• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Introducing Justin Meldal-Johnsen!

Hey Justin, Just stopped in to tell you I caught the NIN show in MA., on the 8th, at the Centrum.
Seriously impressive! I loved the big screens, makes for a great visual experience. I just couldn't see your hands too well. What great sounds though! You did a great job. I will venture to say you are the best syth bass player in the game!!!! I roadied for many years; I've been all over and heard alot of low enders but you kick a*s and made it look so easy!!!
Also please tell Trent he ruled too!

Now for my question:
I use a Line6 LD150. I love it but I'm thinking of ditching the Combo and stepping up with the PODxt, and a Ampeg SVT-3PRO and a SVT610HLF cab(found a great deal on these). Please tell me, how do you think the PODxt will sound with the old school tone of the Ampeg rig?
Peace Bro and keep rocking. You'll be getting input from me on a regular 'bassis' now that I found this spot. Thanks for a great show! Totally worth the wait.

Thanks for the high praise, man. Very nice of you. The 610 HLF is great. The PODxt is great. The only weak link in the chain, for me, is the 3PRO. Just not a lot of power with those. But perhaps it'll be plenty, I'm not sure what cirucumstances you're performing in. If that's the gear you already have, it should be great. POD XT will be great with the rig, but I'm not sure about cascading both preamps into eachother. You may want to use the poweramp in of the 3Pro and the POD XT as a front end. This is also a great question for the very savvy people in the amps forum, so you should probably post over there. I'm not really that all-knowing about gear, after all. :-)

Best,
JMJ
 
Thanks for the high praise, man. Very nice of you. The 610 HLF is great. The PODxt is great. The only weak link in the chain, for me, is the 3PRO. Just not a lot of power with those. But perhaps it'll be plenty, I'm not sure what cirucumstances you're performing in. If that's the gear you already have, it should be great. POD XT will be great with the rig, but I'm not sure about cascading both preamps into eachother. You may want to use the poweramp in of the 3Pro and the POD XT as a front end. This is also a great question for the very savvy people in the amps forum, so you should probably post over there. I'm not really that all-knowing about gear, after all. :-)
Yes you are...never steered me wrong, that's for sure!

HLF's need a good bit of power to kick them in the butt because of their extended low end (as a general rule, larger cabs that go deep aren't as loud as smaller cabs that don't), so even though a 3 Pro would probably be enough in average circumstances, I would probably pass on the 3 Pro and spend that money on a power amp with more beef and just use the Pod as a preamp. Then you'll have more power to kick the HLF.
 
Thanks for the high praise, man. Very nice of you. The 610 HLF is great. The PODxt is great. The only weak link in the chain, for me, is the 3PRO. Just not a lot of power with those. But perhaps it'll be plenty, I'm not sure what cirucumstances you're performing in. If that's the gear you already have, it should be great. POD XT will be great with the rig, but I'm not sure about cascading both preamps into eachother. You may want to use the poweramp in of the 3Pro and the POD XT as a front end. This is also a great question for the very savvy people in the amps forum, so you should probably post over there. I'm not really that all-knowing about gear, after all. :-)

Best,
JMJ
JimmyM said:
Yes you are...never steered me wrong, that's for sure!

HLF's need a good bit of power to kick them in the butt because of their extended low end (as a general rule, larger cabs that go deep aren't as loud as smaller cabs that don't), so even though a 3 Pro would probably be enough in average circumstances, I would probably pass on the 3 Pro and spend that money on a power amp with more beef and just use the Pod as a preamp. Then you'll have more power to kick the HLF.

Thanks for the great advice. I don't feel a need to go to the amp guys, with my question; the answers I need are right here!
Thanks to you Justin and Jimmy M!
I now have the decision of a bigger amp or a smaller cab.
I'll probably only be playing small to medium size clubs so I'm thinking I may just go with SVT 410HLF Classic and snap up this cheap deal on the 3PRO. Any clubs that have alot of air to fill I'll be running to the board anyway. I'm guessing the 3Pro and the 410 will be loud enough for my uses. Do you guys think I am pushing it or will this work ok with the PODxt up front?
Any ideas on a good DI box will also be a great help. I'm spoiled from that XLR out, on the LD150!
I'm now trying to get set up to do alot of industrial sounding snyth bass and I am honored for the chance to be learning from the master!! Thanks. You rock Justin.
 
As an after thought, I did'nt mean to sound like the other great areas of the forum are not helpful, Browsing around I see some great stuff.
Sorry If I'm being a pain in the a%s about gear. I just was hoping to get your opinion because, as I've I seen at line6.com, your the man with the knowledge concerning most things PODxt/Snyth.
Thanks again. Peace, Ty
 
I now have the decision of a bigger amp or a smaller cab.

not that this is the right forum for this (this is JMJ intro), but i thought i would chime in by adding a +1 to Jimmy's suggestion to skip the 3pro and get a bigger poweramp.
imo, the 610 sounds better than the cab than the 410, plus you can move a little more air if you have to... 410 or 610, pod w/ power amp is the way to go.
since you want to run the POD, the 3pro will act as a "tonesuck:" any sound you use with the POD would be effected by the 3pro... that pristine Alembic f2b tone, colored by 3pro; driving Hiwatt 200dr, colored by 3pro, etc. This is what JMJ meant when he questioned your cascading preamps- running one into another- it is unnecessary. you could run the pod in an FX loop, but that would be redundant... the 3pro tone can be replicated by the POD.
the 3pro can be a power amp exclusively by running from the POD to the Power Amp In on the back of the 3pro, but you will still may have power issues, and you wouldn't be using part of what you paid for.
if you sell the 3pro and buy a power amp, you'll have plenty of headroom (just in case), and won't sacrifice any tone. a word to the wise based on my mistakes- stay w/ a light (no more than 30 lbs) poweramp (qsc plx, stewart, etc).
 
Don't get me wrong about the 3 Pro, though...I used one for 5 years and really liked it. But the Pod XT will do everything the 3 Pro can do (IMHO), so while the thought of cascading preamps sounds cool, I think you'd have more to gain by adding power. OTOH, it does put out 450w at 4 ohms, so you should be able to put out a goodly amount of power. If you get a good deal on it, why not?
 
Just another day at the office. Great photo.
3017098980_0cb61e8d67.jpg
 
All kinds of stuff, not sure what you mean.

Well, I know alot of bassists use octave pedals, but the effect is so subtle, I can't really here it all that well. I know some bassists (Juan Alderete) just use the octave pedal to add more bass into the mix, whereas some use it more effect wise. So do you add the octave to another effect to make the effect sound lower, or do you use it to drop your bass down an octave or so? Really I'm just thinking what pedal I should get for christmas, and I don't have an octave, and was thinking of getting one. So I was just wondering if octave pedals are worth getting.

Happy Post-Thanksgiving (I assume you celebrate the holiday, being American),
Stickk
 
I use it for several things:

1) A lower-octave double that is about 80% the volume of the original signal
2) A subtle addition of octave effect for more bass
3) A mega freaked out sub-bass effect by turning off the direct signal. Add fuzz on the back-end to taste.

JMJ
 
Hi Justin, I just wanted to say how happy I was to be seated in Columbus,Ohio so that you were closest to me for the NIN show. Me and my buddy drove 6 hours from Buffalo to see Trent and company but I had the added bonus of getting to see you play with them(NIN being one of my all time favorites). It was cool to see you rock out so hard compared to some of your other musical outlets(Beck being one of my other favorites). I have been thinking about buying a new bass and have really been thinking about getting a Fender Jaguar,my second choice would be a Geddy Lee Jazz bass. What are your personal thoughts on these 2 basses? I play a wide variety of music,mainly rock and its many sub categories. I`m leaning towards the Jag but I respect your opinion and would like to hear what you have to say. One more thing,when rocking out that night in Ohio you tossed your white Gibson Les Paul(Jr?) and let it hit the floor. After things like this do you retire the instrument or see if its still usable? Just curious. Thanks for your time!
 
One more thing,when rocking out that night in Ohio you tossed your white Gibson Les Paul(Jr?) and let it hit the floor. After things like this do you retire the instrument or see if its still usable? Just curious. Thanks for your time!
From how highly Justin speaks of his tech, it sounds like the guy could reglue it if it broke and have it ready to go again the next night.
 
change, those are both great basses. you can't go wrong with either. play both and check the feel, the necks are very different. The Jag is great, just buy it.

Yeah, my guitars get fixed, and if there's a headstock break, for instance, it's usually ready to play on the 2nd night.

Best,
JMJ
 
I felt it was quite good, personally. A strong show with a rather reserved audience, which is seems like an oxymoron, but that's the way it is on the west coast sometimes.

JMJ
 
change, those are both great basses. you can't go wrong with either. play both and check the feel, the necks are very different. The Jag is great, just buy it.

Yeah, my guitars get fixed, and if there's a headstock break, for instance, it's usually ready to play on the 2nd night.

Best,
JMJ

Hey! Thanks for getting back to me! That`s super cool to get you`re input on gear! Thanks so much! I think I will go with the Jag! Your say really helps me a lot! Take it Easy and have a good one! "Ferris Bueller,you`re my hero." Screw that! Justin, you`re my Hero!
 
Thanks for the high praise, man. Very nice of you. The 610 HLF is great. The PODxt is great. The only weak link in the chain, for me, is the 3PRO. Just not a lot of power with those. But perhaps it'll be plenty, I'm not sure what cirucumstances you're performing in. If that's the gear you already have, it should be great. POD XT will be great with the rig, but I'm not sure about cascading both preamps into eachother. You may want to use the poweramp in of the 3Pro and the POD XT as a front end. This is also a great question for the very savvy people in the amps forum, so you should probably post over there. I'm not really that all-knowing about gear, after all. :-)

Best,
JMJ
Thanks JMJ, Jimmy M. and Thombo, for the help. Still had a couple of questions. Rather than do it here, I'll start a fresh post where it should be. Thanks again.
 
I saw this interview around, thought it was great but didn't know where to post, so I'll just put it here;

Q: Theres been a couple of line up changes in Nine Inch Nails in recent months, what happened?

A: We've had the relatively sudden departure of two of our band members. Josh Freese, our drummer of a very good long time, is leaving because he decided he is touring too much. So that wasnt terribly sudden but it was sudden enough, it was unexpected. Then Alessandro Cortini, who has also been in the fold for many years and played keyboards, guitars and was our sound design person, he decided that he wants to focus all his energies on his solo stuff, which is great for him but unfortunate for us. We were sad to see him go because he was a great asset and he was very flexible and interesting and very much leading edge. We have found a drummer. We auditioned a few people and we found a guy called Ilan Rubin from LostProphets. He is very young but he is a very heavy hitter and very dynamic - very Bonham-esque. So that rounded out the rhythm section of the band.

Q: What about a replacement for Alessandro?

A: What we came to relise is thet untimely, it was not superflous, but something that all three of us - myself Robin (Finck) and Trent - can all cover. Because there is alot of keyboard work in Nine Inch Nails that is all incidental and lies very much in the background and sometimes lies very much in the foreground. For those moments in the foreground, Trent thought it would be okay for him to play them. So you can expect to see him more on instruments than in the past. So basically what were doing is, and Australia was the inspiration for it, experimenting with a very different NIN live format - more raw, more rugger a little bit more alive. It a bit more guitaristic. With only four people onstage in terms of layout and lighting. We are going through that right now - all the possibilities on how to light it, how much more intimate it will be. It's a work in progress. We are also going to be playing somgs that hav'nt been heard for a while, songs that have been put on the backburner due to limitations of a very high value production value of the previous tour.

Q: So you are scaling back the production?

A: Having a big production is a blessing and a curse - its a blessing because you get to blow peoples minds beacause its spectacular with the gadgetry production, staging and whatnot. And on the otehr hand one could argue, and I'm not necessarily saying this is the case, that heavy production value and seperate positions onstage for everybody limits the fire in the material to some degree. So we are exploring ways of renderind older material as well and giving it a new edge so we can change the set list more often. We're working hard on the theoretical side of it right now, and come January we will be back in the studio figuring out how to do it all. There will be a whole new lighting design and Australia is where it will be unveiled.

Q: It sounds like alot of work.

A: It's alot of work; we all ahve to relearn 20 more Nine Inch Nails songs that haven't been played in a long time. We already know a good 70. There's that part, then theres adapting yourself physically to a new production strategy and that comes last - you have to be ready for it. One of the benefits of this 4-piece structure over the 5-peice is if the audience does call out songs we can play them without sending waves of panic through the lighting crew of whatever. The current show dosnt really lend itself to that and Trent finds it really restrictive. It's hard because he likes what we did cause its so dramatic and spectacular. It's difficult for me not to boast about it, technologically it's leading edge, but now it's a different path and it's still great. It's going to be different.