Anybody use these? Good for bass? I like vintage Jensen speakers, will these MOD speakers work good for bass? Sound good?
TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
Not by themselves, except at bedroom volume levels. They're guitar drivers.will these MOD speakers work good for bass? Sound good?
billfitzmaurice said:Not by themselves, except at bedroom volume levels. They're guitar drivers.
If I got four of them that are rated at 110 watts a piece do you think I could achieve better results?
Wattage ratings are meaningless. Output is limited by driver displacement. The displacement of the Mod 10-50 is 50cc. That's one-third that of a good bass ten. To get the low end output of a good 410 you'll need twelve Mod 10-50s.
Now you go and say that, all the TB kids will be cobbling together their 8x12 cabinets.

By the power handling being weak are we talking that they fart on yah when you turn it up too high? Or just don't get any louder
Not necessarily. Bass drivers tend to have around a 2:1 xlim to xmax ratio, because they have high xmax. Guitar drivers tend to have 4:1 or higher xlim to xmax ratios, because the xmax is so small. This means that guitar drivers can withstand a lot more overshoot, because they're intended to be driven into heavy clipping, bass drivers are not.if the xmax is low, the xlim will also be fairly low.
Both.By the power handling being weak are we talking that they fart on yah when you turn it up too high? Or just don't get any louder
Wouldn't porting a cab/tuning it help with the displaced volume? I mean, I wouldn't stick a bunch or holes in the cabinet; but a vent hole in the center of the 4 drivers might help. I'll experiment. I need the cab to be able to handle 250 watts from my head and the volume won't be dimed. Most likely around one or two volume. I never need to go louder.
4.5mmWhat's a good bass drivers Xmax?
Forget about watts. They do not define output. Speaker frequency response, sensitivity and displacement do.I need the cab to be able to handle 250 watts from my head and the volume won't be dimed
Bear in mind that lows aren't essential to a good bass sound, depending on context, but it will be a pretty guitary bass sound. Or if you have lots, it will be like using the old SVT cabs, squareback type.
Mr. Foxen said:Were you comparing 30 year old used speakers with new MOD ones?
Mod 10-50 fs is 109Hz, so right there you've got an octave lost with them. Even the C12Ns used by Fender and others (as in my '65 Bassman) have a 112Hz fs and 1mm xmax. Today we wouldn't consider them for a moment for electric bass.In case anyone is interested, here are the specs. I measured from a 1978 SVT square magnet Eminence speaker for comparison purposes:
Fs=59.37Hz
Were you comparing 30 year old used speakers with new MOD ones?