Interesting that pretty much all these examples are from classic punk/hardcore bands. Pop-punk, not so much.
TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
Jumbotron said:Interesting that pretty much all these examples are from classic punk/hardcore bands. Pop-punk, not so much.
I believe he's still good but he made a concious decision to play less on "American Idiot", which is why people think he's "only a root note thumper". l wonder if he works more fills into the new songs live.pdusen said:I'm not a punk fan, but Dirnt used to be a good, interesting player (Longview is extremely fun to mess around with!) before he totally dissappeared on American Idiot.
And I give him props just for calling himself Dirnt. Haha.
sliceanddice said:Everyone thinks that Punk bassists suck - Not true!
Karl Alvarez?Alan Vorse said:The guy from The Descendants (can't think of his name)

BrandonBass said:well punk bassist do suck compared to guys from the other genres...
the best players of punk like the likes of matt freeman versus best of other genres
metal - steve digiorgio, cliff burton, joay demaio
jazz - victor wooten, jaco(are they jazz?)
funk - larry graham, james jamerson?
