I had a similar reaction to the Carcosa as the Boneshaker, however a little less intense. It seemed to overlap with lots of my pedals, but didn't sound as good as them. For my tones, if the Boneshaker is 95% there, the Carcosa was 80% or so. Still though, it has plenty of tones I don't have, so I'm not knocking it at all. It's just that if I wanted those tones I'd have them. But I don't, so the Carcosa didn't last long for me. We're also talking about being beaten by boutique pedals that are often over a hundred dollars more, if not even more expensive.Cool. Thanks for that. I was pretty bummed when i couldn't hop on the steal deal, but now I'm like, ok. Cool. I can do without. Would still like to try one someday. It seems pretty awesome. I'm so happy with my dirt section right now it wouldn't much matter unless it absolutely blew me away. Kinda like you.
In other news I took the carcosa off my board. That lasted like 2 days. See, I got the DG alpha/omega. Holy crap is that the bees knees as far as bass dirt is concerned. It's pretty amazing. And I felt like I could cut down on my dirt section a little. So the carcosa came off. But honestly, I can't not recognize what the carcosa does in a live band mix. It totally maims and pillages. I'm actually thinking Of swapping out the muff I'm using for it and using the carcosa in that role. It does a convincing muff to my ear and it cuts better than any muff I've had or tired. So I think it may be my "muff" fuzz for a bit.
In truth, DOD has been killing it lately. The Gunslinger is also phenomenal (and has been gifted to my guitarist where it shines), the Looking Glass seems great (no experience - yet), and the reissues have all been spot on from what I hear.
