• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

MEGA THREAD:: Favorite/Best Punk Bassist

I'm not a punk fan, but Dirnt used to be a good, interesting player (Longview is extremely fun to mess around with!) before he totally dissappeared on American Idiot.

And I give him props just for calling himself Dirnt. Haha.
 
pdusen said:
I'm not a punk fan, but Dirnt used to be a good, interesting player (Longview is extremely fun to mess around with!) before he totally dissappeared on American Idiot.

And I give him props just for calling himself Dirnt. Haha.
I believe he's still good but he made a concious decision to play less on "American Idiot", which is why people think he's "only a root note thumper". l wonder if he works more fills into the new songs live.
 
Mike Watt
Darryl Jenifer
Matt Freeman
The guy from The Descendants (can't think of his name:eek: )

I'm going to cast a vote for Dee Dee Ramone. Yeah, he's an 8th note basher, but he epitomizes the image of a punk bass player with his leather jacket, hair-cut and P bass down by his knees. Kind of like if Sid Viscious could actually play.
 
well punk bassist do suck compared to guys from the other genres...

the best players of punk like the likes of matt freeman versus best of other genres

metal - steve digiorgio, cliff burton, joay demaio

jazz - victor wooten, jaco(are they jazz?)

funk - larry graham, james jamerson?
 
BrandonBass said:
well punk bassist do suck compared to guys from the other genres...

the best players of punk like the likes of matt freeman versus best of other genres

metal - steve digiorgio, cliff burton, joay demaio

jazz - victor wooten, jaco(are they jazz?)

funk - larry graham, james jamerson?


Wow.

Uhm, OK, have you ever listened to punk? The reason I ask... stick Vic in a punk band... he'd do some flashy junk, but would it be "good"... probably not. Punk is about energy/intensity...

Punk bass (lets just say 8th notes) don't suck! They serve a musical purpose... there are times when straight 8ths are the greatest thing you can do to a song.