• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Jazz Bass Vs Stingray

What bass should I get?

  • Fender Jazz...it's so versatile

    Votes: 200 44.9%
  • Stingray..it slaps really well and gets the funk out of my face

    Votes: 143 32.1%
  • Just play your precision and head back to the woodshed at once!

    Votes: 102 22.9%

  • Total voters
    445
Unfortunately not!

It sounds... it's a little hard to describe. The 'neck' pickup alone is a bit Precision like but less fat and sharper. Both pickups together have a very pronounced midrange 'honk' that I was not aiming for. Sometimes I've experimented with pickup positions, but usually just one pickup, not two. I though maybe it'll have some degree of 'Stingrayness' but with the coils farther apart... I could not predict the result. I went for it anyway before testing, as I could just revert to "Jazz" configuration by putting back the other scratchplate in 5 minutes. It is not a bad sound, but the mid 'honk' needs taming a bit. I roll off the passive tone control and we're in growly funk territory easily. I want to put a 3-band preamp on it to adjust the sound better, but I haven't yet decided which one. I also want to try wiring the coils in series, that might bring the low midrange up and balance the sound a bit better... but who knows?

The pickups are DiMarzio Area J.
As far as mid control, the 4 band Audere is great. I've got it in 3 basses, and I'm usually all about diversity as far as aftermarket equipment
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: mcnach
As far as mid control, the 4 band Audere is great. I've got it in 3 basses, and I'm usually all about diversity as far as aftermarket equipment

I tend to go for John East stuff myself. The red/purple bass on the top picture is going to have a U-Retro installed. I already have it, I just have to sit one day with it and make a battery cavity on the back for it. The mid-sweep control is fantastic.

For the cream one, I never wanted to invest much on it as it was more of an experiment bass, never going to be a bass I gig much (I think I've only played it live a handful of times when it was original: a Matt Freeman Precision). So I'll probably source some inexpensive preamp and see how it goes. I think I have in my drawer of parts a 3-band preamp I bought for something like $6 from AliExpress a while ago... The frequency points were right where I like them, so I'll have that one a go. If it's horrible I'll look at alternatives but I doubt I'll spend the $$$ a John East or Audere cost on this bass. To be honest, I'm tempted to go almost full circle installing the P-style pickguard and let it be a PJ. It's the "chameleon bass" it can be a PJ, a Jazz, or a... "JJ"? with very minimal effort. We'll see. When I don't have a lot of gigs I tend to get into this kind of projects, and then when I get busy they all get archived until winter again :)
 
E8814963-B4CF-4E8C-BBB9-0FF2C93A7FB8.jpeg
 
I'd say this has become a different debate with the introduction of the SR Special, which is arguably closer to a Jazz in tone than its predecessor.
Agreed. In 2nd gear/ position 2, you definitely get a great jazz bass tone.
This is one reason that I returned my Elite Jazz V in favor of the new Stingray5 Special . That one bass can do a P, J, Ray, and cop Gibson SG and Tbird like tones.
 
  • Like
Reactions: wmmj and HD007
Jazz Bass. The best sounding bass ever. So iconic. More versatile than P, more comfortable to play. Larry Graham, Marcus Miller, Jaco Pastorius, Bobby Vega... they all shaped modern bass image. JAZZ IS ALL THE WAY!!!
But if, for whatever reason, you need ray tone, get one of these:
jhj_189_all.jpg
 
I own a Jazz, Precision and a Stingray 5. There is some stuff that I do that Stingray is not ideal for but it still kinda works. For example, the Stingray could sound out of place if you were covering a roots rock or blues cover. You can do it on a Stingray but sounds more "correct" if played on a Precision bass. The Jazz is the most versatile for sure, but as was covered earlier the Stingray has a superb build quality and feels great to play. So I say buy a Jazz or Precision first and save up for a Stingray. Then buy the one you didn't buy earlier so you have all three!
 
Digging this thread back up because I can't decide which one I'd rather have. It doesn't really matter because I have both, and at this point I will likely always have both in my arsenal. Having played nothing but Stingrays for a while, I just purchased another Jazz bass and I love it. I didn't realize how much I appreciate having the tonal variety in one bass.

The Stingray really does feel more comfortable to play but that's totally subjective. I feel like I have to twist my wrist a bit too much when playing the jazz over the bridge pickup. Also it's just a larger instrument all together.

Starting to think maybe I should invest in a Sterling HH or HS for these reasons..
 
  • Like
Reactions: alanloomis1980
@brushfirewolf, have you tried the StingRay Special? I find it much more versatile than the traditional three-band Ray.

I have owned 2. Excellent instruments in every way, but I did not find them versatile (tone wise) at least not like a jazz.

The thing I love about the jazz is I'm perfectly content with the "P" sound I get from favoring the neck pickup, and also love the bridge favored with the tone rolled way back. The only issue I have with jazz basses would be the level of comfort while playing. They just feel big and, like I was saying above, I feel like my wrist gets bent in an awkward way while playing over the bridge pickup- I don't experience this with the stingray.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Pet Sounds

Latest posts