Enjoy the benefits of a premium membership!
Upgrade Account
-
TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
Need help choosing a P-Bass....
- Thread starter bordinco90
- Start date
Idk man there are plenty that pop up on the evilbay and reverb. If you're not comfortable buying w/ pics only, that may not be for you.
I owned a Lakland Skyline Decade which is a different model. I did not like the shape and radius of the neck at all. Many find it nice but others have made the same observation. I would recommend playing one to see if you like it or not. I prefer a more Fender / Warmoth / Musicman type neck and the Skyline was not for me.
FWIW I put together a warmth P from used parts for about $500. Super bass!
FWIW I put together a warmth P from used parts for about $500. Super bass!
The Lakland is the one to get nice bass all around and the necks on these blow away Carvin and Fender...
I vote Roger Waters, seeing that I have one and love it.
I replaced the SPB-3 Duncan Basslines with an EMG GZR, only because I had the basslines in another precision already.
Neck is a "fatty" and awesome "baseball bat" style, and the brass nut is nice stock.
Black on black with Maple is killer as well, it's a great bass!
I replaced the SPB-3 Duncan Basslines with an EMG GZR, only because I had the basslines in another precision already.
Neck is a "fatty" and awesome "baseball bat" style, and the brass nut is nice stock.
Black on black with Maple is killer as well, it's a great bass!
When it comes to PBs, you always want to try before you buy. No two are exactly the same in terms of tone or feel. Last time I shopped for a Fender bass, I auditioned about 15 before I found the one that spoke to me.
Also, keep an open mind and don't arbitrarily confine yourself to specific makes or models. One of the all around nicest PBs I've ever owned is a Squier Matt Freeman. Mine sounds like angels and plays like a dream. The fact it was ridiculously inexpensive and had a name on the headstock that won't get you any bragging rights made no difference to me. It plays well and sounds really good. And nobody was more surprised about that than me.
Also, keep an open mind and don't arbitrarily confine yourself to specific makes or models. One of the all around nicest PBs I've ever owned is a Squier Matt Freeman. Mine sounds like angels and plays like a dream. The fact it was ridiculously inexpensive and had a name on the headstock that won't get you any bragging rights made no difference to me. It plays well and sounds really good. And nobody was more surprised about that than me.
What radius do you prefer? The RWaters P is 7.25...the Carvin is much flatter...
I owned a classic 50s for a long time, the neck was the most stable one I have owned. I moved it on as I now find I prefer a flatter board...(11 my fave)
The Carvin PB4 I owned was fine...I did not care for the nut width and never bonded with it. It reminded me of a decent mid tier..import...and I like imports...on par with my Indo ATK300...
Used Fender American Standard '08-'14 and option? Similar price range...
I owned a classic 50s for a long time, the neck was the most stable one I have owned. I moved it on as I now find I prefer a flatter board...(11 my fave)
The Carvin PB4 I owned was fine...I did not care for the nut width and never bonded with it. It reminded me of a decent mid tier..import...and I like imports...on par with my Indo ATK300...
Used Fender American Standard '08-'14 and option? Similar price range...
Yeah I agree with you. I owned a Matt Freeman P and it was one of the best P Basses I have played as well. Got rid of it to fund the "I need a 5" thing lol.
I believe the Roger Waters sig is the standard 9.5 radius. That is what sweetwater and the Fender website says anyway. If the RW sig is 7.5 I don't want it.
I do have experience with Carvin. Great company and great product, but I sent my PB5 back because I did not like the profile of the neck.
Steal a used Stingray HH for 1000 or less. It's criminal. It will sound like a P, be better built than Fender or import Lakland according to reports and will hold value (used) better than a Carvin. If you don't realize it's awesomeness then sell it for what you paid.
i always vote for carvin,
they're value for the money can't be beat. as far as the instruments go, i'll never claim (nobody does, really) that they're the best sounding bass around. but they're really very good, and if you know what your doing, they compete quite well. the reliability, fit and finish, and overall quality control on carvins is second to none. and, as far as sound is concerned, they do sound better than most basses to my ears.
they're value for the money can't be beat. as far as the instruments go, i'll never claim (nobody does, really) that they're the best sounding bass around. but they're really very good, and if you know what your doing, they compete quite well. the reliability, fit and finish, and overall quality control on carvins is second to none. and, as far as sound is concerned, they do sound better than most basses to my ears.
As a Fender guy in this instance I voted Lakland ... very fat and warm sound and playable neck ... I personally don't like too much the Roger Waters model ... different story if the poll referred to the Nate Mendel model instead ...
Has anyone voted for the Carvin? For those who know Carvin and didn't vote for it, why not? I'm a lefty and it would be in my ballpark to get a Carvin P style bass. An American lefty Fender P would be almost twice as much, and I've rarely found used Fender P's online anywhere.
Carvin -- every Carvin I've played has been a beast. Super high quality, great playing and great sounding instruments for a very reasonable price.
