TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
Another thing to consider is that right now they have time to find another band. If the drummer and the OP are both actually not familiar with the genre, this can only be awful. The BL right now has time to bow out with the explanation that his best players aren't able to be there. He can make up an excuse about them being sick, or whatever, but he is at least in a position now to not leave them high and dry. But trying to pull off an odd-time gig with a drummer who can't play it is probably not going to go well. We don't know if that's the case, but the fact that they don't really know the drummer, and the drummer asked a bassist who also doesn't know the music, seems very sketchy to me.This. I would contact the band leader and be totally honest about where you stand. For all you know the drummer has misrepresented the situation to the band leader (the drummer himself might not even be aware of what he’s gotten himself into repertoire/style-wise). Once the band leader has all the information let him decide, but I’d also make it clear that you have no intention of spending the night in a state of panic and that you need a song list and charts for you to do your job properly. If odd time signatures are, indeed, the order of the day then that would be my primary concern (having to count all night wouldn’t be a whole lot of fun). But, again, I would discuss the situation with the band leader. Good luck!
About 2 weeks ago a (particularly bad) drummer I have gigged with once called me and asked whether I was available to do a gig on New Year's eve. Having never played in the required genre before (basically some Greek/Turkish folk music), and not being too keen on studying a whole new setlist within a limited amount of time I clearly told the guy that I was inexperienced with the genre, I did not know any of the songs, I did not know whether I can spare time to work on it but I could possibly read chords (if they would be made available to me) and thus try to serve the song as best as I could. In addition, I have asked for the highest payment I could fathom, basically asking them not to hire me and go look for someone else. To my surprise, the drummer replied that they have agreed with the conditions.
They were supposed to share the setlist a week ago, having only 10 days left I started to freak out gradually. I have called the BL yesterday to ask for the setlist (he's still to share it) and I learned that they have never worked with the drummer also. I don't even know how well the drummer has communicated my inexperience with the genre, or if he told them I am only semi-pro, while the other people in the band are trying to make their living from this. This thing suddenly started to feel like a very bad idea. On the other hand, I know that I will never gain the experience with the particularly genre (which usually pays good in such organizations) if I don't take the job. How would you navigate something like this? Any thought would be appreciated.
Is that you?I’m soiling myself from fear just reading the thread….
Question for those of you who have played in this genre to some extent. Which mode(s) should the OP be very fluent with? Please don't reply "all of them"![]()
It doesn't seem to me that the drummer sucking is the main issue here. Rather it's the fact that the OP might be way over his head where the music is concerned. The professional thing to do here, in my opinion, is to talk directly to the band leader. How many bebop band leaders would be happy finding out that the bassist who is booked on the gig has never played jazz before?Wow, I'm surprised how many people would bail on a very good paying gig just because the drummer might suck. How the heck do you pay your rent as a musician without ever working with someone in the band who isn't as good as you? How are you making a career out of music only playing with top-tier drummers?!
First, if you're a pro, you do the best you can with what you have to work with and you get paid. You don't owe anything more than that. If they hamstring you with lack of info or details, and you were up front about your needs, that's on them, not you. If their mistakes reduce your ability to turn in a stellar performance that's on them, not you. You owe them what you said, you didn't promise something you couldn't deliver, and you made it clear what you are and are not as a musician. That leaves it up to them to hire you or someone else, and if they pick you then you show up and do what you promised.
I've played very similar gigs before. I had a NYE show once that was an almost unfathomable train wreck: a professional tribute act singer plus an amateur guitarist, a drummer who had literally never heard a single song of the source material, and me, a hired gun bass player, at a fancy resort on NYE with one thrown-together rehearsal the day before the gig. It was a disaster, we were terrible, and I took my pay and went home. Life went on. I paid my rent on time. If the club never booked that act again and they looked stupid it sure wasn't my fault.
The best thing about being a sideman is that you don't even have to worry about all that stuff. You show up, play your bass, take your money, and let it go when you walk out the door. Whether or not the band leader overpromised, under delivered, hired the wrong guys, or mismanaged his gig into the ground is none of your concern.
I don't make my living as a musician anymore.Wow, I'm surprised how many people would bail on a very good paying gig just because the drummer might suck. How the heck do you pay your rent as a musician without ever working with someone in the band who isn't as good as you? How are you making a career out of music only playing with top-tier drummers?!
It's a bit surprising to me the number of people who have apparently never heard middle eastern music. This isn't your Mustang Sally or Real Book sort of gig. I feel bad for someone who is that needy for cash that they'd take a job knowing that they'll not do it well, and I feel worse for the people who hired them.It doesn't seem to me that the drummer sucking is the main issue here. Rather it's the fact that the OP might be way over his head where the music is concerned. The professional thing to do here, in my opinion, is to talk directly to the band leader. How many bebop band leaders would be happy finding out that the bassist who is booked on the gig has never played jazz before?
Wow, I'm surprised how many people would bail on a very good paying gig just because the drummer might suck. How the heck do you pay your rent as a musician without ever working with someone in the band who isn't as good as you? How are you making a career out of music only playing with top-tier drummers?!
First, if you're a pro, you do the best you can with what you have to work with and you get paid. You don't owe anything more than that. If they hamstring you with lack of info or details, and you were up front about your needs, that's on them, not you. If their mistakes reduce your ability to turn in a stellar performance that's on them, not you. You owe them what you said, you didn't promise something you couldn't deliver, and you made it clear what you are and are not as a musician. That leaves it up to them to hire you or someone else, and if they pick you then you show up and do what you promised.
I've played very similar gigs before. I had a NYE show once that was an almost unfathomable train wreck: a professional tribute act singer plus an amateur guitarist, a drummer who had literally never heard a single song of the source material, and me, a hired gun bass player, at a fancy resort on NYE with one thrown-together rehearsal the day before the gig. It was a disaster, we were terrible, and I took my pay and went home. Life went on. I paid my rent on time. If the club never booked that act again and they looked stupid it sure wasn't my fault.
The best thing about being a sideman is that you don't even have to worry about all that stuff. You show up, play your bass, take your money, and let it go when you walk out the door. Whether or not the band leader overpromised, under delivered, hired the wrong guys, or mismanaged his gig into the ground is none of your concern.
I also find it weird that some people think the "professional" thing to do is go ahead with the gig without even having a thorough discussion with the band leader regarding options. Most of my gigging time is as a sideman but I occasionally lead a band and hire musicians. If someone I'd hired was feeling as apprehensive about a gig as the OP seems to feel I would absolutely want that person to come to me with their concerns. At the very least I could then tailor the set to avoid as many train wrecks as possible.It's a bit surprising to me the number of people who have apparently never heard middle eastern music. This isn't your Mustang Sally or Real Book sort of gig. I feel bad for someone who is that needy for cash that they'd take a job knowing that they'll not do it well, and I feel worse for the people who hired them.
You have done all you can to make this work, short of changing your surname to BassopolousThank you all for your input. I have managed to get the other people in the band to meet for a rehearsal, alas not earlier than the 26th.Still, I guess it will give us an opportunity to see how much of a trainwreck we're headed for. By the way it appears that the band will consist an acoustic guitar, clarinet, bass and percussion, talk about feeling exposed out in the open. Will try to update after the rehearsal.