I've ordered a few Spitfire guards and I haven't been disappointed with any of them. They are definitely closer to the old Fender tortoise guards than anything else I've seen, if that's what you're after.
There is an element of trust involved in that you don't really know exactly what the finished product will look like, and there is some variation for sure, but the degree of artistry is very consistent.
This is a "Subtle 60's vintage dark/burgundy mix" P-bass guard (light relic) that I think is my favorite.
View attachment 5236045