• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

inexpensive 5 string basses?

Sep 20, 2011
10,169
31,502
Los Angeleez
in 1993, the first bass i ever had to use regularly was a 36" 5 string with a neck so wide at the 12th that i HAD to play over under as my hand could reach scross it, and it weighed a metric ton. after that, i switched to 4 strings except for a very short period with a mikro 5 string.

but i'm realizing that some of the songs i like to play would really benefit from having a lower string rather than doing workarounds or tuning down.

my first thought was a mezzo 5 string, as i really like the neck on my mezzo 4. but there are a couple things - first, the 5 string mezzo has the same nut width as the 4 string, and while i love the 4 string version, i might love it less if the strings were crammed closer together. issue two is no one has one in stock.

it seems like ibanez is my best bet due to my issue with weight and my shoulder issue, which keeps me from reaching over a large lower bout without pain. the thing is, all the ones i'm considering have the same nut width as the 4 strings and as each other. maybe it'll be fine.

the only ones in stock that i can find are the GSR105 - i have 2 GSR100s, and i love 'em, but the shape/weight means limited playing time - and the GSR205, which has a finish i don't like, but i can live with that. the lightest one sweetwater has has a doable weight. if i kept it, i'd probably change the pickups.

i came very close to buying a GSR200 or SR300 five or six years ago, but ended up with a used SR500, which i've since sold. my shoulder problems have changed since then, and playing a bass for a few minutes at a store has never really let me know what playing it for real on my own chair or on a strap will be like for my shoulder.

i'm sort of asking for thoughts on the above basses, kind of musing it through. right now, my mezzo is my most comfortable bass to play, and it's become my go-to.

i have emailed our rep at sweetwater to ask if he has an approximate date when they'll have more 5 string mezzos or maybe some more 5 string SR305s in case there were some lighter ones than they have now.
 
in 1993, the first bass i ever had to use regularly was a 36" 5 string with a neck so wide at the 12th that i HAD to play over under as my hand could reach scross it, and it weighed a metric ton. after that, i switched to 4 strings except for a very short period with a mikro 5 string.

but i'm realizing that some of the songs i like to play would really benefit from having a lower string rather than doing workarounds or tuning down.

my first thought was a mezzo 5 string, as i really like the neck on my mezzo 4. but there are a couple things - first, the 5 string mezzo has the same nut width as the 4 string, and while i love the 4 string version, i might love it less if the strings were crammed closer together. issue two is no one has one in stock.

it seems like ibanez is my best bet due to my issue with weight and my shoulder issue, which keeps me from reaching over a large lower bout without pain. the thing is, all the ones i'm considering have the same nut width as the 4 strings and as each other. maybe it'll be fine.

the only ones in stock that i can find are the GSR105 - i have 2 GSR100s, and i love 'em, but the shape/weight means limited playing time - and the GSR205, which has a finish i don't like, but i can live with that. the lightest one sweetwater has has a doable weight. if i kept it, i'd probably change the pickups.

i came very close to buying a GSR200 or SR300 five or six years ago, but ended up with a used SR500, which i've since sold. my shoulder problems have changed since then, and playing a bass for a few minutes at a store has never really let me know what playing it for real on my own chair or on a strap will be like for my shoulder.

i'm sort of asking for thoughts on the above basses, kind of musing it through. right now, my mezzo is my most comfortable bass to play, and it's become my go-to.

i have emailed our rep at sweetwater to ask if he has an approximate date when they'll have more 5 string mezzos or maybe some more 5 string SR305s in case there were some lighter ones than they have now.
Do you have a budget? Are you only interested in new?

Ibanez SR is what immediately came to mind.

Maybe a Steinberger Spirit 5 would work.
 
Last edited:
Do you have a budget? Are you only interested in new?

Ibanez is what immediately came to mind.

budget is low. under $400 - i could stretch to $500 but it would have to be better than the cheaper ones. and part of better = lighter.

probably new, yes. since i haven't seen $600 to $700 5 strings better for my needs including weight, i can't see an advantage to getting a more expensive bass used instead of a new $400 bass.
 
  • Like
Reactions: EatS1stBassist
26522198[/URL], member: 202366"]in 1993, the first bass i ever had to use regularly was a 36" 5 string with a neck so wide at the 12th that i HAD to play over under as my hand could reach scross it, and it weighed a metric ton. after that, i switched to 4 strings except for a very short period with a mikro 5 string.

but i'm realizing that some of the songs i like to play would really benefit from having a lower string rather than doing workarounds or tuning down.

my first thought was a mezzo 5 string, as i really like the neck on my mezzo 4. but there are a couple things - first, the 5 string mezzo has the same nut width as the 4 string, and while i love the 4 string version, i might love it less if the strings were crammed closer together. issue two is no one has one in stock.
Are you sure about the nut width? According to the Ibanez website, the 4 string has a 38mm nut, while the 5 string is 45mm.
 
Are you sure about the nut width? According to the Ibanez website, the 4 string has a 38mm nut, while the 5 string is 45mm.

like an idiot, i was going by retailer info. shoulda checked ibanez. you're so right! (why don't we have a head bashing on a brick wall emoji?)

well, heck - all i need now is for someone to get one in stock.

Would the new Sire P5 work for you?

it's probably not for me. a lightweight bass with waist that doesn't push my arm over the lower bout, which can't be too protruding, are the most important things. i also prefer a slimmer neck at the nut with a 12 to 16" radius. thanks for suggesting it - it's always a good idea to know what's out there.
 
Ibanez SR is what immediately came to mind.
Ditto, but I'm a fan and own several.

Maybe a Steinberger Spirit 5 would work.
Agreed, but I'll step in early before anyone tells you because of the small body, first position is a reach. Well, it is, but a strap pin extender is common amongst wood Steinberger (and clone) owners and is cheap and easy, and can be tailored to fit you. There was a recent revival of an old thread on this but I can't find it. Just did. There are other threads too, and some in the Spirit thread, but I'm sure you'll get the gist.

There's also a SB string adaptor available soon; protos have been made and there are some small adjustments to the design before it's 100%.
 
  • Like
Reactions: pcake and sonojono
I ordered the mezzo 5 on a whim a while back. I really liked it. Matching headstock, 18mm spacing, I think it was under 8lbs, $350, what’s not to like? I thought the B was good even though it’s 32in scale. My daughter claimed it.

I’m predominantly using a sire v3 under 9lbs. Which was 440 but I think went up if you can find one. Checks all my boxes in a 5.
 
  • Like
Reactions: covermego and five7
First off, not endorsing or admonishing this seller, I don't know who it is, but hopefully is a good person...
This is just reference for a bass I once owned and was pretty pleased with:
Schecter Diamond Series Elite-5 Active 5-String Bass Cherry Sunburst | Reverb

Mine was red with rosewood board. Weighed 8.5 lbs. For the range of instrument that it is, very good quality.
String spacing is 16.5mm with a 16" radius. That spec is pretty widely used by Schecter. I had a Raiden 5 (passive) that was that spec as well.
Anyway, mine played pretty nice, and maybe it might work out for yo as well. If you go used, you should be able to land one for your budget.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Nuage420
Local Craigslist works well for me sometimes. Listed at $275, I drove 20 minutes to check this out and paid $240. Seller didn't know anything about it except he got it in a trade package deal and said it had one too many strings. I still don't know what it is, but it functions without any issues, sounds good to excellent, feels comfy, and weighs 8.72lbs. I've done nothing to it but change the strap buttons:

Orange 5st monboard 2-12 good jpg.jpg
 
in 1993, the first bass i ever had to use regularly was a 36" 5 string with a neck so wide at the 12th that i HAD to play over under as my hand could reach scross it, and it weighed a metric ton. after that, i switched to 4 strings except for a very short period with a mikro 5 string.

but i'm realizing that some of the songs i like to play would really benefit from having a lower string rather than doing workarounds or tuning down.

my first thought was a mezzo 5 string, as i really like the neck on my mezzo 4. but there are a couple things - first, the 5 string mezzo has the same nut width as the 4 string, and while i love the 4 string version, i might love it less if the strings were crammed closer together. issue two is no one has one in stock.

it seems like ibanez is my best bet due to my issue with weight and my shoulder issue, which keeps me from reaching over a large lower bout without pain. the thing is, all the ones i'm considering have the same nut width as the 4 strings and as each other. maybe it'll be fine.

the only ones in stock that i can find are the GSR105 - i have 2 GSR100s, and i love 'em, but the shape/weight means limited playing time - and the GSR205, which has a finish i don't like, but i can live with that. the lightest one sweetwater has has a doable weight. if i kept it, i'd probably change the pickups.

i came very close to buying a GSR200 or SR300 five or six years ago, but ended up with a used SR500, which i've since sold. my shoulder problems have changed since then, and playing a bass for a few minutes at a store has never really let me know what playing it for real on my own chair or on a strap will be like for my shoulder.

i'm sort of asking for thoughts on the above basses, kind of musing it through. right now, my mezzo is my most comfortable bass to play, and it's become my go-to.

i have emailed our rep at sweetwater to ask if he has an approximate date when they'll have more 5 string mezzos or maybe some more 5 string SR305s in case there were some lighter ones than they have now.

Just a quick thought, have you thought about another 4 string like what you already own tuned to BEAD? A couple of things from your past posts. One is that it took you a while to find a bass that didn't cause you pain and you were comfortable playing it. Secondly, a 5 string is bound to be heavier than a 4 string, and finally you will have the neck width to consider, not just at the nut, but further up the fret board.

Take care.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LowWay and pcake
Another vote for Ibanez. SR305 is $400 new, so there you go.

If you want other options, the Yamaha TRBX305 should be around $400–might be a little over but a very solid bass. Yamaha BB235 should be under $400, but maybe not the shape you’re looking for. The aforementioned Sire M2 would be good, but Sire has really hiked prices of late and I think that’s probably over $450 now.