• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

"Proof that you're a bass player" songs

Lol! I’m trying to understand your explanation, but I’m 64 years old and my
flexibility is limited!
Ha! Okay, a re-post, sans sarcasm...

When it comes to online forums such as this, as well as social media platforms like Facebook and Twitter, many people have a bad habit of becoming intellectually and communicatively lazy; they will read a little bit of a post, assume what the rest says, and reply. Or maybe the post will remind them of something they think we should hear, with varying degrees of relevance, and post about that. This, co-mingled with the posts directly related to the subject of the original post, makes for a very difficult thread to keep up with.

This is not really a complaint; it is simply what happens when a widely varied group of people with a widely varied set of experiences and practices all post on the same thread. Imagine attending a lecture in school, and partway through the lecture, various factions break off and begin to have their own conversations. Rude, huh? Well, it's kind of what happens online, however it's really not so rude here, but part of the fun, and can lead to different places. Now, not everyone in every thread has something useful to add to the conversation (not that it stops them), but they can usually be passed over easily enough if you're trying to follow a certain aspect of the thread.

Some people go out of their way to pick a fight, whether in person or online; in the latter case, there is far less risk, since we all have aliases and are out of arm's reach. I highly doubt there are any posts like that in this thread, as I highly doubt that more than 0.1% of TB members fit that description. I like to think that for some reason bassists as a general rule are less likely to be disrespectful than the average musician or person, and for that reason I find myself spending a lot more time here than I do FB these days. :)
 
There were not enough bass players in my immediate attention to know. I do remember trumpet players and their contest to go into Maynard Ferguson's territory. But in a time where funk and jazz fusion had just started getting their when we really looked at the bass player to bring that groove.second wave of players in the late 70s Slide by Slave comes to my mind
 
Just watched an interview with Geddy Lee where he mentions a Stones song, "2120 S. Michigan Avenue", as a song he needed to be able to play to "prove he was a bass player" in order to audition for a certain band as a young teen.

It has been said that if you wanted a gig as a bassist in Detroit in the 70s, you had better be good enough to play "Scorpio" by Dennis Coffey note-for-note or you wouldn't even be considered.

At parties, if someone trots out a bass, there will be those (generally enthusiastic non-musicians) who will issue challenges: "Can you play Smoke On The Water? Barney Miller? Another One Bites The Dust? Got The Time? Longview? Teen Town? DEAN Town?"

Here, it was "Tom Sawyer". If you could handle that, you could handle just about anything. And if your band could pull off YYZ, you were nothing short of musical royalty at the high school.

So what songs were the "proof" songs when you were growing up?

That was a song where the bass was dominant...and there weren't that many songs like that at the time.
 
  • Like
Reactions: fretlessman71
Lol... I'm not pickin on you, but this was the first that jumped out at me :) .

‘My Generation’ - by The Who

I doubt Paul McCartney could play My Generation.

I'm (almost) fairly certain Roger Waters couldn't, either.

And I could easily name a dozen more successful bass players that couldn't play that, or probably most of the other songs that popped up in this thread that I haven't read yet :) . Including myself.

If I were going to test someone on their bass playing skills I'd see how they handled something like Play That Funky Music, or maybe something I can't think of off the top of my head that has a little more technical difficulty. If they can make that groove, they're good in my book.

Should note that it also has a lot to do with what kind of band they need to prove themselves for.




If I were auditioning someone for a pop rock cover band I'd have The Killer's Mr. Briteside as a song. Its a pretty easy song that LOTS and LOTS of people train-wreck for some reason. I think its a fairly good litmus test.
 
When I purchased my first elec guitar, I was asked by some friends who already had their guitars, if I'd put some bass strings on mine and learn bass. I probably looked the fool I was since they laughed and said "do you even know what the bass is?" No - honestly I had no clue. I thought that was the drummer doing all those low things. Sir Paul changed that eventually. If there was a benchmark it probably was "Young Man Blues" by the Who. EDIT: I should mention here that I grew up in a medium size city in Germany.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: fretlessman71
' So what songs were the "proof" songs when you were growing up? '

I have no idea. I didn't start playing bass until about age 25, and I've never felt the need to prove that I was a bass player, at all, let alone "high school royalty", lol.
 
Just watched an interview with Geddy Lee where he mentions a Stones song, "2120 S. Michigan Avenue", as a song he needed to be able to play to "prove he was a bass player" in order to audition for a certain band as a young teen.

It has been said that if you wanted a gig as a bassist in Detroit in the 70s, you had better be good enough to play "Scorpio" by Dennis Coffey note-for-note or you wouldn't even be considered.

At parties, if someone trots out a bass, there will be those (generally enthusiastic non-musicians) who will issue challenges: "Can you play Smoke On The Water? Barney Miller? Another One Bites The Dust? Got The Time? Longview? Teen Town? DEAN Town?"

Here, it was "Tom Sawyer". If you could handle that, you could handle just about anything. And if your band could pull off YYZ, you were nothing short of musical royalty at the high school.

So what songs were the "proof" songs when you were growing up?

When I was growing up the "proof" as U call it, or being popular as a bass player, was the ability to play whatever it was that the other kids were in to. Same now, I guess, generally speaking: You ain't going to be considered to be a bass player unless what you do is considered as such by other people.
 
When I was growing up the "proof" as U call it, or being popular as a bass player, was the ability to play whatever it was that the other kids were in to. Same now, I guess, generally speaking: You ain't going to be considered to be a bass player unless what you do is considered as such by other people.
Okay, so, for your experience, what were some of those songs? For instance, you meet someone new at school who finds out you play bass, and they say, "Wow, you play bass? Cool! Can you play ___________?"
 
What's Going On-Marvin Gaye (James Jamerson)
Everything is Everything-Donny Hathaway (Willie Weeks)
Stomp-Brothers Johnson(Louis Johnson)
School Days-Stanley Clarke
Reach For It-George Duke (Byron Miller)
Never Too Much-Luther Vandross (Marcus Miller)
Do I Do-Stevie Wonder (Nathan Watts)
Sunset Drive -Jean-Luc Ponty (Ralphe Armstrong)
Rhythms of Hope-Jean-Luc Ponty (Randy Jackson)
Glide-Pleasure (Nathaniel Phillips)
Slide-Slave (Mark Adams)