• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Reducing output by removing tubes

WE got WAAAAAY to far into this thread before this suggestion was brought up.

OP, turn the volume DOWN on your BASS. Problem solved. Then you can drive the crap out of the tubes because the input signal is so much weaker.

Could you probably make this amp somewhat workable using all kinds of complicated tricks with your bass dimed? Maybe. But why bother when it is just stupid simple to turn down the bassor run a volume pedal and let the head eat all it wants to?

What kind of bass/pickups do you run that sounds different at different volumes on the bass itself? I have never run into this.
I'm running 2 P-basses. 1 With barts and one with a SPB3. Their volume levels are similar. When rolling volumes on either bass, it changes the character of the sound. I like it wide open and clear. I'm thinking I'm going to try making one of those passive volume controls and run it through my effects chain. That way I get my bass wide open into the gain/pre & can then level it off from there.
 
Darn yous guys - this place is worse than an alcoholic hanging out at the local dive bar ;) .
I ended up ordering a CTM-30 last night:
https://8thstreet.com/Product/Get/70246/ashdown-ctm-30-30-watt-all-tube-bass-amp-head
$459.15 delivered with the 12% off promo code.
There's a nice restored B25B on fleaBay for about the same but I'd rather have new and light. I play a lot of early (Woodstock era) rock when guitars were clean and bass was overdriven through a B15. I normally run my SVT clone with the master on "1" and the gain on 2 o'clock or so.

Not sure how the circuit differs from the LB30 (which I own) but those little Ashdowns are pretty tough. I have only had mine a few weeks and even with the simple control layout I discover new ways to take advantage if this little tube powerhouse every time I sit down at it.

Best of luck with your quest OP.
 
Ah... No... :wacky:

Ah...... Yes. I have never experienced the exact pickups he is using. But I have done this all the time with my passive Fender basses. One Roscoe Beck Sig and one 5 string P bass. I have the LB30 and a Walkabout. I just sold a V4. I also do a lot of daisy chaining channels on an old Fender PA100. And if I want to slightly overdrive at lower volumes, I simply crank up the gain (particularly on my Walkabout which overdrvies the best of these to me) and start with the volume on the bass at zero. I dial up on the bass and down on the gain until I get the overdrive/volume desired. Works great. And I have never noticed a big difference in tone by doing it that way or balls out loud with the volume on the bass pegged and the gain down a bit.
 
It would appear from Traynor's response:

Traynor said:
Hi Andrew. Pulling tubes won't work as the failsafe circuitry will simply kick that pair of tubes out of action and boost voltage to the others to maintain power. It almost sounds as if you'd like some sort of pedal. You might try patching a volume pedal into the effects loop. That way your preamp gain functions normally and you get some control over volume.
Hoping this helps.
Mike Holman\
Yorkville Sound

that Removing tubes from this amp to lessen output power is a bad idea. Unless you are personally trying to support your tube supplier.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BassmanPaul
I'm running 2 P-basses. 1 With barts and one with a SPB3. Their volume levels are similar. When rolling volumes on either bass, it changes the character of the sound. I like it wide open and clear. I'm thinking I'm going to try making one of those passive volume controls and run it through my effects chain. That way I get my bass wide open into the gain/pre & can then level it off from there.

Is there an effect box in your loop that has a volume control? Sounds like it would have essentially the same effect?
 
  • Like
Reactions: rodl2005
It would appear from Traynor's response:

Traynor said:
Hi Andrew. Pulling tubes won't work as the failsafe circuitry will simply kick that pair of tubes out of action and boost voltage to the others to maintain power. It almost sounds as if you'd like some sort of pedal. You might try patching a volume pedal into the effects loop. That way your preamp gain functions normally and you get some control over volume.
Hoping this helps.
Mike Holman\
Yorkville Sound

that Removing tubes from this amp to lessen output power is a bad idea. Unless you are personally trying to support your tube supplier.
Since the OP already tried it and it worked I suspect that Traynor guy was a script reading droid. But in general if you're going to research tube pulling on the internet make sure you have a good pair of muck boots on LOL.
 
Is there an effect box in your loop that has a volume control? Sounds like it would have essentially the same effect?
The only effect I have with a volume control is my Boss DA-2, but the level knob on that thing becomes unclear at low volume, too. I'm going to attempt to just build a passive volume box to run through my effects loop. I have enough spare parts (other than a case) to try this.
 
Since the OP already tried it and it worked I suspect that Traynor guy was a script reading droid. But in general if you're going to research tube pulling on the internet make sure you have a good pair of muck boots on LOL.

Did you read how many the OP had to pull before any real difference was heard? You can close your eyes jumping out of an airplane, but you're still headed for the ground ;)
 
Did you read how many the OP had to pull before any real difference was heard? You can close your eyes jumping out of an airplane, but you're still headed for the ground ;)
The difference between 100 and 300 watts is only 4.77db - and part of that is made up for by the reduced power compression from running the cab at less power. It's absolutely no surprise that pulling only 1/3 of the tubes makes little difference to the ear...