• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Mesa vs Aguilar?

Thanks for the input! You’re right, I remember the 15s from 20-25 years ago (and older for some of the older cabs) that were so muddy that it went with “bass should be felt not heard” mentality. I play a 5 string (Fender American Ultra) and I will frequently use the low B-Db, but I still want clarity in it. I’ll see if there are any 15’s local to me to try out.
Nice bass!! I think you'll enjoy how rich and full it will sound through the SW115. And while that is one of my most favorite cabs, I would encourage you to play anything else they have in the store as you may find something you like better for your uses.
 
The best cab for me (and my tone goals) with the TH500 has been the Berg CN212. In all fairness though, I can't name a head that hasn't sounded good to me through that Berg cab.
During the break on the first gig I did with a TH500 and Berg CN212, the guitarist was missing during the break. I found him standing in front of my rig just staring at it!! He couldn't believe how good it sounded.

These days I use Barefaced 112 cabs with my Aguilar amps. Another perfect match.
 
I have zero experience with Aguilar heads, though two years ago I was debating between a TH, a D800/800+ or a Darkglass M500v2. Went with the Darkglass, but continued to be curious about the Tone Hammers and Mesa Subway products.

I had a pair of Aguilar DB210s which I loved with every amp I’ve had them with, so continued using them with the M500. Recently bought a pair of used GS112’s, and then about a week later a used D800+.

Played them Saturday night in our jam space, full drum kit with a loud drummer, and a guitar player using a Vox combo that was also capable of getting pretty loud.

There was a comment in this thread about the Mesa not being punchy, and other comments about it being too dark, or not a rock amp.

Saturday my D800+ was delivering truckloads of punch and a delightful rock tone. Gain was set so the light would come on about 20-25% of the time, HPF set around 9:00, and all the EQ knobs were set right around 12:00, so pretty flat.

There was definitely a solid and authoritative bottom end, without question, but the EQ on this head is pretty powerful and flexible, I can dial in pretty much anything. I have some more experimenting to do, but just set flat like that was really very enjoyable to hear! It’s hard to imagine anyone being disappointed with this head.

We’re a cover band, so I prefer to use pedals to get a variety of different overdrive or fuzz tones, versus using my amp. The Darkglass makes it easy to access a few others, and the cabsims come in handy in IEM or FOH applications, so I’ll probably keep it also, but the D800+ I will never give up, it’s a keeper for life.

I also realized this morning that I had the impedance set at 2 Ohms Saturday night, as I’d previously had it connected to an Avatar 212 as well as the two GS112s. That explains why I had my volume set at around 10:00-11:00, as I was getting about half the wattage from the 4 Ohm set up - but again, the drummer and the guitar player were very loud.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SJan3 and agedhorse