• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Putting a dollar amount to how much weight matters, if it does.

Do you value less weight enough to pay more?

  • Option A: $719 / 11.5 lbs

    Votes: 19 10.1%
  • Option B: $849 / 10.3 lbs

    Votes: 5 2.6%
  • Option C: $875 / 9.4 lbs

    Votes: 165 87.3%

  • Total voters
    189
I build my own basses, with an emphasis (among other things) on weight. My heaviest 5 string is 8.2 pounds. My lightest (a 4 string) is 6.6

While 9.4 pounds is OK for some folks, I’d pass on all 3 of those options. None of them are my idea of “light”.

Yes, all my basses cost more than $1K to build, so light weight is worth paying for.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Yonni
I am really impressed by those Fender style basses you guys manage to get under 8 pounds or even 7 pounds for that matter, aren't they neck diving?
I thought my chambered Godin RG4 was light at 8.3 pounds and it is a bit neck heavy and the headstock is not as big a typical Fender...Do you all have hipshot ultralight tuners?

Tuners are the absolute first thing that you tackle when building a light weight bass. Especially on a 5 string, Hipshot ultralites are a given. There is no reason to use clunky Fender style steel tuners.

My lightest is 6.6 pounds. You can let go of the neck and hop up and down all you want - there isn’t a hint of neck dive. I have a 5 string that's 7.25 pounds - same thing, no neck dive.
 
  • Like
Reactions: chris_b
From a medical standpoint, the less concentrated weight bearing down on one side of your body, the better off you’ll be over the long run.

Agreed! and its far cheaper spending a bit extra on a lighter bass than it is to visit a chiropractor, massage professional or any other person that can fix your body, after your neck and shoulders become so misaligned from too much weight over a prolonged period of time that you look like Quasimodo ( it happened!). I don’t even consider myself very old or unfit in any way, just a personal preference and belief.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Relayer71 and Yonni
I have a 7.5lb Ibanez jazz that cost around $250 and plays really well but I’d pay $1,000 or more for a Japanese Fender jazz that weighed 8.5lbs if it was the right one. Weight is more of an issue for my shoulder than price by a long way. The difficulty is finding the right weight/tone/neck all in the same bass. This is what gives me GAS.
 
Im a body builder. 9 lbs to 11lbs doesnt make much a difference to me. I guess its all personal preference. I've got a peavey t-40 and bop around dancing with that bass like it's nothing. I never even thought about bass weight until I got on TB. I have no idea what any of my basses weigh and really don't care. they are all light enough for me. ymmv.
 
I’m 65 and was given the genetic gift of degenerative disk disease by my ancestors, so for me, weight matters a great deal. If I play a four set night with my 96 Jazz, I’m lucky if I can feel my fingers at the end of the night. It’s a porker at 9.8lbs. My Dunable is much better at 8.3lbs. and is my daily driver. I’m very much looking forward to receiving my Nordy Acononyx as it’ll be quite a bit lighter.
 
  • Like
Reactions: obimark
So let's say I have three options for three different models same bass. The price I'm giving is including shipping and after any negotiating. All three are new and come with warranty.

Option A: $719 / 11.5 lbs
Option B: $849 / 10.3 lbs
Option C: $875 / 9.4 lbs

Everything else being equal, the only difference is the weight. How important is lightweight to you?

My qualification requirement on a bass lies on whether it’s a good instrument and a useful tool. I understand there are those that have medical issues, and those that have strong preferences. A pound or two either way doesn’t tip the scale for me.
 
As another 60+ player, I won’t be interested in anything in the upper 8 pound range. My fretless 5r is under 8 and it makes a huge difference. When I was younger Weight wasn’t an issue, but now?!? 10 years or so ago I had a Warwick fretless that was close to 11 pounds. It played great and had huge tone but I couldn’t last more than 45 minutes with it around my neck. It’s not so much shoulder pain as it is lower back for me.
 
I care more about the balance of a bass and how comfortable it is personally. Out of the choice I did go the lightest most costly but I wouldn’t consider that light weight. I dong like my basses to be over 10.5 pounds and that’s more out of comfort and what I’m used to.
 
Heavier Basses seem to sound better to me. They seem to sustain better and have better high end. As well of course as a thunderous low end. So when considering a bass I like to feel how solid it feels first. I only play 5 string and of the 4 that I have 3 are heavier than one that I consider light weight. And they definitely sound better despite the quality of the hardware.

Two little words fix everything for me.

Comfort strap.
 
One of the best sounding and playing basses I have ever put my hands on was a friends Travis Bean. The thing was amazing. I’ve owned and played many, many basses over my life and im telling you, it was awesome. I cried when I gave it back to him. I truly loved that bass.

It weighed a metric ton and it was worth every ounce of it. There is a reason they cost as much as they do now.