• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Leaving the band

The thing about singing jumped out for me. Singing past a certain age is HARD and it requires a level of dedication few understand. We did a show a few months ago and I agreed to do a Gladys Knight song. I don't normally sing lead these days so getting into condition where I could sing Gladys and play Jamerson at the same time was not a walk in the park. It was a lot of work. After that was done, my voice was in great shape and I asked my band for a couple more lead songs; we added a few but they dropped them from the set list but still wanted to keep Gladys in. I said, nope. Not going through what I need to do to stay in shape to do that for just one song.

We ended up getting a request for it at our last show from someone who heard me sing it at that other show, so I did it, and I sang it poorly. Tonight someone who was there told me the song is "out of my range." It's not out of my range, you moron. It's a song I wasn't prepared to sing. I have plenty of range for it, obviously, or it wouldn't have sounded good at the previous show. But I wasn't physically conditioned for it at this more recent show. I wasn't planning to sing it. It's a hard freaking song. It was a hard song for me to sing when I was in my 20's and I'm almost 60 now.

So if you really enjoy singing, this is something you'll need to keep in mind as you age. You need to commit time and physical resources to keeping your singing core in shape. That means exercising all the musculature related to breathing and vocalizing, and doing that frequently.

If you don't enjoy singing, or your bands aren't giving you opportunities to sing, then it's up to you as to whether to do that extra work. For me, I'd rather not if there's no payback. I love singing, but I don't mind being a sideman, if that's where the work is.
 
The thing about singing jumped out for me. Singing past a certain age is HARD and it requires a level of dedication few understand. We did a show a few months ago and I agreed to do a Gladys Knight song. I don't normally sing lead these days so getting into condition where I could sing Gladys and play Jamerson at the same time was not a walk in the park. It was a lot of work. After that was done, my voice was in great shape and I asked my band for a couple more lead songs; we added a few but they dropped them from the set list but still wanted to keep Gladys in. I said, nope. Not going through what I need to do to stay in shape to do that for just one song.

We ended up getting a request for it at our last show from someone who heard me sing it at that other show, so I did it, and I sang it poorly. Tonight someone who was there told me the song is "out of my range." It's not out of my range, you moron. It's a song I wasn't prepared to sing. I have plenty of range for it, obviously, or it wouldn't have sounded good at the previous show. But I wasn't physically conditioned for it at this more recent show. I wasn't planning to sing it. It's a hard freaking song. It was a hard song for me to sing when I was in my 20's and I'm almost 60 now.

So if you really enjoy singing, this is something you'll need to keep in mind as you age. You need to commit time and physical resources to keeping your singing core in shape. That means exercising all the musculature related to breathing and vocalizing, and doing that frequently.

If you don't enjoy singing, or your bands aren't giving you opportunities to sing, then it's up to you as to whether to do that extra work. For me, I'd rather not if there's no payback. I love singing, but I don't mind being a sideman, if that's where the work is.

I’ll bet I can count the number of bass players who can play Jamerson’s lines while singing a Gladys Knight song on one hand.
 
The only reason I can think of to join a band is for the eventual fun of quitting.

Some day I'll figure out if you are here to just insert sarcasm as "one of the guys" or just to troll and mock people.

Not being vindictive, just want to know. If I'm missing the sarcasm than my fault for not getting it but I just don't get the "fun of quitting is the reason to join a band?"
 
Some day I'll figure out if you are here to just insert sarcasm as "one of the guys" or just to troll and mock people.

Not being vindictive, just want to know. If I'm missing the sarcasm than my fault for not getting it but I just don't get the "fun of quitting is the reason to join a band?"

It won't be today, apparently.

Not mocking anyone; not trolling; not being sarcastic. Just posting on a bass forum. Certainly not "one of the guys."

Let's just say I've done my time in bands. I'm not saying I will never be in one again, but it's telling that my favorite memories of some bands are the day I quit.

I like to be "that other voice."
 
Yeah - when its time to move on, it's time. Had a love/hate with my last band. Played with them off and on for over a decade. Nothing real serious, but would get real frustrated with one of the members. What kept it alive as long as it was, was our taking at least a month or so off over the summer. No rehearsals or anything. After the time off, it felt better and we were all anxious to play again. But when an chance came up to work with a band that I was a real fan of, there was no question about making the move.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jimmy4string
With this type of a situation I have pretty much lived by the though of when it becomes un-fun and more of a chore then it's time to move on and/or take a break. No sense staying with something if you're not happy.
 
I am letting my band no today that I am just not into it anymore. It was a fun 4 years as we started as a CL project in a warehouse. Over time for a variety of reasons i have become less "Hell yeah" and more "maybe". The usual deal -noone responding to texts, dressing down for shows, etc. Also my vocals (that were not always the best) are getting degraded with age. When i think of rehearsal latley it just doesnt spark joy :)
Anyway -i told the guys I am leaving up the FB page in case someone wants to contact us for a gig. However, I am not pursuing any. Also they can get another singer if they like -no hurt feelings.
Anyway -I may pursue country music in the coming year. That may be a new adventure with it's own pitfalls.View attachment 3293327 View attachment 3293328

I think you know my story over in the Check-in thread but I did a similar shift. 3 1/2 years into a classic rock power trio, things were becoming "chore-ish" and not as much fun anymore. Similar challenges; dressing down, phoning it in, no new songs, same 2 venues, etc. Made the jump in June, '18, to an up-and-coming country band with a charismatic leader and great musicians and while it's been a bit of a whirlwind coming up to speed, I couldn't be happier overall. Great gigs. Great music (have added more songs to the playlist in 6 months than the previous 4 years in the old band). Great chemistry. Top it off that TONS of people come out for country music and it adds that nice little touch of ego satiation everyone needs to fuel the fire. Make the jump and pour all your heart into it and you won't be disappointed.
 
I should add, @Jimmy4string, when I say pour your heart into it, what I mean is LIVE it. I wasn't well versed in country music (paid arms-length attention to it over the years but didn't actively listen to it) so I've done nothing but focus on steeping myself in it the last 9+ months to the dismay of my traditional favorites. It's certainly helped come up to speed and pick up on references and influences that I can bring into my playing. It will certainly help you with singing/playing as well. I wish you nothing but the best.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Fat Freddy