• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

I feel he is underrated...

Odd... Maybe he's just not as known outside of the jazz world. I've always been aware of him, since I got his bass book in the 90's. I've recently started paying more attention to him as I get more into my six stringers. Amazing player. One of the best.
 
I have really been digging on his electric quartet stuff lately. Very well-recorded and excellent comping/soloing. They all just ooze good vibes, like they are really enjoying themselves…



Thanks for posting that :thumbsup:

I'm a Rock & Roll guy, and never heard of him before.

I can tell you he's not underrated anymore!

I watched this vid and then went to YouTube and searched "John Patitucci" and his name was first on the (Long!) list that popped up as soon as I finished the word "John".
 
  • Like
Reactions: Skillet
I have really been digging on his electric quartet stuff lately. Very well-recorded and excellent comping/soloing. They all just ooze good vibes, like they are really enjoying themselves…



Thanks for posting this. I will definitely be checking out their other stuff on YouTube. Did they do a studio or a live album together?

Edit: Nevermind. I found it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Thud Staff
This is only my opinion and is in no way intended to shade JP in any way but his upright playing is so incredible that I sometimes wonder why he bothers with slab bass at all.
 
By he, I mean John Patitucci. I see a lot of love for Palladino, Gary Willis, Victor, Marcus, etc... but not so much for JP. Everything I've heard and seen from him is off the charts. He is definitely not one dimensional, and blows my mind every time. I'm beginning the process of incorporating transcribing him into my practice routine. It has only been a catalyst to boost my admiration for him. Just curious, if anybody else has noticed this.

I’d go with less appreciated or less revered than some of his contemporaries by those that recognize players. I would agree that he is to some degree less revered or possibly less noticed than other bassists.

“Overrated” or “underrated” tends to evoke thoughts of some numbers like a pitcher or quarterback so the individuals cane be compared. That’s hardly an exact science in music / musicianship.

My initial thought is that Patitucci’s personality is fairly quiet and reserved which might contribute to him being overlooked by some. I think his playing speaks for itself when someone hears it and most would put him among those you listed as being a very gifted player.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bassGtar
By he, I mean John Patitucci. I see a lot of love for Palladino, Gary Willis, Victor, Marcus, etc... but not so much for JP. Everything I've heard and seen from him is off the charts. He is definitely not one dimensional, and blows my mind every time. I'm beginning the process of incorporating transcribing him into my practice routine. It has only been a catalyst to boost my admiration for him. Just curious, if anybody else has noticed this.

I think the issue for being a bit overlooked is similar to why more people don't like Jaco - a lot of people just aren't into the type of music John plays, despite being one of the modern stalwarts of the instrument. Others in that vein could include people like Brian Bromberg or Alain Caron.

Personally as a contemporary jazz guy (or, as my wife calls it, "the world's only non-ironic elevator music lover"), I like his stuff with David Benoit, Chuck Loeb (1999's "Listen" is one of my all-time favorite albums), and of course Lee Ritenour. But I'm not exactly listening to those albums because of Pattituci per se, rather I'm listening mainly for the headliner on the album proper. I haven't spun much of his solo stuff because, and I know this is blasphemy to some, I don't really like it when the bass guitar is the prominent instrument that carries the melody, and I know he brings in others to do that at times, but even then it can still be too much (lead) bass after a while.
 
Last edited:
Absolutely never thought Patitucci was considered to be underrated. He's played with HUGE artists, had a popular bass instructional video, and landed on the COVER of Bass Player Magazine. Pretty darn impressive if you ask me.

Whenever I see people say "underrated," I think what they mean to say is "overlooked," because if anything, JP is rated quite highly among people who know his work.
 
By he, I mean John Patitucci. I see a lot of love for Palladino, Gary Willis, Victor, Marcus, etc... but not so much for JP. Everything I've heard and seen from him is off the charts. He is definitely not one dimensional, and blows my mind every time. I'm beginning the process of incorporating transcribing him into my practice routine. It has only been a catalyst to boost my admiration for him. Just curious, if anybody else has noticed this.
line by line and the angel albums are outragoulsy good. the Rooot may be one of the top 100 all time greatest songs. The Root - YouTube
 
  • Like
Reactions: misterCRUSH
This is only my opinion and is in no way intended to shade JP in any way but his upright playing is so incredible that I sometimes wonder why he bothers with slab bass at all.
I sort of feel this sentiment as well although, I think the two are equally as fun and challenging in his mind if I had to bet. That being said, and maybe it's just me but, I feel like at certain points during his career he might have gotten a tad bored (for lack of a better word?) and he went exclusively upright for a while on most projects. Maybe it was to hone in on his upright skills more? Who knows, but I overall think he takes "breaks" from each way of playing bass from time to time.
 
  • Like
Reactions: misterCRUSH and REV