Last month I bought a budget Acer Aspire 5517-5136 (
which isn't fast enough to record audio BTW) that came pre-loaded with Windows 7 Home Premium (larded with a glut of trial-ware).
For a while I dual-booted with Ubuntu 10.04 LTS to compare the two OSes and found that 10.04 runs faster, is MUCH more elegant, and of course doesn't have that OS-under-siege-by-malware feel.
I also found that Windows 7 exhibits a >~250ms audio latency between the '5517's mic input and its headphone out whereas Ubuntu 10.04 LTS has no audible latency at all.
Yesterday I reformatted the Acer's Windows executable and recovery partitions to a single ext 4 partition for use as a storage volume by Ubuntu.
For my uses Ubuntu 10.04 outclasses Windows 7 Home Premium to the point where dual-booting offers no discernible advantage.
My .02
--------
EDIT: It seems that this notebook IS fast enough for recording a few tracks via Audacity under both: the 32 bit and 64 bit versions of Ubuntu 10.04 LTS (I'm now dual-booting both versions for comparison).
The reason I thought the 5517-5136 wouldn't record audio is due to an intermittent problem with ALSA in dealing with the 5517-5136's SBx00 Azalia (Intel HDA) sound card (which uses a Realtek ALC272 chip).
After Googling about I found...
[ubuntu] No sound with hp 6735s, ATI SBx00 Azalia (Intel HDA)
...which offers a few configuration file tweaks applicable to Ubuntu 9.10 and...
Link Removed
...whose more complex initial approach culminated in this March 18th, 2010 post by Jimbopix:
"Another win in the column for this thread.
I think it was the gnome-alsamixer that solved it for me. Once that was installed I was able to select the Audigy Analog/Digital Output Jack from the list of check boxes and away went my sound.
Thanks so much for this post. The silence was making me go crazy, lol."
...which provided the apparent solution (install
gnome-alsamixer from either the Ubuntu Software Centre or Synaptic Package Manager) to the intermittent audio recording problems I was experiencing on the Acer Aspire 5517-5136 under 32 bit and 64 bit Ubuntu 10.04 LTS.
This being said the budget-priced, single-core 1.6 GHz AMD Athlon TF-20-equipped 5517-5136 is NOT a preferred option when choosing a notebook for recording audio (I was actually shopping for a netbook the day I bought mine).
There is a range of AMD Athlon™ 64 X2 Dual-Core variants of this notebook which might appeal to those on a very tight budget but generally a machine sporting a fast Intel Core 2 Duo processor with nVidia graphics etc would make a better entry-level audio recording notebook.
As a point of interest however, the 5517-5136's Radeon HD 3200 Graphics works well with the ATI/AMD proprietary FGLRX graphics driver (and its included ATI Catalyst Control Center software) available from Ubuntu 10.04's System-->Administration-->Hardware Drivers.
--------
EDIT #2: Audio recording capability is misbehaving again.
Oddly it seems to work fine when the 5517-5136 is connected to the Internet. More detective work is required...
--------
EDIT #3: I tried alsamixer (and Gnome Alsa Mixer) to make sure none of the audio inputs were muted and/or turned down yet I still can't record audio via my Acer Aspire 5517-5136's mic input unless I have either of my two USB-based wi-fi adaptors plugged into the '5517-5136 at boot time.
Said adaptors (which are both recognized by Ubuntu 10.04 BTW) are...
- a
Wi-Fire (which uses the zd1211rw module that is part of the Linux kernel version 2.6.24 or later), and...
- an
AirLink101 AWLL6080 300N Wireless USB Adapter (which uses a
Ralink chip).
I've since discovered that although either one of these adaptors needs to be plugged at boot time in order to enable audio recording, it is not necessary for them to be connected to the Internet.
This has me theorizing that the
bcmwl-kernel-source (which I had to install via System-->Administration-->Hardware Drivers to enable the 5517-5136's internal Broadcom BCM4312 wi-fi card) may be inhibiting audio recording somehow and that plugging in one of the other two USB-based wi-fi adaptors overrides this inhibition.
Uninstalling the
bcmwl-kernel-source is impractical because I need the convenience of the Acer's built-in wi-fi card for Internet access at local public libraries (which is why I bought a notebook), and because I have a hard time believing that a wi-fi kernel module could interfere with audio recording in the first place.
I'm hoping that others who own an Acer Aspire 5517-5136 (whose budget price, 4 GB RAM capacity, 15.6" display, and S1 socket make it popular notebook make & model for low-cost processor upgrades) will have some insight into this unit's odd audio recording behaviour.