• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Introvert? Extrovert? Which vert are you???

In the 'Motivation: Why do we do it?' thread, a few fellow bass players described themselves as introverts... and it got me thinking.

In my daily life, I am largely an extrovert. I consider myself social and gregarious. However, onstage, I MUCH prefer the bass space; hanging in the back, laying down the groove, and supporting the band. Occasionally, I am asked to play lead guitar or sing. I'm happy to do it because I love music & performing. But I find it adds a little anxiety, as it puts me more 'out front'.

So my question is, is there an overall tendency for bassists to be more introverted and guitarists/singers to be more extroverted? (Notice I said 'tendency' because there are always exceptions).

How would you describe YOUR personality? Do you think your personality-type played a role in choosing your instrument?

I am an unabashed extrovert. As for bass, I have a job to do and that does not include “being the show”. My #1job is to make sure everything reconciles musically speaking. I’m way to busy mentally analyzing what everybody else is doing anticipating what they are going to do. I may give the appearance of being introverted on stage, as I’ve said, I have all the visual entertainment value of a potted plant, but there is no doubt, I’m an extrovert.
 
I’m a true introvert/extreme INTJ personality type. I’m very capable of being in the spotlight and playing the role of an extrovert quite effectively when it’s needed, but it takes a lot out of me and is never my preference. I like when people pay attention to the music I make, but I’d rather not have attention focused on me personally. I’d much rather help others stand out than stand out myself, but that probably isn’t a bad thing for a bass player.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Energy and moe.moe
Interesting topic.

Like many (most?) of us, I am an introvert by nature.

But I’ve noticed that, the older I get, and the more I interact with other people, many of whom are not as clever/smart/knowledgeable/charismatic/interesting as they think they are, the less I care what they think of me. Which means I’m getting gradually less self-conscious. Which means I’m gradually becoming an extrovert.

It feels a bit strange actually... :cool:
 
Les haricots sont pas sale.
no they are not
Interesting topic.

Like many (most?) of us, I am an introvert by nature.

But I’ve noticed that, the older I get, and the more I interact with other people, many of whom are not as clever/smart/knowledgeable/charismatic/interesting as they think they are, the less I care what they think of me. Which means I’m getting gradually less self-conscious. Which means I’m gradually becoming an extrovert.

It feels a bit strange actually... :cool:
I like the way you nuance.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ctmullins
Extrovert = gets energy from crowds
Introvert = gives energy to crowds

Most folks are truly one or the other. I love performing, hamming it up like the best of em. But soon afterwards I must get home and be by myself to recharge. I realized only about ten years ago that I’m introverted.

Solid description of the difference between the two personality types. Just because someome is one or the other doesn't mean that they can't act in and enjoy the other role, it just affects their batteries differently. I too am quite introverted, but it doesn't mean I can't perform or enjoy the extroverted aspects of my job, my band, or the other things that I do. But it does mean that doing so drains my batteries and I have to spend alone time to recharge them. I have learned my limits and take care of them.

It also doesn't mean that an extrovert can't enjoy solo experiences and perform them well. It just means that they get to a point where they have to spend time with a crowd to recharge their batteries.

Being an introvert didn't affect my decision to pick up the bass. At the gig I'm acting in the extrovert role regardless because I'm performing. And I love it. However, when it's over I'm ready to spend some significant time alone.
 
I once heard an interesting definition of introvert and extrovert from a psychologist friend (that seems to echo what others have posted). What she said was:
Extroverts feel recharged after being in a group of people or a social situation. Introverts feel drained after the same kinds of social interactions.
I'm an introvert, and have become more introverted over time. However I can "scan" like an extrovert and turn on gregariousness and social interaction. But I come away drained and very much in need of downtime afterward.
I should have figured it out early - as a teen one reason that I wanted to play music is that I could be cool at parties without having to talk to people... :D

On the other hand, I'm very, very comfortable speaking to crowds, presenting, teaching, public speaking, and talking from the stage.
 

Latest posts