• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

RANT - String Demo Videos - I WANT FINGERSTYLES

iiipopes

Supporting Member
May 4, 2009
12,891
10,355
I just recently watched a demo video for new La Bella Gold Tapewounds. Good strings.

Now, why, WHY, do demo videos for strings have to be so g@*-*@##^* slap-heavy!!!???

Most bass players still play mostly fingerstyle on the first five frets. Amateur and professional alike. We call it the "cash register" as opposed to the low register of dropped tuning or high register of flailing up the fretboard. Yes, I can do all that too. I refrain from doing it where it is not appropriate, which it is not appropriate more than it is.

I WANT TO HEAR FINGERSTYLES. Yes, that is plural: fingerstyles. Neck or mid pickup alone, bridge pickup alone, blend: Macca, Jamerson, Dunn, C. Kaye, Squire, Entwistle, Jaco, and the rest of the classic rockers and fusion of all decades, fingers and picks. And then there are all the jazz and country bass royalty that are on every album, modestly laying down all the famous lines in those genres, and which I should be able to list their names, but they aren't coming to me right now.

Make no mistake: Larry Graham is a monster of bass playing. Bass playing in general took a quantum leap and a paradigm shift with his playing. But he's not the only one. Bootsy, S. Clarke, etc., all relied on fingers as much as slap.

I AM SICK AND TIRED OF ALL THE DEMO VIDEOS PLAYING SLAP TO THE EXCLUSION OF ALL THE OTHER STYLES, just to make a percussive impression.

PLEASE -- everyone going forward, professionals, string reps, demo auditions, basement tapes, youtube excursions, PLEASE -- balance out the percussion with the styles that define the rest of proper bass playing and lay down the proper foundation and groove for the rest of the styles of music so we really know what those strings sound like.

Thank you.
 
I AM SICK AND TIRED OF ALL THE DEMO VIDEOS PLAYING SLAP TO THE EXCLUSION OF ALL THE OTHER STYLES, just to make a percussive impression.

PLEASE -- everyone going forward, professionals, string reps, demo auditions, basement tapes, youtube excursions, PLEASE -- balance out the percussion with the styles that define the rest of proper bass playing and lay down the proper foundation and groove for the rest of the styles of music so we really know what those strings sound like.

Good to know I'm not the only one who feels this way. ;)
 
Or make just slap video/demos for those that care and then I can pass those by for something more useful. Even some pick style or tapping mixed in to demo versatility, but slap demos for slappers...

But I guess they need to have the 'views' counted, whether they are liked or watched thru or not. 'View' tallies must be another factor of the 'showoff' syndrome.
 
This is exactly why all of our soundclips (that I've made myself) have a RANGE of styles, as we have a range of players.

And RE: demos more about showing off the player over the product, that is a huge thing. I've gotten a lot of great gear from manufacturers mainly by making some demos that don't do anything more than showcase the pedal for what it can - and can't - do. It's definitely a fine line, because you obviously don't want a demo (of anything!) with a poor quality audio or player on it, but at the same time, you need to have it showcased as a "this is what the _________ can do in these situations."
 
This is exactly why all of our soundclips (that I've made myself) have a RANGE of styles, as we have a range of players.

And RE: demos more about showing off the player over the product, that is a huge thing. I've gotten a lot of great gear from manufacturers mainly by making some demos that don't do anything more than showcase the pedal for what it can - and can't - do. It's definitely a fine line, because you obviously don't want a demo (of anything!) with a poor quality audio or player on it, but at the same time, you need to have it showcased as a "this is what the _________ can do in these situations."
Does that mean if they don't use finger style, that particular product isn't good for that :)
 
Does that mean if they don't use finger style, that particular product isn't good for that :)

You can take whatever you want from an omission. Personally, I try to cover as many styles as possible to give the viewer/listener the most information. I've slapped on flats, just so the listener - who may be new to flatwounds - can say "Oh, they doesn't sound as great for that. I may try something else that fits my needs better" over "Wow! Listen to that guy play!"
 
  • Like
Reactions: mrb327
Agreed two fold! And I'll add, I don't like it when the string demo is part of a mix. I don't care how it sounds in a mix someone else made. I can compensate for a lot of things with my hand location, pickup blend, on board tone controls, foot pedals, preamp and cab selection. I don't need to hear it in a mix! Just give me a few open strings, a walking bass line and maybe some harmonics. Save the slapping for a 2 year old brat at Walmart.
 
Ya know what would also be nice? I'd like to take it a step even more simple than finger style. How about single whole note out of each string? I don't know about anyone else, but when I change strings to something I've never tried before, I pluck and open E, A, D and G. It's the most straight forward tone example you can get out of a bass string.

Maybe we need an international minimum standard for bass string testing? It would be nice to be able to truly compare the tones of strings made by different manufacturers. There would need to be a standard test rig (e.g. bass, amp, DI, recording device, settings, etc. etc.) and the primary tests might include open E-A-D-G and scales from x to x. Once minimum standards are covered, feel free to slap yourself silly. I mean, they use international standards to independently verify almost all consumer goods, so why not bass strings as well?

Just an idea.
 

Latest posts