• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

P bass players?

I always run my tone wide open.

I typically turn my volume down 10-20 percent so I have some wiggle room to turn up a smidge on certain songs/parts.

Otherwise the rest of the tone/volume control is all done by the amp and PA.

FWIW, I play roundwounds in a Blues/Rock band.
 
So the reason I'm asking this in the first place.

I'm really enjoying playing my Steve harris sig. P bass.

It's comfortable to play and just feels right in my hands.

I recently installed a Dimarzio dp122 as I felt the the SD spb1 was not modern/sharp/clear enough.

The dp 122 gives me much more tonal options as it is sharper with more pronounced clearer mids and lows.

With the SD I had to run the tone wide open so I could hear myself.

But with the Dimarzio gives me more tone options and has me experimenting.

Based on the room my eight piece rehearses in. If I run my tone dial at 50% I run the controls on my amp pretty close to flat and get a good sound. It is right for the room and I can hear myself.

If I run the tone dial wide open, I have to dial in some bass and mids (but not much) . This really makes the bass cut thru the mix with much more authority.

I can't decide which way prefer to dial in.

Since I consider myself relatively new to the p bass, it made me wonder how other players dial in their p bass.
 
I have the older 2001 SH Fender sig precision and usually turn the tone about half way. There is a certain point just slightly beyond 50% where it just goes from mid-bassy to all out thick low muffled and it sounds terrible to me. Also anything from about 40% downward to all out open sounds too clicky and punchy. maybe this is just the way the SD QP is supposed to be but I keep thinking something just doesn't seem right with this pup.
 
I have mine low maybe on 3. I keep my volume up and my treble low on my amp. I use light strings and I think they sound perfect for my style. I would use med but I had a finger reatatched and any other gauge hurts it bad. To much, info
 
volume is almost all the way up as well as tone. maybe a 9 out of 10. i have a volume pedal that i use to turn down if needed and the tone just seems to sound better just slightly backed off. i have a brand spankin new MIA P. now my Gibson is quite different...
 
The answer is trivially simple.

Run the tone the way YOU like it. That's how you get a sound you like. What others do is nothing more than a departure point for your own experimentation.

What you've learned is that people run the tone knob anywhere from full treble to somewhat bassy. Not a lot of specificity there.