• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

I like hollowbodies but...

The back pad also fits in with Gretsch's fondness in the '50s and '60s for gimmickry in general. For example there's the weird Floating Sound Unit bridge, sometimes referred to as the Tuning Fork bridge, used on some late '60s and '70s Gretsch hollowbodies. Invalid Link Removed Or the built in string mufflers used on some models. A lot of this stuff came from the weird brain of guitarist Jimmie Webster, a Gretsch endorser and product demonstrator who released a method book for fretboard tapping several years before Eddie Van Halen was born.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ThuzzleFump
Having had a WF Bass, and a Vox Apollo, the pads on each serve their function. The WF pushes it's mojo over the top. The WF is one of the finest Basses I've ever had through the stable. The pad is embellishment. The Vox padded cover actually does cover the 9V battery cover, and access to electronics. I traded the WF for a V6, and still have the Vox.
Robin
 
What's up with those d*mn barstool covers they snap onto the backs of some of 'em? I mean, I guess it's supposed to be for comfort, but I don't want the back of my bass to look like 3 AM at a worn-out piano bar. I also can't imagine that it does much for the sound.

Should I learn to appreciate them, or simply wallow in my current horror?
I'd say you need to broaden your horizons hollow-body wise if you don't like those - because that's essentially a (vntage) Gretsch thing (yes there were copies in the 60s that did it too).
If you don't like weirdo GRetsch style appoinments - pretty much anyone elsemaking a hollow body will provide a bass that does not have that feature.
As far as sound - the rear of the bass is already being muffled by you and your clothes so the effect is nominal at most (and even less since the rear is a "reflector" not a "resonator".
Actually, ironically they were to protect the back from scratches - it was the 60s they covered everything in vinyl to protect it - they somehow didn't consider permanently installing coat snaps on the back as "damage" to the finish.
 
Huh. never seen (or noticed) these either. I own a Guild and it has none.

DSC04029.jpg
 
I think it is only fairly recently that manufacturers have chased the idiosyncratic weirdness out of semi-hollow designs. For example the Warwick Star bass looks a lot like a Rivoli/EB-2D style bass, but it sounds totally modern. Likewise Lakland have produced semi-hollow basses that have all the weirdness factor ironed out.

A lot of what is chalked up as 'semi-hollow tone' is really just shortscale/flats/weird-pickups-in-weird places tone in my opinion. If you built a 30'' scale length bass with strange mini-humbuckers located either right at the end of the neck or right down at the bridge, then strung it up with flats, it wouldn't matter if the body fore and aft of the central section is hollow or not. If you want a vintage semi-hollow bass then you have to accept the weirdness. I've played a Vox Wyman bass and the neck was like a snooker cue. I've played an old Guild M85 that had the 'suck' switch and the massive body... you just have to accept that that is how these instruments roll.

I own a semi-hollow at the moment, purely for window-dressing. It fits the aesthetics of the band and I've always wanted one. Nothing more complex than that! I don't think the soft pad on the back of old Gretsches and the like is anything to worry about.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ThuzzleFump
Gretsch.JPG

I have this (ignore those leftie guitars in the back, they're my dad's). When I bought mine it was in a sale for ~£550, retailing about £800 normally, I see they're going for over £1000 now post-Brexit vote. Anyways, great vintagey hollow Gretsch thump, no buckle protector thing. It came with insanely bright strings on it so I put flats on it, nowadays I prefer nickel rounds on it. What more do you want from a hollowbody bass? This thing sounds amazing, I only wish I had a decent tube amp to do it justice.
 
Can I ask - what is it about "hollow bodies" that you like so much?

A very valid question..
A hollow bodied Bass is, essentially a sound chamber. Sure, it has it's own agenda.. being a Bass, and that comes first. It also has the ability to resonate other sounds being created in the band. I feel the Bass vibrate when there a kick or snare hit during a sound check (when not playing). And when The whole band is playing, I feel everything, especially the Bass note attack!
MANY years ago, I was given some good advice about shopping for a Bass. NO AMP, play it and see if it resonates, especially on the low E.. good advise. I've started selling off the heard, not because any of them are bad Basses, I've just found the 5123B is MY Bass. Strangely, I purchased the first of the 5123B's on specs alone. I knew what I was getting with the second :-)
Robin