I'm not making myself look 'dumb'
I'm stating my opinion, which some people can't seem to think.
I'm stating my opinion, which some people can't seem to think.
TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
I'm not making myself look 'dumb'
I'm stating my opinion, which some people can't seem to think.
Mike Dirnt is a great bassist! He's not the greatest bassist ever, but when you listen to some of the stuff from Dookie, he's awesome!
I agree with Dash Rantic when it comes to him toning down in American Idiot, which I find a shame, but if you listen to longview, Minority, When I come Around etc. he is really good!
Shame about American Idiot (apart from the bass solo/bridge in Holiday)
He ain't using the MD signature Fenfer either, he uses an early 80's G&L L-1000 with them most of the time. It sounds awesome!
BassSurfer, you're obviously a huge fan of Greenday and that's cool.
He uses a pick, loses points with me just based on that. No right hand technique.
He plays ok, nothing more to me. His playing fits the simple chords of Greenday. Compare him to a Mike Watt with the minutemen or firehose, and he doesn't register on the same scale to me.
If he's a "great" bassist, what does that make Larry Graham or Geddy Lee?
I actually think his playing on American Idiot was pretty good, albeit a bit more restrained but the album wouldn't sound right with tonnes of fills. Just like any bass player, ya gotta know when to turn it up a notch or when to hold back. This is him holding back.
It'll be interesting to see what the next album holds.
If you listen to his early work, on 1039/Smooth is awesome. Even if you watch some of the live footage from around that time, his playing was great!
In more recent times, if you listen to his work with his other band, The Frustrators. (where I got my username from)
You can hear him really at it. He ain't using the MD signature Fenfer either, he uses an early 80's G&L L-1000 with them most of the time. It sounds awesome!
He's done some other session stuff that sounds cool too, like his work on Sabriana Stewarts Smoking Gun EP.![]()