• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Hofner-(not just Beatle Basses)-Group Part 2

I have a question regarding upgrading tuning machines on an ignition.

HCT tuners? Or go straight to Grover?

When I bought my first Hofner Club many years ago, the first thing I changed was the tuners. Those (terrible) little ones seemed made for guitars not basses. So, I changed the tuners to Schallers - there were not many choices in the 60's. Then, when I finally found a hard case for it, found that they were too wide to go in a hard case!

The case sat empty for many years, until I stopped to talk to the fine folks at Hipshot at the NAMM show. They agreed to make a custom set of tuners expressly for the Hofners. I have changed them on 2 Hofners so far. Pearl handles (as before) and short shafts so the bass will still fit in a hard case.

Here's the Schallers and the Hipshots on my German Club. A HUGE improvement!! Just contact Hipshot - they have made many of these sets now because of my interest. Many thanks to the great folks at Hipshot.
IMG_0004.JPG
IMG_0508.JPG
IMG_0509.JPG
IMG_0510.JPG
 
Last edited:
When I bought my first Hofner Club many years ago, the first thing I changed was the tuners. Those (terrible) little ones seemed made for guitars not basses. So, I changed the tuners to Schallers - there were not many choices in the 60's. Then, when I finally found a hard case for it, found that they were too wide to go in a hard case!

The case sat empty for many years, until I stopped to talk to the fine folks at Hipshot at the NAMM show. They agreed to make a custom set of tuners expressly for the Hofners. I have changed them on 2 Hofners so far. Pearl handles (as before) and short shafts so the bass will still fit in a hard case.

Here's the Schallers and the Hipshots on my German Club. A HUGE improvement!! Just contact Hipshot - they have made many of these sets now because of my interest. Many thanks to the great folks at Hipshot. View attachment 5142205 View attachment 5142206 View attachment 5142207 View attachment 5142208
That is quite excellent . I’m sure that they’re amazing
Although I don’t know the cost, I must admit that they look like they’re pretty expensive for my Chinese ignition bass. I suppose I’d have to ask them, but the USA bass machines are pretty expensive
I probably don’t want to spend that kind of money. The Grovers are $52.00 for a set and since they’re guitar tuners, you get an extra one of each side.
The HCTs are a little more $$ but supposedly drop right in.
 
That is quite excellent . I’m sure that they’re amazing
Although I don’t know the cost, I must admit that they look like they’re pretty expensive for my Chinese ignition bass. I suppose I’d have to ask them, but the USA bass machines are pretty expensive
I probably don’t want to spend that kind of money. The Grovers are $52.00 for a set and since they’re guitar tuners, you get an extra one of each side.
The HCTs are a little more $$ but supposedly drop right in.

I have never had any issues with the HCT tuners either. I did have to tighten up the buttons on one set once, and after that they function well.
 
I have a question regarding upgrading tuning machines on an ignition.

HCT tuners? Or go straight to Grover?
If you’re talking Grover sealed tuners, you have to ream out the peg holes. It’s an irreversible mod, and they’ll make your bass head-heavy.

Wilkinson 18:1 vintage tuners are smoother than the HCT tuners, less expensive, and they’re a drop-in replacement. The part number is in this thread if you do a search.

The only downside is chrome buttons instead of plastic.

If you want interchangeable plastic buttons, you have to get the Gotoh equivalent, which is expensive, and hard to find these days.
 
If you’re talking Grover sealed tuners, you have to ream out the peg holes. It’s an irreversible mod, and they’ll make your bass head-heavy.

Wilkinson 18:1 vintage tuners are smoother than the HCT tuners, less expensive, and they’re a drop-in replacement. The part number is in this thread if you do a search.

The only downside is chrome buttons instead of plastic.

If you want interchangeable plastic buttons, you have to get the Gotoh equivalent, which is expensive, and hard to find these days.
Appreciate the input Steve.
This is what I wound up ordering.
They are an upgraded tuning machine for the HCT. I was assured by Barry Clark music that these will be a big improvement.
Pics show the std. HCT tuner vs the new “upgrade “ tuners.
I’ll find out soon enough I guess.
IMG_1856.jpeg
IMG_1855.jpeg
IMG_1857.png
 
Last edited:
Yes - the Teacups are unusual and really attractive and ONLY Hofner! This is my C-series Club. They made a huge difference over the standard-looking knobs it came with. They even fee; better to use.

I re-wired it for Volume, Balance, Tone - a lot easier and more functional to use. The Rhythm/Solo switch is now a Mute, and the other switches 2 different tone caps.

upload_2023-8-2_9-40-31.png
 
My Black HCT 500/1 hasn't really grown on me since I bought it a few months ago. So I bought 2 Tea Cup knobs from Project Guitars here in the UK and it does, make a difference to the overall look of the bass I do think the bass looks better for it. Hofner (China) really should put these on as standard for the HCT models, a definite improvement.
View attachment 5145136 View attachment 5145137
Yeah, it’s like the way a car runs better after getting a carwash! My Contemp Club played so much better with the teacups! :)

It does look much nicer and it is actually easier to dial in volume with them. Playability and looks matter!

Hope you develop a bond with yours. I did! Now I want a German one. Maybe double cutaway?
 
Yeah, it’s like the way a car runs better after getting a carwash! My Contemp Club played so much better with the teacups! :)

It does look much nicer and it is actually easier to dial in volume with them. Playability and looks matter!

Hope you develop a bond with yours. I did! Now I want a German one. Maybe double cutaway?
You never know I'm going to do a little more tinkering with it nothing major, just a couple of little mods one being the machine heads.
It will always be a HCT and something that if it got knocked wouldn't worry me, the same could not be said for my original '64 500/1 I really love that bass. :D:thumbsup:
20230509_083111.jpg
 
Sadly I had to move my Hofner CT club bass on, lovely bass but tonally it doesn't fit what I am playing at the moment and I have way too limited space where I live to keep things that I dont use.

Even more sadly I found that despite using Labella low tension flats the truss rod was at its tightest with no room to tighten any more severely limiting string choice with flats to either Labella ltf or TI's, this did mean that someone was able to get an absolutely screaming deal on a Hofner club bass, maybe one day karma will repay me.
 
Sadly I had to move my Hofner CT club bass on, lovely bass but tonally it doesn't fit what I am playing at the moment and I have way too limited space where I live to keep things that I dont use.

Even more sadly I found that despite using Labella low tension flats the truss rod was at its tightest with no room to tighten any more severely limiting string choice with flats to either Labella ltf or TI's, this did mean that someone was able to get an absolutely screaming deal on a Hofner club bass, maybe one day karma will repay me.
 
I had a bass that had no more room to tighten the truss rod.
I took it to my favourite luthier. He made a shim to place before the truss nut. 10 minutes later, I had a fully adjustable truss.
That's great! A couple of small washers are all that is needed! I have done this a couple of times.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Doctor Intrepid