I had a recent conversation with a well-known bass builder. We were discussing strings. I asked him if his brand of strings were perfect for his basses. His response surprised me... "Not really. The bass chooses the string."
Hmmm... that response was a little more hippie than I expected... lol.
I've typically used the same strings on all my basses because I like the consistency of feel. However, in recent years I'm using NYXL nickels on my Lull, Sandberg steels on my Sandberg and Pure Blues on my Bluesman Vintage jazz. It wasn't necessarily intentional. It just sort of happened since, with the exception of the Lull, those are the strings that came with each bass and I liked them. So now I have 3 brands of strings on 3 basses.
Do you use the same brand on all your basses? Or does each bass 'choose' the string? lol
Yeah; IME (50+ year's worth), the bass does choose the string. In fact, IME the instrument - regardless of type - chooses the string. Insofar as they work for what
you want from that particular bass, guitar, or whatever. So, no, I don't have the same strings on all 23 of my basses - or guitars. I do have the same
brand (Dogal) of strings on my 3 guitars, but one wears their "Jalapeno Hot" rounds, and the other 2 wear "Carbonsteel" flats in different gauges... The one banjo, obviously wears what it wears; John Hersey Long Scale Phosphor Bronze strings (it's a long scale '63 Type 3 ODE). Mainly because, AFAIK, nobody else makes long scale banjo strings... As for the basses? One wears "short scale" TI Jazz Rounds (pretty much out of necessity - although they do sound... adequately decent... on that bass. One - my Rogue VB-100 violin bass - wears medium scale Roto TruBass88 Tapes. Both for the sound, and for their ease of tuning/intonating on that bass; which can be a nightmare for this type of bass. All the other basses wear flats. All but a couple of them (the newest ones) don't have the flats they'll wear permanently - yet. But, the ones that do?
- La Bella DTFs, in various scales and gauges;
- Optimas, both the RB's and the "Chromes";
- Thomastik-Infeld Jazz Flats (long scale);
- Dogal, both "Jaco" Carbonsteels and R44s (long scale);
- GHS Precision Flats, long and short scale;
- Galli Jazz Flats (long scale);
- Fender 9050L's (long scale); and
- DR Legends (short scale).
In addition, I've used Roto RS77LDs - and liked them. I sold one bass ('18 Gibson T-Bird) that wore them, and replaced the ones on my '78 P-Bass with GHS Precision Flats for the more "vintage tone" they had on that bass. I've also used a rather old, well broken-in set of D'Addario Chromes on my G&L ASAT Bass. IMO, they were... adequate; but, when they died? I put a set of Fender 9050L's on it, which IMO sounded much better on that bass. So...
Yeah; IME the bass pretty much does choose the strings. In my case, I like the feel and tone of flats in general, and I've found that flats are different enough one from another, that there's almost always one brand/gauge that will give me
exactly the sound I want from a particular bass...
