• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Is my tone bad or is it just me?

Hopefully this is the right forum to post. Here goes..

Disclaimer: I started playing bass around a month ago, so I still very much suck at muting, dynamics, expression, you name it, so you're gonna hear that in the attached recordings, just so you know. Not to mention that whenever I attempt to record myself, I can barely pluck a clear note without messing up.

Anyway, I've been noticing that a lot of experienced players have this recognizable full, rich bass sound and I feel like mine sounds nothing alike. I feel like my tone sounds very muddy and muffled. However, as I said, my technique sucks and I have not yet developed an ear for a proper bass tone, so maybe the instrument is perfectly fine and it's all me.

I'm playing a Sire M2 (dual humbuckers), in passive mode, volume and tone all the way up, going directly into an audio interface, into a DAW. No effects, no processing except for Gate on input to minimize noise. Playing regular 2 finger plucking, not using a pick.

Below are two recordings, one from the neck pickup and the other from the bridge pickup all the way up. I played very simple open notes and some minor scale at the end to keep the focus on tone and not get bottle-necked by my skills.

Does the tone sound okay to you?
 

Attachments

Sounds just fine for a month in. Keep going, you’ll get a feel for dynamics and how to get certain sounds you hear in your head. Don’t go down the gear rabbit hole while you’re learning, that’s a great bass and plugging into a DAW you can run any bass amp simulators you want.

Does sound like you may be going a bit hard at the strings. Keep working it!
 
sounds great

I suggest not worrying about "your tone" for at least a year or two of study. worry about notes and rhythms instead.

Don't expect to sound like $10,000 worth of recording gear and expertise like your heroes. There will be no shortage of gear clamoring for your money, and no shortage of TBr's telling you what piece of kit you "need" to get "your tone". But until you have a gig It's a distraction.
 
Last edited:
Welcome to Talkbass,
Sounds okay. For now keep you eq at 12 o'clock for all the knobs. Tone should not be a thing you should focus on.
As for the muting as you play, play through the string and let your one finger rest on the open string so your next pluck will be cleaner. You left hand technique assuming you are a right handed player, is pretty consisted and even which is good as a person just starting out. Good luck with your bass journey. Remember we all started out like you. RTS
 
I feel like my tone sounds very muddy and muffled....
I'm playing a Sire M2 (dual humbuckers), in passive mode...going directly into an audio interface...
Below are two recordings, one from the neck pickup and the other from the bridge pickup all the way up...

Does the tone sound okay to you?
It does - I think you're off to a great start!

I will say, if you want the sound to be clearer, put your bass in active mode.
You don't even need to boost the bass or the treble - engaging the preamp will generally make the sound clearer.

Also, I think your files are mislabeled - the deeper sound is probably the neck pickup, and the twangier sound is the bridge pickup.

If you haven't already, find a good bass teacher and get your bass set up to play comfortably - those two actions will steer you away from bad habits that you'd be fighting for years.
 
If you stick with this, as a bass player, you will be chasing tone to some degree for the rest of your life.

You hear something you don't like, or seems off, nice. Good ear. Don't worry about it now. Most of it is in your hands, how you play. It will come...

Just keep playing!