• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

How did we survive before digtal editing???

Pitch correction is actually completely undetectable if done properly. Putting an autotune plugin on a track in chromatic mode and letting it affect every single note is not the way.

If you're not dealing with a professional vocalist, or even sometimes when you are, no matter how many takes you ask them to do they will never sing the note in tune. You'll waste time and burn them out. Just manually correct that one bad note and no one will ever know. I've done pitch correction and had the vocalist not even know...

I'm sure that's exactly what Rascal Flatts' producer told their lead singer :D
 
  • Like
Reactions: JimmyM
The last time I recorded drums, I had ~20 tracks just for a 4 piece kit. I only used 7 or 8 for mixing. I had the inputs so it only cost about an hour of setup/teardown time, and didn't hurt anything. Just mute and hide them and its like they never existed. I'd rather have tracks I don't end up using than wish I had a track that I didn't take 5 minutes to set up.
I suppose, but dang, that's a lot of tracks to record a Ringo set! How could the drummer avoid hitting mics every 5 seconds? :D
 
  • Like
Reactions: DJ Bebop
Non-linear video editing was a positive gamechanger with no downside. You never see video editors longing for the days of tape-to-tape. :smug:

Like it was said in the Sound City documentary (and I'll paraphrase), ProTools too easily put recording tools in the hands of bozos who had no business having it... and the wonderful music industry has shown this ever since.

I imagine digital editing revolutionized video editing in much the same way it did music editing. It's still a fairly time-consuming process, but it's shorter now.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DJ Bebop and JimmyM
The last time I recorded drums, I had ~20 tracks just for a 4 piece kit. I only used 7 or 8 for mixing. I had the inputs so it only cost about an hour of setup/teardown time, and didn't hurt anything. Just mute and hide them and its like they never existed. I'd rather have tracks I don't end up using than wish I had a track that I didn't take 5 minutes to set up.
I mean... if you're not sure what sound you're going for, are working in a new room / with new (to you) gear, I guess. Otherwise, track it how it's supposed to sound is my m.o.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DJ Bebop and JimmyM
Non-linear video editing was a positive gamechanger with no downside. You never see video editors longing for the days of tape-to-tape. :smug:

Like it was said in the Sound City documentary (and I'll paraphrase), ProTools too easily put recording tools in the hands of bozos who had no business having it... and the wonderful music industry has shown this ever since.

NLE was around long before tape went away in video. The editors loved it, relative to stuff like EdiTec and other manual methods (especially when they had a tape operator to load all the tape for them ;) ).

CMX Systems - Wikipedia

The sight of 4-6 videotape machines plus an MM1000 and an AG440 cueing, syncing, and rolling up to an edit was something.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DJ Bebop
I suppose, but dang, that's a lot of tracks to record a Ringo set! How could the drummer avoid hitting mics every 5 seconds? :D

If he's hitting both sets of room mics and overheads there are lots of problems with his playing. He's not going to hit either kick drum mic, nor the bottom snare, and he'd have to try really hard to hit the hat mic. The triggers (for 808 sounds they insisted having as an option) are kept out of the way, so the only ones in the line of fire are the top snare and two tom mics.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JimmyM and DJ Bebop
If he's hitting both sets of room mics and overheads there are lots of problems with his playing. He's not going to hit either kick drum mic, nor the bottom snare, and he'd have to try really hard to hit the hat mic. The triggers (for 808 sounds they insisted having as an option) are kept out of the way, so the only ones in the line of fire are the top snare and two tom mics.
So you only had one mic per drum and not like 4 or 5 pointed at each? :D
 
  • Like
Reactions: DJ Bebop
So you only had one mic per drum and not like 4 or 5 pointed at each? :D
I only use three.
maxresdefault.jpg

:)
 
I've done audio tape/razor/tape editing with talking and stuff like that--but multi track music?
That would be tricky.

I got quite good at synching up the audio of a person speaking but never tried it with multi track music.

Digital is way easier.
& quicker.