• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Great music recorded on cheap instruments

ElectroVibe

Inactive
Mar 2, 2013
4,136
5,452
Is anyone aware of any great recordings done with cheap instruments?

I'm talking about clearly heard instruments on songs that have endured, and are held in regard as great moments in history of rock, pop, etc.

Music that sounds great when played through the finest sound system.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DJ Bebop
I wanted a Washburn AB-20 for years (still do) because of the tone I thought Allen Woody got out of one on a live acoustic version of Elizabeth Reed. Turns out it was something else . . . This interview is from the Vintage Guitar magazine website:

Was that the Washburn AB-20 on the acoustic version of “In Memory of Elizabeth Reed” on the An Evening with the Allman Brothers Band: Second Set album?

No, and there’s a funny story about the bass I used. I collect Hofner copies; the ****tier the better (chuckles). I was in Japan, and Warren and I had been guitar shopping. In the magazines over there, a store will print pictures of its entire inventory. I saw an Audition violin-shaped bass for sale for $125. Audition was the Woolworth/Woolco house brand. I contacted the store, and an employee brought it to the show. It had a brown vinyl gig bag, and it looked great and sounded great, so I bought it.

Later, we had to do a performance for a record association in California. Only four of us were at the meeting; Gregg, Dickie, Warren and me. I had my Washburn AB-20, and I’d brought along the Audition along as a spare and for looks, as well; I thought it would look good for a cozy, intimate acoustic show. I figured I’d better tune it up, so I did, and I started noodling around on it. Our sound man, Bud Snyder, was out in the mobile, and he came in and told me the sound of the Audition was perfect for what we were doing. So the “Liz Reed” acoustic thing on the last live album had a bass that was a $125 Hofner copy.
 
"Great music recorded on cheap instruments"

Define cheap.



Okay but far from the first that comes to mind.

Their label-mates, for some time, Sonic Youth were about 10 years ahead of Nirvana on that, and Cobain would tell you that if he were alive. And that's just talking label-mates, not everything else.

Minutemen - them guys definitely jammed econo.

Jamming econo is about getting the most for your money.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: PsyDocHill
Two issues with OP's question: There is no uniform definition of "cheap" and what you hear on the so-called recording might not have been played by the particular player in the band who's signature instrument is a "cheap" piece of c*#p. Studio cats abounded back in the day and fooled everyone except the producers and the studio cats.
 
  • Like
Reactions: pcake and Artman
The Police, especially the records before Ghost in the Machine.

I saw Sting on his "back to the bass" tour 10 or 12 years ago. He noodled more than usual on that 50s P bass of his between songs. It was fascinating to hear, but to my ears that bass sounds like garbage when you hear it alone. Sure sounds good in the tunes though.