Who do you guys think is the most overrated actor? I'll list two, Nicholas Cage - I've just seen him overplay too many rolls "Snake Eyes" was almost a laughable acting job in a serious movie! Jack Nicholson (I can see the evil stares) I loved him in Cukoos nest but ever since then I get the feeling he's still playing that role. He always seems a little on the edge like he's about ready to get checked into an institution. When I see him it's almost like the character becomes Jack Nicholson, instead of Him becoming the character.