• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Music and Politics?

Status
Not open for further replies.
My guess is that the guy they're replacing had some pretty strong conservative opinions. Don't need political debates interrupting rehearsals. I keep my political opinions to myself, and ignore the meatheads who can't seem to do the same (whatever side they fall on).

There's no doubt in my mind that a majority of musicians (in my area) are tilted to the left. Put me on the other side of the stage, I'll lean to the right ... nicely balanced!
 
I'd rather see that than the obligatory No One Over 35 because at least I qualify. But I see no problem with people wanting to be with culturally similar people. I've never seen that though. It's really pretty moot around here -- there aren't any republican musicians or visual artists, or poets, or film makers or actors (did I leave any creative trade out? oh yeah, cartoonists & weavers) while there are thousands of liberals and/or green libertarians ...Ted Nugent is somewhere else out hunting deer and The Ramones are...gone... yes, that wonderful facist dictatorship of a band was Quite republican.
It's 85 degrees in the middle of March and no one is saying "humans never polluted anything"! They're saying "in 40 years I've never seen this," or "I hope the summer isn't horrible."
 
Ha, my local music scene has a thread dedicated soley to politics, and it's, sadly, the longest thread on the board at like 130 something pages now. It's pretty much the same people, many of whom aren't even really musicians, reintering the same talking points over and over again.
 
Hm, is the poster one of my ex-BFs? He was on the far left side of the political spectrum, and denounced most people who didn't agree with him as a right-wing lunatics (yet he got upset when I suggested that he just might be a left-wing lunatic). I'm not exactly conservative, but he told me on a few occasions that I had been brainwashed by my Limbaugh-worshipping father, and wasn't that a shame! He was unable to carry on a conversation of any length without getting all worked up about the evils of the Bushes and Reagan, which got old really quickly.

He told me that he had quit multiple bands whose members were big fans of the Bushes and Reagan and reminded him constantly of it during rehearsal. I have my doubts about this and suspect it was more like one of them said one complimentary thing about a Republican, which he blew out of proportion, went on a tirade, then stormed out.

As someone mentioned above, it's nice to be on the same page with bandmates when it comes to social and political issues. However, where I live it's hard to find good musicians regardless of their political affiliations. I've found that it's best just to stay away from discussing those things as much as possible. Bands have enough drama without throwing politics into the mix!
 
Jarnett said:
Yeah me too.. I wouldn't consider myself either though.

Not everybody falls into the Democrat/Republican "left/right" whatever you want to call it. In fact most peole who claim to be "liberal democrats" are just as crazy and annoying as the so-called "conservative republicans".

IMO, you don't have to have ANY political affiliation and still be a douche. Unless the band is wanting to write songs with politically driven lyrics, why should someone's personal politcs even matter?
 
Not everybody falls into the Democrat/Republican "left/right" whatever you want to call it. In fact most peole who claim to be "liberal democrats" are just as crazy and annoying as the so-called "conservative republicans".

IMO, you don't have to have ANY political affiliation and still be a douche. Unless the band is wanting to write songs with politically driven lyrics, why should someone's personal politcs even matter?

+1

IMO, if you don't have your own lobbyist, you really don't have a political party. Just sayin....
 
most musicians, especially rock stars, should STFU when it comes to politics. Since when does the best or luckiest musician actually know anything more about this stuff then the average person who foolishly believes they do. Ditto for actors....

My thoughts exactly..... Just because I am a fan of Your body of work (Film, Music, art), it doesn't mean I give one hill of beans about Your political views or convictions. I respect that You feel that way, but please keep it to Yourself.

As far as in a band setting, personal political convictions have nothing to do with the task at hand. So again, please keep it to Yourself. Nobody mentions it, Nobody gets a$$ hurt and wants to argue about it.
 
Good politics in music- Bob Dylan, Pete Seeger, Woody Guthrie, and RATM making heartfelt songs with political/social themes that are earnest and true to their hearts.

Bad politics in music- Dixie Chicks dissing the President (even tho I agreed with them) in a foreign country, Ted Nugent on Bill O'Reilley, etc.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.