• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Rethinking Black Metal.

Alright so I am a fan of Black Metal, and I feel the genre is misunderstood. So I am here to say a couple things about it, and explain the context in which is should be understood and enjoyed.

Many of the bands that perform the style of Black Metal follow the pagan religions of the early Nordic people of the Scandinavian Peninsula (Asatur for example). When the Christians came to these people they subjected the natives of the land to rape, murder, enslavement, and most importantly forced religious conversion.

This story is explained in "One Rode to Asa Bay" by Bathory.
Bathory - One Rode To Asa Bay - YouTube
BATHORY LYRICS - "Hammerheart" (1990) album

In many pagan religions, following ones heritage is of utmost importance. So though the events happened long ago. For followers of the Pagan religion it is very close to their hearts.

The satanic imagery of Black Metal is often blown off as nothing more than theatrics, and of course for some bands it is only theatrics. However in origin the music was created in opposition to Christian oppression, and the genuine artists used the concept of Satan to express their contempt and displeasure with history. Thus creating a music that was simultaneously political and religious.

Now, many of the artists have tried to explain this. However, understand that this is a pretty complex subject to discuss. Especially when many of the artists do not speak English natively or fluently. Thus what they say sometimes seems nonsensical, or humorous, but in reality it is a language barrier problem.

As a Christian man myself, I do not necessarily agree with the ideologies of black metal. However I do understand it's context and I understand where the bands are coming from.

I just feel like it's often dismissed as either blasphemous or comical. Which is fine and entertaining in it's own right. Yet I feel that the cultural and historical context of the music is often lost. Underneath the corpse-paint there is a serious music and message that should be understood.

Just a point to ponder, and something I wanted to clear up.
 
You've got some good points here about the context in which to examine black metal, but at the same time, I don't think you've addressed some of the most common criticisms of it.
The most common complaints I hear are that the "rules" of the genre are too strict and thus the music and the lyrical content is very similar between albums and between bands. To be accepted by the other bands and the fans of black metal you have to play the drums a certain way, look a certain way, and your lyrics have to be about a limited range of subjects. Thus people view it as sort of a stagnant genre because the "best" black metal albums are just the ones that sound most like the last ones. Now, in the past year or two a number of bands have been trying to rewrite the rules of black metal, or at least trying to mix in some new influences (think Wolves in the Throne Room), but just look at all the backlash Liturgy has gotten from the old guard basically for everything from wearing jeans in concert to doing an all vocal track.

So, I do agree that black metal is misunderstood, and that a lot of people don't give it a fair shake because they are turned off by the perceived anti-chistian content or the corpsepaint. But at the same time, a lot of people give it a spin and still don't find much to like because to a certain degree it does all sound the same. I am happy to see some of the active and exciting black metal bands out there right now are changing that, but it's going to be a long uphill battle.
 
The Nordic countries adopted Christianity over 1K years ago. It's not as if there's a general lingering resentment among the populace. As I see it, it's about certain individuals who have become fascinated by systematic egotists like Crowley and LaVey, and have started bands to disseminate a sociopathic creed with accompanying "ethnic" theatrics. This has been marketable.
 
Thanks for posting the links. I read the lyrics first, then clicked on the YouTube link. I like metal, I've heard of Bathory, and am interested in the politico-religious protest theme, but have never actually listened to them before. Now that I have, sorry, but I was expecting more from this music. IMO the song just drags along, for far too long. Somebody mentioned strict rules, is all Black Metal like this?
 
The Nordic countries adopted Christianity over 1K years ago. It's not as if there's a general lingering resentment among the populace. As I see it, it's about certain individuals who have become fascinated by systematic egotists like Crowley and LaVey, and have started bands to disseminate a sociopathic creed with accompanying "ethnic" theatrics. This has been marketable.

No, the people performing black metal for genuine religious reasons are practicing a religion that has much more in common with Asatru than with LeVeyan Satanism. Ancestory is a massively important component in Asatru, Odinism, and other Scandanavian pagan religions. They don't believe in Satan, but they use Satan to symbolize a counter-Christian sentiment.
 
Thanks for posting the links. I read the lyrics first, then clicked on the YouTube link. I like metal, I've heard of Bathory, and am interested in the politico-religious protest theme, but have never actually listened to them before. Now that I have, sorry, but I was expecting more from this music. IMO the song just drags along, for far too long. Somebody mentioned strict rules, is all Black Metal like this?

Actually though Bathory was originally a Black Metal Band.
Bathory-Enter the Eternal Fire - YouTube

Quorthon had progressed his project to Viking Metal by the time Hammerheart came out, and that album would be classified by most as Viking Metal or Pagan Metal. Kind of like Chuck Schuldiner evolved Death from a Death metal band to a more and more progressive metal as his career went on.

Black Metal is in whats called the third wave, but purists insist that if it doesnt sound 1st wave it isn't true, and some even insist for some idiotic reason that a band must be from Norway to play true black metal. These people are akin to Blues purists who believe you must be an old black man and play only on an acoustic guitar for it to be real blues. Fools in other words.


Centric Elements of Black Metal:
-Usually but not always, lo-fi production
-Simple repetitive guitar and bass parts
-Usually but not always, Blast Beat drum patterns
-Lyric themes consisting of but not limited to: Anti-Christian agenda, Scandinavian Pride, Tolkien Lore, Depression, Hate, and Winter Climate.
-Harsh Vocals.

Examples of Various Black Metal
Purists Black Metal
Mayhem - Deathcrush - YouTube

Depressive Black Metal
Nocturnal Depression - Her Ghost Haunts These Walls

Modern Production Black Metal
Immortal - Tyrants - YouTube

Just some examples to show the range.

And for those interested in Metal Genres:
Map of Metal
 
While it's not a genre I spend much time with, I can appreciate and get into some tracks from time to time. More importantly, to the OP, thank you for posting. Context and reason should always be welcomed - regardless of the subject. Every scene has its purists, and too often they are responsible to the most misunderstanding, and almost always responsible for segregations.
 
No, the people performing black metal for genuine religious reasons are practicing a religion that has much more in common with Asatru than with LeVeyan Satanism. Ancestory is a massively important component in Asatru, Odinism, and other Scandanavian pagan religions. They don't believe in Satan, but they use Satan to symbolize a counter-Christian sentiment.

Well, I think you're romanticizing all this. As a Scandinavian myself, I don't see any ancient religions being practiced here, even on the level of Wicca in the UK. What I do see is certain eccentric personalities making a hodgepodge of Nordic mythology, occult lore and racism, and selling this to the world by playing in rock bands. I've encountered several of these personages backstage on festivals, and the only thing they seem to do religiously is drinking beer.
 
The rule of black metal is as follows...

The spikiness and illegibility of your logo shall be directly proportional to the ridiculousness of your corpsepaint and inversely proportional to the quality of your drum sound.

There you go.

Actually, I love Bathory. The gatefold centre of the Blood, Fire, Death album is highly evocative. As for that whole Marduk and Dimmu Borgir thing...well the drumming never ceases to amaze me but that's about it.

I also love Darkthrone...do they count?
 
There is an unfortunate tie between racial pride and racial hatred. Not that they can't be separated on paper (online), but that in actual practice far too many people slide fast down that slippery slope.

Of course you can find strong negative content in other genres (metal or not), but almost no other genre is as explicitly tied to one hateful issue, as Black Metal is to violent racism.
 
cdef said:
Well, I think you're romanticizing all this. As a Scandinavian myself, I don't see any ancient religions being practiced here, even on the level of Wicca in the UK. What I do see is certain eccentric personalities making a hodgepodge of Nordic mythology, occult lore and racism, and selling this to the world by playing in rock bands. I've encountered several of these personages backstage on festivals, and the only thing they seem to do religiously is drinking beer.

:-)
 
Of course you can find strong negative content in other genres (metal or not), but almost no other genre is as explicitly tied to one hateful issue, as Black Metal is to violent racism.

I'm sorry, but where the hell do you get that from? I'm fully aware that there are certain bands that play so called "national-socialist black metal" (oh, the irony...), but they are such a marginal part of the scene they should not even be counted. None of them have made any important contributions to the scene musically.
 
I'm sorry, but where the hell do you get that from?

Just every single article I've ever seen on the subject, plus news reports about violent acts, plus reading blog and forum posts from Black Metal fans that are not "apologists" for the genre...

Basically from almost every single media reference I've seen since the genre first became known in the West. The only exception I can think of from non-apologists is the Vegan Black Metal Chef.

Which means even if I'm wrong, and even if those reports and forum posts are overblown or inaccurate, they make it clear that the question "where the hell do you get that from" is pretty silly.