• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

New bass decision - help needed

Which bass?


  • Total voters
    86
So I've figured that my current bass's neck (a '94 Korean Ibanez ATK) is just a little too large for my small to average paws. I've learnt lessons in the past from playing guitar that if I'm not getting on with the neck, a lot of other things suffer as a result!

So I was keen on trying an Ibanez Soundgear, specifically the SR1300, and trotted to all the local GCs around Colorado trying them out. Great slim neck, exotic and light body, Nordstands, Gotoh tuning pegs, nice bridge and the premium fret treatment. They all felt great, though some could have done with a setup. My untrained ear weren't able to fully appreciate the pickups, as I'm sure they would be great. But I will say, I kinda get what people talk about when they say Soundgears sound...modern. I could get a fair approximation of a P-Bass and Jazz, but just not quite there...

With a trade-in and coupon I could probably score it for around $850, maybe less.

Out of curiosity I tried a natural FSR Jazz bass and the first thing I noticed is that the neck really did fit my hand well. Enough girth to aid tone, but pretty fast and playable. Frets end weren't as good as the SR, but nothing I could cut myself on. 2nd thing is how light it was, even against the SR. 3rd - it buzzed so badly on the first three frets it sounded like it was being played through a vocoder. And the sound on when it wasn't buzzing? Man, it sounded awesome. No need to dial anything in. Just a sweet sweet bass tone.

With a trade in, I could probably get it for around $450. I spoke to a rep there and he said they could fix the buzz for me. Though I doubt they'd put much effort in.

So the dilemma is: which one? The SR hits all the right notes, but tonally not quite as good as the Jazz. The Jazz will take some work, but the extra $300-400 could be spent on a luthier setup, some hardware upgrades plus some change if I wanted to upgrade to some Seymour Duncans or the like in the future.

Any help appreciated!
 
Hi Seraphial :)

Jazzbass!!! get her fixed and :bassist::bassist::bassist:

Why?


the neck really did fit my hand well

sounded awesome

sweet sweet bass tone

and...

05042017113.jpg


any more questions? :hyper::hyper::hyper:

may the bass be with you

Wise(b)ass
 
Not normally a Fender fan but this is about you :) Buy the Fender. Get them to set it up and play to your heart's content. You say it sounds great so why start thinking about upgrades. If a bass feels great but is lacking something in tone then think about upgrades. IMO swapping pickups just for the sake of it don't make sense.

Buy the Fender.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rip Van Dan
Setup is key.

Hand size is a perception issue that is easily overcome.

Always play an instrument out of the best amps and cabs in the house to get an idea of what follows the bass from setup to setup.
 
I have used three different Ibanez SR basses. I like them. (I also have had three different Fender basses, including two US Jazz's). The SR necks are wonderful, especially for 5-strings. The pickups and pre-amps vary from model to model. For the most part, I have had good luck dialing in a great sound, of pretty much any type, on the active SRs.
 
Setups and fretwork can be fixed, so I wouldn't factor either into your decision.

But no matter what you do, those basses are going to sound different. If you aren't happy with how the bass sounds, and it isn't something subtle that a string change might fix, I wouldn't suggest buying the bass.

It sounds like the Jazz is the answer, but you'd RATHER the Ibanez be the answer. If this is so, I'd suggest (1) looking for a different Jazz Bass, there are a million of them out there in every color and flavor, or (2) look for a different "modern"-style brand. Ibanezes have a very specific tone, IMO, and there a ton of different basses that look similar to an Ibanez but sound closer to a Jazz Bass, and also tend to have something like a Jazz neck profile. Be patient and get what you really want.
 
So I've figured that my current bass's neck (a '94 Korean Ibanez ATK) is just a little too large for my small to average paws. I've learnt lessons in the past from playing guitar that if I'm not getting on with the neck, a lot of other things suffer as a result!

So I was keen on trying an Ibanez Soundgear, specifically the SR1300, and trotted to all the local GCs around Colorado trying them out. Great slim neck, exotic and light body, Nordstands, Gotoh tuning pegs, nice bridge and the premium fret treatment. They all felt great, though some could have done with a setup. My untrained ear weren't able to fully appreciate the pickups, as I'm sure they would be great. But I will say, I kinda get what people talk about when they say Soundgears sound...modern. I could get a fair approximation of a P-Bass and Jazz, but just not quite there...

With a trade-in and coupon I could probably score it for around $850, maybe less.

Out of curiosity I tried a natural FSR Jazz bass and the first thing I noticed is that the neck really did fit my hand well. Enough girth to aid tone, but pretty fast and playable. Frets end weren't as good as the SR, but nothing I could cut myself on. 2nd thing is how light it was, even against the SR. 3rd - it buzzed so badly on the first three frets it sounded like it was being played through a vocoder. And the sound on when it wasn't buzzing? Man, it sounded awesome. No need to dial anything in. Just a sweet sweet bass tone.

With a trade in, I could probably get it for around $450. I spoke to a rep there and he said they could fix the buzz for me. Though I doubt they'd put much effort in.

So the dilemma is: which one? The SR hits all the right notes, but tonally not quite as good as the Jazz. The Jazz will take some work, but the extra $300-400 could be spent on a luthier setup, some hardware upgrades plus some change if I wanted to upgrade to some Seymour Duncans or the like in the future.

Any help appreciated!
Dude, if the sound is right, why in the world are you talking about putting in different pickups and hardware on the Fender Special Run Jazz (FSR)? That just doesn't make any sense - "if it ain't broke, don't fix it!".

Also price seems off. Did they make any in US? All the ones I see as the FSR were Made in Mexico (MIM) and GC was selling them for $500. Reverb sold one earlier this year used for $350 + $50 shipping. The irritating fret buzz should be a simple set-up adjustment, possibly a truss rod adjustment, which is easy on those. No way you should have to pay a luthier $300-$400 to fix that. I'd say that if the neck feels right to you and the sound is what you want, get the Jazz.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kodiakblair
I am a crusty curmudgeon. I wouldn't consider anything, that doesn't say Fender on the headstock, a bass. Played an Ibanez in a pawn shop. It was sweet. I might have brought it home, but it didn't say Fender.

Buy the one that feels right in your hands. You'll be able to make it sound great if it likes you, and you like it.