• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Review: GHS Balanced Nickels 4M-NB

For the stainless steel players, like me, GHS does not plan to release a SS version of these strings in the immediate future. When I heard of these strings I sent an email to GHS asking about SS, and got a response the next day stating that, since nickel out sells stainless by 20 to 1, they are only releasing nickel for now.

Yep, I answered that one. I'm still shocked at how much nickel strings outsell stainless.


Yeah, that’s great...but they have only offered one winding length that is too short to fit on my string-through-body basses. I wish they offered the extra long length like they do with P-Flats. In the meantime I’ll stick with Sunbeams...maybe GHS will stop making all their sets just for Fender...not everyone plays a Fender.

I know we've talked about this before, and I'm sorry the 37.25" winding length doesn't work for you. Does your bass have a top-load option on the bass in addition to string-thru?

True, not everyone plays a Fender (like myself). But the 37.25" fits a lot more non-Fender basses than you may think.


How would one make a SS version of a pure nickel string? Asking for a friend. ;)

It was the balanced construction (where each string has two wraps, and is balanced tension) that he was asking about, as in "would there be a Balanced Steels set in the future?"
 
Like to hear how they compare to the D'Addario XLs

I'm looking forward to a shoot out as well. The GHS BT set (44-60-80-106) nickel over round core vs D'A BT set (45-60-80-107) nickel over hex core should be a pretty close apples to apples comparison. Based on the OP's review I suspect the D'A set will have a little more bite out of the box. Should be interesting.

Disclosure: I've been using the D'A balanced XLs for several years now. Also use D'As coated XLs (EXP nickel) and build my own balanced sets from BSO. So yes, looking forward to a head to head comparison with the new GHS strings.
 
Love how Jon says he doesn't play a Fender, then posts a video of himself....playing a Fender :)

Sorry man, got to give you a hard time!!

You mean the bass I built from parts, one of which is a Mighty Mite neck someone relic’d and put a water slide decal on?

Yeah, totally not a Fender.

Now, while I have some Fenders in the office (for obvious reasons), my main bass is a med scale Hilton 5st, which these strings don’t work on.
 
The GHS BT set (44-60-80-106) nickel over round core vs D'A BT set (45-60-80-107) nickel over hex core should be a pretty close apples to apples comparison.

Pure nickel over round core vs. Nickel-plated-steel over hex core - it's more like apples-to-pears comparison. I have used the D'A EXL170BT set and these two are not even close.
 
The GHS BT set (44-60-80-106) nickel over round core vs D'A BT set (45-60-80-107) nickel over hex core should be a pretty close apples to apples comparison.

Yeah, no.

Aside from what was already mentioned, the D'A BT set still uses 1 cover for the G string and 3 covers for the E string, whereas the Balanced Nickels use 2 covers on all four strings. Different construction, not to mention materials that are different as well.

An apples/apples comparison would be between the D'A set and our Bassics in 44-58-80-106.
 
Oh no, I'll definitely be getting some anyway. Love GHS Precision flats, and I love Nickel Roundwounds (only roundwounds I like are nickel). So I'm sure I'll like these, and get used to the wimpy G.

What color are the silks?

I have the light set with the 40-G, which is anything but "wimpy". In fact, it's rather shocking how good a 40-G can sound with an innovative design such as these. The best 40 I've ever played by a mile.

ObUIWdhKu6MSIxWRFaKZk-SES_B10CGnB_DHhfEOkN2dwOVMJ-Rw9kNIk7Kuc8etne1dvkzfcZ2tF5LC2wg=w800-h449-no.jpg