I had the exact same colour combo for about three and a half weeks last August - September. I ended up returning it to the store as I had a great deal come my way on an AVRI '57. I tried the black pickguard, as my previous (stolen) P was a black with maple, and I loved the black pickguard on it - I didn't really like it all that much on the CFM, couldn't really put my finger on why - I did however like the white pearloid that ended up going on it - but honestly, the w-b-w looks great on that colour/fretboard combo, and I normally don't like white pickguards on anything.
If it was rosewood I'd have to say tort... to the poster who mentioned getting a blizzard pearl/rosewood - tort is a must for that IMHO...
I love American Fenders, but I don't get Fender's fascination with white pickguards... Was really pleased to see them use Tort again in '08, but they should have used black instead of white, again IMHO.
Rosewood-tort, Maple-black. That's the rule.

Except for CFM.
If it was rosewood I'd have to say tort... to the poster who mentioned getting a blizzard pearl/rosewood - tort is a must for that IMHO...
I love American Fenders, but I don't get Fender's fascination with white pickguards... Was really pleased to see them use Tort again in '08, but they should have used black instead of white, again IMHO.
Rosewood-tort, Maple-black. That's the rule.
Except for CFM.
