• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Prog metal...where do I start?

43% burnt said:
Sweet. Good stuff...I wish I could find people around here that want to play tht kind of stuff.

Thanks for the recs everyone. I'm updating my "bands to check out" list. Because of this thread and everyones posts I've found some seriously amazing new music!

I've been looking and I can't find any Watchtower. :(

I also found this link for the 100 Greatest Prog Metal Albums.

Not sure what I think about that list. While there are a lot of good ones on there, it seemed like whoever came up with it likes the same 6 bands, and it's obvious.
 
Definitely check out Voivod and Devin Townsend. They're sorta in the middle of the spectrum, not overly technical but pretty damn good nonetheless.

I'd also like to be the 50,000th person to reccomend Fates Warning.

It seems like you're off to a good start already... Necrophagist, BTBAM, Cryptopsy, Cynic, Atheist and Pestilence are all AWESOME bands.
 
As Ben Strange already mentioned - I'm listening to Fredrik Thordendal's Special Defects, Sol Niger Within (Version 3.33). EXCELLENT and bizarre, a flow of songs that link together. Predecessor to "I" and Catch 33? Maybe, but with fusion guitar and sax and randomness as well! MORGAN AGREN RULES!!!!

Borknagar is highly thought of around here, haven't heard much, but they sound good - not too keen on the vocals, but your opinion may differ.

Attention Deficit - Idiot King is a superb heavy fusion record (as previously mentioned as well) Not metal, but it aint looking backward at all.

Anything with Gene Hoglan on drums is bound to progress in some way shape or form, Death is pretty cool with him holding it down!

I'm strangely drawn towards the last two Dimmu Borgir records. Orchestra metal? Blast beats, string section, alternating death/opera vocals: I'm loving it!
 
Thanks guys...more good suggestions I'll be sure to check out.

I picked up Opeth's "Still Life" today...I'm pretty psyched about this one.

And I finally heard some Liquid Tension Expirament...I'll definitely be buying their albums very soon.
 
The Fall of Troy - VERY genre bending stuff, delves right into metal, then flails into neo-classical in such a terrific style.

The album by them I'd reccomend is called Ghostship Demos. Its free, so don't worry. It only has 3 (or 4, I forget) tracks, but dear christ.. Ghostships Part 1 is the best song I've ever heard.

Here it is. Again, it was released online, and is FREE.

Link Removed
 
OysterBoy said:
The Fall of Troy - VERY genre bending stuff, delves right into metal, then flails into neo-classical in such a terrific style.

The album by them I'd reccomend is called Ghostship Demos. Its free, so don't worry. It only has 3 (or 4, I forget) tracks, but dear christ.. Ghostships Part 1 is the best song I've ever heard.

Here it is. Again, it was released online, and is FREE.

Link Removed
Thanks alot! Very cool stuff...kinda reminded me of a heavier version on the Mars Volta. They do a great job combining different styles too. Great production, I love the bass tone. Good playing too!
 
43% burnt said:
Thanks alot! Very cool stuff...kinda reminded me of a heavier version on the Mars Volta. They do a great job combining different styles too. Great production, I love the bass tone. Good playing too!
+1...just listened to this in the car on the way to work this morning. Couldn't help but think of TMV when I listened to it. Thanks for the recomendation OysterBoy!!! :bassist:
 
By the way, has anyone mentioned Therion? Ozric Tentacles? Hawkwind? Sorry if anyone already had...those three are good prog with metal thrown in!

Therion - Lemuria/Sirius B
Ozric Tentacles - Jurassic Shift
Hawkwind - Space Ritual (thanks Matt Till for turning me on to these guys!)
 
Matt Till said:
Yessssssssssssssssss... furthermore "Nothingface"!! But Outer Limits is proggier, different moods.

Backing up Page's call on Tiamat. I have the album Clouds and it blows me away. It's not overly tech, but there is so much layering. It's awesome.
+1...I love Dimension Hatross, Nothingface, and The Outer Limits...all good albums.

I'm going to try to pick up Tiamat's Clouds...sounds intriguing!
 
Just repeating what I've been told about Tiamat, they invented symphonic black metal. Even though the vocals aren't black metal. What I like about them is they are heavy... but chilled out as well. Very atmospheric without doing what I hate about a lot of Black Metal (over reverbaration). I love Clouds though, I don't know how to give it a proper review. It's just great.
 
Noted...added to list:

Tiamat, Voivod, Therion, Ozric Tentacles and Hawkwind.

The Fall of Troy reminded me of Link Removed at points. Maybe it was his screaming voice. Anyway, they're a great expirimental type of band. Anyone heard these guys? I have their album "Wonderland" and I think its fantastic. I recommend it to any fans of Mike Patton, Sleepy Time Gorilla Museum, Botch, etc..
 
Among many purchases, I picked up Athiest's "Unquestionable Presence" & "Somewhere in Time" albums recently. What a fantastic band! I'm glad Relapse records has reissued these albums under their "Relapse Cult Classic" moniker.

Athiest - Unquestionable Presence: has been getting the most listening between the two. Athiest definitely has their own sound. They sound somewhere between Cynic, Death and Sadus to me. All tremedously great bands. The whole album rocks my fav songs are "Unquestionable Presence", "The Psychic Saw" and "Enthralled in Essence." I learned alot about the band, since the booklet provides a nice band bio and history. I was also saddened to read the tragic story about the death of their original bass player Roger Patterson on tour. :( That was so sad. He was an unbelieveable player! Holy chops! You know he was insanely good since the only capable replacement was Tony Choy. I thought its was great how they included demo cuts and rythm tracks with him playing in addition to the full length. I haven't listened to the other album enought to give a quality review...maybe in a week or so.
 
43% burnt said:
Among many purchases, I picked up Athiest's "Unquestionable Presence" & "Somewhere in Time" albums recently. What a fantastic band! I'm glad Relapse records has reissued these albums under their "Relapse Cult Classic" moniker.

Athiest - Unquestionable Presence: has been getting the most listening between the two. Athiest definitely has their own sound. They sound somewhere between Cynic, Death and Sadus to me. All tremedously great bands. The whole album rocks my fav songs are "Unquestionable Presence", "The Psychic Saw" and "Enthralled in Essence." I learned alot about the band, since the booklet provides a nice band bio and history. I was also saddened to read the tragic story about the death of their original bass player Roger Patterson on tour. :( That was so sad. He was an unbelieveable player! Holy chops! You know he was insanely good since the only capable replacement was Tony Choy. I thought its was great how they included demo cuts and rythm tracks with him playing in addition to the full length. I haven't listened to the other album enought to give a quality review...maybe in a week or so.

Atheist is one of my favorite bands...I wish they had more than three albums, but what they managed to record is all great (how many bands can you say that about?!).

BTW, I listened to Tiamat's Clouds and Wildhoney...holy crap (thanks again, Matt Till)! Both GREAT albums! I'm digging DragonLord and Alarum too! Great picks!! :hyper: I know Darkest Hour probably doesn't count as prog metal, but I like them too...pretty good stuff!

Thanks for starting this thread, 43% burnt! I've got to listen to some very good music that I never would have heard of before! :bassist:

~Tim (aka xsogol)
 
43% burnt said:
Awesome sugestions guys.

I love that album...Tool's best work IMO. I'll take a listen to the Dream Theater album you suggested too.


Thanks man, these all look very promising. That Yeti song sounds bananas, i will definitely be getting that album. I have "Of Natural History" by STGM...thats one crazy record. Very good, yet very weird.

If you think that SGM is insane on record, try seeing them live, THEY'RE A HUNDRED TIMES MORE SO!!!
 
Buried Inside are a wicked band. their latest album "Chronoclast" is presented as 1x40 minute peice od music. you cant understand a word the singer is saying so you'll have to keep the lyric sheet handy. there music is more screemo than proggy (whatever that means) but there use of dynamics is like nothing ive ever heard, it sounds more like tension than dynamics i guess.
 

Latest posts