always been interested in fivers so took the opportunity. Took to it easier than anticipated. Lots of fun. Still love playing fours and can go back and forth easily. For me it's about what works for a given style or project. No rules, play what you want!!
 
Yup. Started on 4 in '94. Bought my first 5 string in '98 and haven't looked back. I will bust out my wife's P Bass every now and then as it does sound really good with flats... but it feels rather restrictive. The only thing on my radar is an extended scale 6 tuned F#-G.
 
I played 5's from about 1988 to 2007, then I went back to the 4. I play my own thing at home but in 30 years of working as a bassist, outside of pit work, I can count the number of songs that required a 5 on one hand, and it still wouldn't fill it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Passinwind
My 2nd bass was a 5, which I played for 10 years. I swapped some unused gear to a friend for a 4 string Geddy Jazz which I assumed I'd never play, and it ended up being my main bass for years. Since then I've owned one other 5, but 4 has just felt like home.

Sometimes when you are working within narrower limitations, you make better use of what's available - not true of everyone for sure. Just me.
 

Latest posts