• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Precision basses other than Fender

The fralins are really nice. I actually really like the underwound Franlins. They are just so pure sounding.

Mine are the stock ones, but I'd be curious about under wound too. Before I put these back in I had some overwound Duncans that were cool for a while (they were hot and PHAT!), but eventually I got tired of how wooly they made the bass sound. Now I like an airier sound.
 
Mine are the stock ones, but I'd be curious about under wound too. Before I put these back in I had some overwound Duncans that were cool for a while (they were hot and PHAT!), but eventually I got tired of how wooly they made the bass sound. Now I like an airier sound.
The underwounds have that sound of a good old pickup that has lost a little but just sounds so sweet that you turn the amp up instead
 
Thanks guys. Sadowsky is a good one. I love the Fender precisions but I don't want to be limited to just them in case there is something else good out there. If that makes sense

G&L LB-100s are amazing P-basses. They have a classic P pickup and tone.

The nice thing about G&L is that they always come with a two piece, bookmatched body. Even MIA Fenders use three or four piece bodies now. G&Ls also have lightweight tuners and bone nuts standard. They also use a special bridge called a "Saddle lock bridge" that is a unique design. Basically the bridge is high-mass, but it has a metal lip that is set deep in the body underneath. It really makes the wood vibrate when you're playing, you can feel the strings vibrating in your rib cage when playing that bass.

G&Ls are awesome. Each one also has a Plek job so you know the fretwork is superb. When you order a G&L you get to pick the nut width and fretboard radius as well. You also can pick different color or fretboard options.

If you want something a little different I definitely recommend their SB-1 or SB-2. The SB-2 is sort of like a P bass but it has two pickups, with two volumes and no tone. Your bridge pickup volume is your tone knob. The SB-1 uses the same neck pickup, but has no bridge pickup and a tone control instead.

The SBs have MFD pickups which are much brighter, or HiFi vs. standard P bass pickups. They're very high output but aren't too mid-heavy like you'd expect out of a hot pickup. The secret is in the magnets, they're incredibly powerful. However the pickup itself is wound to a lower resistance compared to even vintage pickups. The end result is a wide frequency, brighter sound with the P tone supporting it underneath.

I have a LB100, SB-1 and a SB-2. I like them all for different purposes. The SB-1 is my go-to bass for most everything, the LB100 is a backup or used in warmer stuff, and the SB-2 is my slap bass, or used for brighter melodic parts. I did wire a tone control in my SB-2 so it also serves as a backup for my SB-1 as well.

Screen Shot 2016-05-19 at 2.22.34 PM.png

3952.jpg

Screen Shot 2016-05-19 at 2.23.19 PM.png
 
Last edited:
I'm on the Lull bandwagon too.
My burst Alder/RW P4 with Nordstrand NP4a pickup is my favorite all-time P.
A close second would be a number of Lakland's, Sadowsky, and G&Ls I have owned from time to time.
The Lull neck profile is what does it for me over those other very good basses.

DSCN7344_zpsc11b213c.jpg


There are many good P-style pickups out there to try (probably lots of threads on this very topic), aside from the Nordstrand I mention, also love the EMG Geezer Butler pickup, and the Darkstar/Bisonic pickup for a more modern tone, and the Lindy Fralin and Lollar pickups when you want that vintage motown tone.
 
Last edited:
Some other brands to look out for :

Carvin,
Lakland,
Lull,
Sadowsky,
Dingwall,
Peavey,
Xotic,
Certain Bass,
Nash,
Vintage,
Musicman (they're making a P now!)


My choice would be G&L though, the LB-100 and SB-1 are absolutely awesome in quality and tone.
 
Two of my three basses are P basses. One is G&L LB-100. Great bass. The other one is a Warmoth parts bass. It looks, plays & sounds great.

I had an American Fender P bass but I like the G&L and the Warmoth better. They balance better, weigh less, have better hardware and better necks all for less than a Fender.