• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Minor scale/mode theory question

Some of you guys really need to tune their instruments\ ears properly. Where do you hear the Eb? There is no Eb in there! From the Dub Connection Dm natural.mp3 example:

View attachment 4457080

The green marked events corespond to the Flute melody. Decending from C over Bb A G to F.
The only other event (Red) that comes even halfway close to Eb is some percusion or a sound effect. But even that is quite clearly an E.


can you explain what that software is and what is going on?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Phaidrus
It's an audiotool called Spectralayers which is included in Cubase. It's basically a frequency analysis tool in form of a heatmap. The Y-Axis shows the frequency\note (seen on the right border). X-Axis shows time (upper boarder). The louder a note\ frequencys the brighter it gets. However, it can do much more than that.

 
  • Like
Reactions: Phaidrus
Some of you guys really need to tune their instruments\ ears properly. Where do you hear the Eb? There is no Eb in there! From the Dub Connection Dm natural.mp3 example:

View attachment 4457080

The green marked events corespond to the Flute melody. Decending from C over Bb A G to F.
The only other event (Red) that comes even halfway close to Eb is some percusion or a sound effect. But even that is quite clearly an E.

Not "some". It's me.
That Eb is a SOUND EFFECT and it's clearly pronounced as a NOTE.
And my comment clearly indicate the time on that track.
It's upsetting about my "bass brethren".
I'm not here to fight lame battles.
Listen, brethren.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Phaidrus
Could you please suggest some reading material for chord theory?
Right off the bat, I don't know of anything but much of Carol Kaye's information. Basically it's the idea that chords tell you exactly what to play on the strong beats, and everything else is a matter of taste when you use them. It involves learning the fretboard up and down and how chords are formed and how they can relate to other chords. Learn the basics first before you proceed onto further study. Readimg music and/or knowing how to plunk around on a keyboard helps immensely.
 
Right off the bat, I don't know of anything but much of Carol Kaye's information. Basically it's the idea that chords tell you exactly what to play on the strong beats, and everything else is a matter of taste when you use them. It involves learning the fretboard up and down and how chords are formed and how they can relate to other chords. Learn the basics first before you proceed onto further study. Readimg music and/or knowing how to plunk around on a keyboard helps immensely.

You mean basic chords (triads) and 7th chords?
 
If you haven't learned them, yes. But if you have, time to move onto more complex chords like augmented, diminished, and suspended chords. It can get a little complex at times, and if it gets too strange, I generally stick to the root :D
Read the chord from left to right and get as many chord tones into the bass line as your skill level will allow -- or the song needs.

A good ole root or root five will play a lot of bass.
 
Chord Tones
Nice convenient list. One point, though: Some of the dim7 chords are technically misspelled. For instance, Cdim7 is technically C Eb Gb Bbb, and Fdim7 is F Ab Cb Ebb. (See also Gdim7, Ddim7, and Bbdim7.)

I know lots of folks don't like seeing Fb and Cb, and scarcely anyone ever wants to see a double flat, let alone write one, but these things do exist. Showing the correct (if tiresome) spellings would clarify the way in which the chords are derived. Maybe the more convenient enharmonic spelling(s) could be added in parentheses after the clunky correct ones.
 
Nice convenient list. One point, though: Some of the dim7 chords are technically misspelled. For instance, Cdim7 is technically C Eb Gb Bbb, and Fdim7 is F Ab Cb Ebb. (See also Gdim7, Ddim7, and Bbdim7.)

I know lots of folks don't like seeing Fb and Cb, and scarcely anyone ever wants to see a double flat, let alone write one, but these things do exist. Showing the correct (if tiresome) spellings would clarify the way in which the chords are derived. Maybe the more convenient enharmonic spelling(s) could be added in parentheses after the clunky correct ones.
Just don't make everyone lose their mind by telling them that if you learn modes, you also learn how to construct chords.