I got in the last thread shortly before it closed. Wrote (
here and
here) about my initial impressions trying a Monique Tardis through the effects returns of a few different amps in the very non-gig environment of my modest living room. There are all sorts of things I like about Monique but the top end to me seems to roll off a bit early -- at least in comparison to what I'm used to. I might feel different playing in a group setting. (Depending on the mix, I sometimes roll the tone back farther live than at home.)
I got some good feedback, including a comment from BurningSkies about how even the "power amp" section of bass amps is pretty "voiced" (as opposed to a dedicated power amp that's supposed to reproduce any of a variety of sources). This was news to me. Last night I again tried Monique through the effects returns of the Aguilar TH500, Markbass F500, and Genz GBE 1200 and, indeed, there were significant differences: The Aguilar was more relaxed/less bright than the Genz (the most open and, to me, least "voiced" sounding power section) and the Markbass was still unmistakably itself. In a previous post I noted that the effects return on the Aguilar and the master effects return on the Genz seem to bypass all front end EQ (gain and EQ controls have no effect) while this isn't true of the Markbass (gain has no effect, but EQ and filters do). With Monique in front, the F500 still retains much of its signature sound.
Dialing in highs at the F500 (the HI control is voiced audibly higher than Monique's) did make some difference and I imagine that the resulting tone, while not what I'd call airy, would be plenty bright and cutting for just about any live use but you can still hear that the top ends are voiced differently. In every other respect (and maybe with regard to the high end, too, depending on your preference), the F500 + Monique is a more attractive amp than the F500 without -- it's warmer, fuller, smoother, more organic sounding while remaining very, very quick and articulate -- but it's hardly a neutral platform through which to run Monique, if that's what you're looking for.
Running through the FET channel effects return on the Genz brings in the EQ section. Again, here you can add some grind/air, but the different voicing up top still makes itself felt. The sound also seemed thinner this way. Overall, I think I prefer the tone and simplicity of going through the MASTER return/power amp in and bypassing the EQ.
I don't mean to make this thread about these different heads, but if people are looking at using Monique in conjunction with a dedicated bass head they might find the above relevant.
Cheers, and happy Thanksgiving to all.
-Mark