First, Mike himself will tell you that the electronics and preamps were never his strongest part of the package. and, what I mean is that his luthiery expertise far outweighs his electronics tech capability. That said, certainly each to their own. There are def a bunch of players, like yourself, who prize the TCT / drop shoulder pickups.
That's all cool; but, for my part, I struggled with all of that. Both of the pre-Nashvilles I gigged extensively were Sig5's. The first one had the later preamp you described; and I had to work extensively with the Nashville folks to finally get a preamp I liked in it. Sort of.
That didn't stick; and a few years later I obtained an earlier Hollywood bass with the TCT / Drop Shoulder pickups. In my hands the TCT, after I removed some objectionable LPF wiring that had been installed as an option, was OK going to tape, but just meh in a live mix. I ended up (carefully / reversibly) stripping that out and installing a Pope preamp, which opened the live voicing up to a considerable extent.
Meanwhile, Pat Wilkins did the refin on my C6, which included the Pope preamp AND what were then prototype Nordstrand Zen Blades. And, that result was SO successful, that I ultimately sold the Hollywood Sig 5, because I didn't want to do an irreversible rout to replace the Drop Shoulder pickups; and used the proceeds to fund the bass Mike more recently built for me. For MY purposes, the Zen Blades plus Pope preamp are a significant improvement over the Drop Shoulders / TCT, the latter of which both just sounded more closed up. Which is fine for studio tracking; but, I prefer more open voicing so for live work. So, as always, YMMV; that's just my experience.
You definitely have to be a fan of the dual coil thing to like the old pickups, which it seems like you're not. The problem (but also beauty) with the TCT is that all the controls affect each other, so any difference in wiring will affect the whole circuit. With so many different ways to wire it, the trick is finding the right way for you. It's taken years of examining pictures of the preamps in 80's Tobias' that I liked the sound of to figure out what Bob Lee did with those particular setups that had "that" sound.
.
). Figured I'd put it up here and see what the Tobias community thinks.